Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Back-to-back California quakes, and what the USGS says about the risk of a bigger one

Two California earthquakes struck less than five hours apart, one near a national park in the Central Coast ranges and one beneath an industrial stretch of Los Angeles County, and the obvious question followed: is something bigger on the way? The U.S. Geological Survey’s own forecasts put the odds of a stronger shock after the Pinnacles quake at about 1.8% for the coming week.

Read next on Morning Overview: Hidden wear was found inside a New Jersey nuclear reactor during its outage

The first quake, a magnitude 4.98 that rounds to 5.0, hit at 10:49 p.m. Pacific time on Thursday, Nov. 19, about 6 miles northwest of Pinnacles in San Benito County, at a depth near 4 miles. About 10,000 people reported light to moderate shaking, and the ShakeAlert early warning system was activated, according to a Nacionale rundown of the USGS data. The second, a magnitude 4.2, struck at 3:25 a.m. on Friday, Nov. 20, roughly 0.6 miles northwest of Commerce, about 250 miles southeast of the first. More than 13,000 people reported feeling it.

USGS one-week aftershock odds

For Pinnacles, the USGS forecast issued on Nov. 20 gave about a 74% chance of at least one aftershock of magnitude 3 or larger over a week, about 1.8% for magnitude 5 or larger, about 0.18% for magnitude 6 or larger and about 0.02% for magnitude 7 or larger. The chance of a quake larger than the 4.98 mainshock was also about 1.8%.

The Los Angeles forecast, created later that day, was lower across the board: about 27% for a magnitude 3 or larger, 3.6% for a magnitude 4 or larger, 0.38% for magnitude 5 or larger and 0.04% for magnitude 6 or larger. The odds of anything larger than the 4.2 mainshock came to about 2.3%.

These are not predictions in the everyday sense. The USGS operational aftershock forecast overview describes them as situational awareness after a significant earthquake, estimating how many smaller aftershocks may be felt, the probability of damaging magnitude 5 or larger aftershocks, and the chance of future magnitude 6 or 7 earthquakes. Forecasts run for one day, one week, one month and one year, and they are updated because aftershock rates change over time.

How a forecast gets built

The USGS says the forecasts use either the Reasenberg-Jones model or the Epidemic-Type Aftershock Sequence model, each with one of three parameter sets: generic values drawn from past sequences in similar tectonic settings, values fit to the current sequence, or a Bayesian blend of the two. Early forecasts lean on the mainshock magnitude, so the agency waits at least 20 minutes after an event before issuing one, letting the magnitude estimate settle.

The same overview notes that forecasts are posted for magnitude 4 or larger earthquakes in the contiguous United States. That threshold explains why both the 5.0 and the 4.2 received one, and why a quake of 3.5 would not.

A likely culprit under Commerce

The Commerce quake likely occurred on the Puente Hills thrust fault system, according to the Nacionale account of the USGS findings, a wording that stops short of a confirmed attribution. Mayor Karen Bass reported no operational impacts, including at LAX, and no serious injuries or major damage were immediately reported.

The two quakes sit hundreds of miles apart. Nothing in the sources read for this article links them as parts of one sequence, and the pair appears to be a coincidence of timing rather than a cascade. The Nacionale piece relays one line from the USGS on that point: “neither it nor any other scientists have ever predicted a major earthquake.”

The 30-year picture is a different number

Long-term odds are a separate calculation from aftershock odds, and the two are easy to confuse. The Nacionale report cites the Uniform California Earthquake Rupture Forecast, version 3, for a 30-year window: for the Los Angeles area, 60% for a magnitude 6.7, 46% for a magnitude 7 and 31% for a magnitude 7.5, and for the San Francisco Bay Area, 72%, 51% and 20% for the same three sizes.

UCERF3 comes from the California Geological Survey, working with the USGS and the Southern California Earthquake Center. Statewide, it put the chance of a magnitude 8 or larger quake in 30 years at about 7.0%, up from about 4.7% in the earlier version, and cut the expected rate of magnitude 6.7 events from one per 4.8 years to one per 6.3 years.

Lead author Ned Field attributed the rise in great-quake odds to a modeling change in the USGS release announcing UCERF3 on March 10, 2015: “The new likelihoods are due to the inclusion of possible multi-fault ruptures.” The accompanying USGS fact sheet adds a blunt sentence, “damaging earthquakes are inevitable for California,” a statement about the decades ahead rather than the next week.

Whether either quake gets an aftershock above magnitude 5 will be visible in the USGS forecasts as they are revised, and the Pinnacles figure of 1.8% was a snapshot from Nov. 20 that falls or rises with each update.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.