Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Palisades’ restart is stalled by a tipped fuel assembly and a ‘chilled work environment’

Fuel has been loaded into the reactor at Palisades, the Lake Michigan plant that Holtec International is trying to bring back from decommissioning, but the plant is not producing electricity. Two separate problems stand in the way of a clean restart.

Read next on Morning Overview: Up to 5 feet of snow is burying Donner Pass, and forecasters warn against Sierra travel

One fuel assembly tipped over after Aug. 30 while new fuel was being lowered into the core. Weeks later, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission reported that a “chilled work environment” exists in two departments at the Covert Township site, and Holtec answered with a worker-safety plan on Nov. 19.

The assembly that tipped

According to The National’s Oct. 16 report, one fuel assembly tipped while the new fuel was being loaded, and the planned restart was put on hold. The NRC said no radiation was released.

The commission has since allowed Holtec to retrieve the assembly, with NRC specialists and resident inspectors watching the removal. If retrieval succeeds, the same report says, the restart is likely to continue under NRC oversight.

Critics are less sanguine. Arnie Gundersen, an adviser to the group Don’t Waste Michigan, told the outlet that a later NRC report found the assembly has “significant bowing.” A Holtec spokesperson said the plant will return to service once all required work and federal requirements are met, and the company has not published a restart timeline.

What inspectors found in the supply chain and quality departments

The second problem began with an NRC inspection in July. In an Oct. 13 letter and report to Fadi Diya, Holtec’s chief nuclear officer, the commission wrote that “a Chilled Work Environment exists in two specific departments: supply chain and quality assurance,” according to Nuclear News as republished by the American Nuclear Society. The NRC defines the term as a setting where the “willingness of a group of employees to report safety or regulatory concerns is inhibited.”

No violations were identified. The same inspection concluded that “most personnel felt free to raise nuclear safety concerns without fear of retaliation” across the site.

Inside the two departments the picture was different. Some employees hesitated to use available channels, including the NRC itself, which the report attributes largely to fear of retaliation, “including the possibility of termination.” The chill reached the corrective action program and the employee concerns program, and managers at multiple levels “may not always be receptive” to what workers raise. Employees named procurement and qualification of equipment, and whether quality assurance can operate independently, as areas where speaking up felt unsafe.

Other threads ran through the report. Some workers perceived that management emphasized production and would listen mainly to safety issues touching restart work. Line staff had little trouble going to immediate supervisors, but turnover and reorganizations left some unsure whom to approach higher up. Work planning, coordination and schedule adherence also drew criticism, with the report saying they had “resulted in unpredictable schedule changes.”

The NRC still said it remained confident in Holtec’s ability to restart the plant and called the issues “isolated.” Holtec told the American Nuclear Society’s publication that it takes the findings seriously.

Holtec’s 30-day answer

The commission gave Holtec 30 days to submit its plan. Michigan Public reported on Nov. 19 that Diya wrote that the company “fully recognize[s] the significance of the NRC’s conclusion” that employees may hold back for fear of retaliation.

The steps so far are modest and visible: more communication with staff in the two departments, town hall meetings, posted signs encouraging reports, and video and audio messages from senior leaders. The larger piece is an independent assessment team that will interview workers and recommend changes. The plan says “Evaluators will be independent of the affected departments and of decisions under review,” and that site personnel may supply coordination and records but “will not control interview selection,” join confidential interviews or alter the team’s findings.

Interviews are scheduled for December, a report for January and follow-up with workers for February.

A plant with fuel and no output

The NRC’s power reactor status report for Nov. 20 lists Palisades at 0% power. Michigan Public describes the plant as now in operating status with fuel loaded; it stopped operating in 2022 and, if it restarts, would be the first U.S. plant to return after entering decommissioning. A World Nuclear News item puts the reactor at 805 MWe.

A $1.5 billion federal loan is helping fund the effort, and Michigan Public says the restart has been pushed back a year while workers meet regulations. A sidebar to that story points to an Oct. 29 report in which Energy Secretary Chris Wright said the plant could restart as soon as the end of November. The Nov. 20 status shows no output.

The work-culture question is not new at the site. The National notes that a 2012 NRC report raised concerns about Palisades’ work culture, and that in October 2025 a worker fell from a refueling bridge into a pool of water and was not seriously hurt. Whether the independent team’s January report finds the same fear of retaliation the NRC described in July is the next measurable test.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.