Some of the tiniest objects from the first villages in the Middle East carry the smudged fingerprints of kids. Under a microscope, a team of archaeologists found adult and child prints pressed into 15,000-year-old clay birds, gazelles and human figures, and concluded that children helped make what may be the region’s earliest clay figurines.
Laurent Davin of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem led the work, published on Nov. 11 in the open-access journal PLOS One. He said in a press release: “What is particularly fascinating is the evidence that children were involved in making these objects.”
A hundred and fifty fragments from forager villages
The clay comes from Natufian communities, a hunter-gatherer culture that was among the first to live in permanent or semi-permanent villages in Southwest Asia. According to the release, the pieces date to between about 15,000 and 11,500 years ago and were excavated at three sites in modern-day Israel, including Eynan-Mallaha and Nahal Ein Gev II in the Upper Jordan Valley. A summary in Archaeology Magazine’s news site lists the three sites differently, naming Eynan-Mallaha, Hayonim Terrace and el-Wad Terrace, so the exact site list is worth checking against the paper itself.
The team went back through fragments that earlier excavators had overlooked. By that account the sample came to 154 clay pieces, of which 15 are clear figurines and 139 are cylinder-shaped fragments thought to be parts of larger figures.
Until now, Natufian figurines were mostly carved from bone or stone, and clay figurines were thought to become common only with the Neolithic, around 11,500 years ago. The authors argue that the seeds of Neolithic culture were sown before the agricultural revolution. The PLOS press release calls the objects “the earliest known example of a tradition of making clay figurines in the Middle East.”
Mostly birds, in clay
Eleven of the 15 figurines depict birds, according to the Archaeology Magazine summary; the rest include a mammal, a gazelle and two human forms. Some birds are simple shapes while others have carefully marked wings, tails and feathers. Several resemble ducks or geese, others appear to be birds of prey, and a few have heads tilted down and turned left, a pose the team links to duck courtship in breeding season.
The release adds that one piece shows a human interacting with a bird, and that one fragment may show the facial pattern of a mountain gazelle. Some pieces carry traces of orange or red coloring. A figurine dated to about 15,000 years ago has engobe, a thin layer of colored clay, which the summary describes as the earliest known use of the technique.
Fingerprint ridges as the evidence for children
The child-and-adult claim rests on the prints. Ridge spacing on a fingerprint varies with age and sex, which lets analysts estimate who handled the clay. Science News reported that about 60 of the pieces preserved fingerprints, that most pieces were under 2 centimeters long, and that the prints point mostly to women and children, with only a few sets from men. Some of the children were likely younger than 10.
One tiny human torso dated to about 14,500 years ago bears two overlapping prints: one from a young adult or adult woman and one from a child who had not reached puberty. In the Archaeology Magazine account, the figure appears to have passed between the two while they worked. Davin told Science News that the children’s role was not necessarily to learn to make figurines, and he suspects the figures may have represented stories.
Concrete evidence of children’s involvement in prehistoric art has been hard to find. Science News cited two older candidates, child-sized handprints in roughly 200,000-year-old rock art in Tibet and child-sized fingerprints on clay sculptures about 30,000 years old in the Czech Republic. Steven Dorland of Grand Valley State University, who has studied children’s fingerprints on Great Lakes pottery, called the intergenerational learning evidence “fascinating” and said it shows how much researchers can learn by looking beyond adult males.
Open questions in the PLOS One paper
The full study, titled “Modelling symbols among the first-sedentary communities: Emergence of clay figurines in Epipaleolithic Southwest Asia,” is catalogued as PLOS One 21(11): e0360388 and is also reachable through a free-access link. Authors include Davin, M. Sindel, M. Weinstein-Evron, R. Yeshurun, D. Kaufman and L. Grosman, with researchers working in Israel and France. The release is labeled an observational study.
The funding list is long, from the Israel Science Foundation and the Wenner-Gren Foundation to the National Geographic Foundation. No competing interests were declared.
Davin framed the larger stakes in the same release: “These discoveries change how [people] understand the beginnings of artistic expression in the first villages of humanity.” Whether the child makers were apprentices, storytellers or simply playing is the question the clay cannot answer, and Davin’s own suggestion, that the figures carried stories, remains an interpretation rather than a finding.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part