Shortly after 4 a.m. local time on November 17, the ground shook across the islands of eastern Indonesia, from Tual and Saumlaki to Sorong and Manokwari on New Guinea. The source was deep beneath the Banda Sea, and within minutes the two agencies that track it had published different answers to the most basic question: how big was it?
Read next on Morning Overview: Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman
The U.S. Geological Survey put the earthquake at magnitude 6.6. Indonesia’s Meteorology, Climatology and Geophysical Agency, known as BMKG, said 7.1. Both agreed on the time, and both concluded that the quake posed little danger to the people who felt it.
Magnitude 6.6 by one count, 7.1 by the other
According to The Watchers’ report, the quake struck 148 kilometers (92 miles) west-southwest of Tual at 21:11 UTC on November 16. The USGS event page lists it as an M 6.6 at a depth of 68 kilometers, and the agency’s reviewed event record shows the magnitude type as Mww, a moment magnitude calculated from the waveforms of the shaking, with the epicenter at 6.08 degrees south and 131.49 degrees east.
BMKG recorded the same origin time, 04:11:20 Western Indonesia Time, but placed the event about 130 kilometers southwest of Maluku Tenggara at a depth of 115 kilometers, with a magnitude of 7.1. Its felt-earthquake bulletin lists weak shaking at intensity III in Saumlaki, Tiakur, Dobo, Sorong, Manokwari, South Manokwari, Bintuni, Tual, Fakfak and Kaimana, and intensity II in Nabire and Serui.
A half-unit gap is larger than it sounds. Magnitude scales are logarithmic: as the Pacific Northwest Seismic Network explains, Charles Richter built the original scale on the logarithm of recorded wave amplitude because the range of amplitudes was so large, so that in his example a 10 mm trace was a magnitude 2 and a 100 mm trace a magnitude 3. The two agencies’ depths also differ by 47 kilometers, a large disagreement for an event both located within minutes.
Why two agencies can measure the same quake differently
Disagreements like this are routine in the first hours after a large earthquake. The USGS explains that “fundamentally different calculation methods are specified by magnitude type,” and that differences “generally arise due to the use of different Earth models, data availability and data processing.” An agency using its own national network close to the event will see different stations, and model the crust differently, from one working from a global network.
Numbers also move as analysis improves. The USGS says changes in its preferred magnitude in the minutes and hours after a significant quake often reflect a switch to a different magnitude type or the addition of more data. Its record for this event is marked as reviewed, meaning an analyst has checked the automatic solution, and it was last updated hours after the shaking stopped.
The USGS solution rests on a large data set. Its event record lists 129 seismic stations used to locate the quake, an azimuthal gap of 21 degrees, meaning stations surrounded the source on nearly all sides, and a suite of products including a moment tensor, a ShakeMap, a ground-failure estimate and a PAGER loss assessment. BMKG, for its part, works from Indonesia’s national network, which sits much closer to the epicenter.
Green alert, no tsunami, weak shaking in coastal towns
On impact, the two agencies agreed. The USGS issued a Green alert under its PAGER system for shaking-related fatalities and economic losses, indicating a low likelihood of casualties and damage. It estimated that about 8,100 people were exposed to moderate shaking at intensity 5, a similar number at intensity 4, and no one to intensity 6 or above. Its record also lists the event as having no tsunami flag.
BMKG said the earthquake did not have tsunami potential, a key statement in a region where coastal communities rely on the agency’s warnings. Only 10 people had filed felt reports with the USGS by the time its record was last updated, a reflection of how remote the epicenter is. Those reports put the highest community intensity at 3.4, while the USGS ShakeMap model estimated peak shaking of about 5.4 on the Modified Mercalli scale, consistent with the moderate-but-not-damaging picture in the PAGER estimate. The USGS record was last revised a little more than eight hours after the quake, with the magnitude still at 6.6.
For residents, the practical takeaway is the one both agencies delivered within minutes: weak to moderate shaking, no tsunami threat and a low likelihood of damage. The towns that felt it stretch from the Tanimbar and Kei islands to the Bird’s Head of New Guinea, a spread that reflects how far shaking from a deep event can travel. Whether the final catalog value lands at 6.6, 7.1 or somewhere between will depend on further review, but neither agency has reported damage from the November 16 quake.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part