Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Hidden card skimmers on gas pumps and ATMs can be exposed with one quick shake

The card reader at a gas pump or a bank ATM looks like every other card reader, and that sameness is what a skimmer is built to exploit. A device bolted on top can copy a card’s magnetic stripe, while a tiny camera or keypad overlay captures the PIN. Police in South Burlington, Vermont, gave a local TV station a free test in August: reach up and shake the reader before inserting a card, because if it moves, something is going on.

The advice came in an Aug. 4 report by WCAX reporter Lizzie Jensen, built around interviews with the town’s deputy police chief, the state attorney general and the head of AARP Vermont. Its central tip is simple enough to try at any pump, though the FBI’s own description of skimming shows where the test stops working.

Where skimmers turn up and what they look like

South Burlington Deputy Police Chief Sean Briscoe told WCAX that the targets are normally “gas pumps, ATMs,” meaning any machine where a customer deals with a device rather than a person. The common thread is the absence of an attendant, which gives an installer time to attach hardware and walk away. The station’s report added that, according to the FBI, card skimming costs financial institutions and consumers more than $1 billion a year.

The devices come in two broad forms, per Briscoe: “a hidden camera that looks at the keypad or even a keypad overlay.” The overlay sits on top of the real keypad and records presses. The camera watches the PIN being typed. Either one can pair with a card-reading unit disguised to look like the machine’s own reader. Local reports are not common, Briscoe said, but the threat is not confined to big cities: “It is fairly common nationally, and if it happens around the country, it very well could happen here.”

What a shake can and cannot reveal

A shake test is aimed at the part of the scheme that is physically attached to the machine. A skimmer fitted over a genuine reader tends to be held on with adhesive or clips, so a loose, wobbling or shifting reader is a warning sign. That is the logic behind the police advice, and it costs a few seconds.

The limits are worth stating plainly. An FBI feature on an ATM skimming case explains that skimming “typically requires two devices to be installed on an ATM or other card reader”: one captures data from the magnetic stripe and a pinhole camera records PINs as they are entered. The Bureau adds that some devices use Bluetooth, so criminals can retrieve data remotely, and that devices are typically left for about a day before being collected. A pinhole camera mounted above or beside a keypad will not wobble when a reader is shaken, which is why the FBI also tells people to cover the keypad when typing a PIN.

FBI Special Agent Paul Scuzzarella said in that feature that ATMs in main, visible areas are less likely to have been tampered with than those tucked away, and that anyone who notices anything unusual should not use the machine. “If it’s in the main area, it’s less likely someone has tampered with that,” he said.

Credit card protections after a skimming loss

Vermont Attorney General Charity Clark told the station that paying with a credit card is “always a very good way to pay for things because there are those consumer protections built in,” and that a cardholder can start what she called a chargeback to get the money back. Her remarks pointed to a federal system that has been in place for decades.

Under the FTC’s guidance on disputing credit card charges, federal law limits responsibility for unauthorized charges to $50. A written dispute has to reach the issuer within 60 days after the first bill containing the error was sent. The issuer must acknowledge it in writing within 30 days and resolve it within 90 days, and a cardholder can withhold the disputed amount while the issuer investigates.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s explanation of billing disputes advises calling the card company right away and following up with a written notice within 60 calendar days of the charge appearing on the statement. A debit card connected directly to a checking account is a different matter, since the money has already left the account. Reviewing statements regularly, the habit WCAX’s report recommends, is what catches a stray charge inside that 60-day window.

Capital One’s skimmer guide adds checks that go beyond the shake: look for a reader or keypad that bulges or sits out of alignment, compare a pump with its neighbors, inspect the security seal near the reader, and look above the reader for tiny holes that could hide a pinhole camera. It also suggests paying inside at gas stations, using a pump in the attendant’s view, or tapping a contactless card or mobile wallet instead of swiping.

AARP Vermont director Greg Marchildon told the station that older residents who did not grow up with smartphones are a worry, and that a removed skimmer leaves little evidence: “There’s no fingerprints, no nothing. It’s been removed and taken away.” That detail answers a question the police test cannot, which is how many skimmers are installed and removed without anyone noticing. No public tally of such devices accompanies the WCAX report.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview


Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.