Three people ran USS South Dakota’s day-to-day life, and on Oct. 14 all three were removed. The commanding officer, the executive officer and the chief of the boat of the Virginia-class attack submarine were relieved, and for about a month the House Armed Services Committee heard nothing about it.
Read next on Morning Overview: California’s Long Valley supervolcano is quietly sinking, its biggest drop on record
Two House Democrats made the lapse public on Nov. 12 in a letter to the Navy’s civilian and uniformed leaders. Their question, still unanswered in public, is what happened to the boat and whether it was hurt.
The command triad and who they were
USNI News reported that Cmdr. Daniel Goodwin was relieved as commanding officer. Goodwin had taken over in June 2026 from Cmdr. Burnes C.W. Brown at Naval Submarine Base New London in Groton, Connecticut. A defense official confirmed the removals to the outlet, and a Navy spokesperson acknowledged the question without an immediate comment.
Stripes named the other two: Lt. Cmdr. Jacqueline Penichet, the executive officer, and Senior Chief Information Systems Technician (Submarines) Jon Nogaj, the chief of the boat. The public affairs office for Commander, Submarine Force Atlantic confirmed Goodwin’s removal and cited a “loss of confidence in his ability to fulfill his assigned duties.” Stripes found no separate Navy statement on the other two.
Task & Purpose, citing The Day of New London, said Goodwin assumed command on June 30, 2026. South Dakota, hull number SSN 790, was commissioned in 2019 and belongs to Submarine Squadron 4.
What is known about the grounding
The word “grounding” comes from the lawmakers and from sources, not from a Navy statement. USNI’s updated report said a source described the removals as following a soft grounding involving the submarine’s rudder, and added that it was unclear whether the boat was damaged. The Navy has not published an account. Maritime Executive, in its Nov. 12 report, said the Navy confirmed Goodwin’s removal for “loss of confidence” but did not confirm a grounding or the dismissal of the executive officer and chief of the boat. The outlet attributed the September timing of the grounding to sources.
The Day, as relayed by Stripes, reported an “immediate navigational hazard” in September when the submarine descended toward shallow water. The evidence is a commendation: on Oct. 6, Electronics Technician Navigation Seaman Ben Boyce received a Navy and Marine Corps Commendation signed by Capt. Thomas Flaherty, commodore of Submarine Squadron 4. The certificate says Boyce, a fathometer operator, “recognized the rate of shoaling water presented an immediate navigational hazard to the ship.” His family posted it on Oct. 23, the day after the submarine returned to its Groton homeport.
Stripes was careful to note that its reporting does not confirm the hazard led to the firings, and that the lawmakers themselves asked about a “grounding or other mishap at sea.” The firing date and the sailor’s commendation are the two documented points; the connection between them rests on reporting.
The lawmakers’ letter and the unanswered deadline
Rep. Joe Courtney of Connecticut, ranking member of the House Seapower and Projection Forces Subcommittee, and Rep. Adam Smith of Washington, ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee, wrote to Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao and Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Daryl Caudle.
“The Department of the Navy’s failure to communicate these incidents to Congress is unacceptable,” the letter says, per USNI. The pair said they learned of the relief from a reporter’s request for comment, not from the Navy, and that the committee had received no notification of the firings or the incident roughly a month later.
Courtney said the Armed Services Committee is routinely notified when a command triad is removed after a serious mishap, according to Maritime Executive, and that no such notice came here. The outlet also noted that under Goodwin’s predecessor the crew had earned a Battle “E” for readiness and a “Hook-Em” award for anti-submarine warfare.
The letter lists what the Navy has not explained: what happened, the effects on the submarine’s “structural health” and the crew’s well-being, and whether training to standard procedures showed systemic problems. It also says the silence has damaged the Navy’s relationship with Congress. Stripes reported that the lawmakers asked for answers by Nov. 20, a date that has now passed; no public Navy reply turned up in the sources reviewed for this article.
The Navy has handled surface-ship groundings in public before. On July 8, 2024, 6th Fleet relieved Capt. Lenard C. Mitchell, commanding officer of the expeditionary sea base USS Hershel “Woody” Williams, two months after the ship soft-grounded near Libreville, Gabon, on May 9. 6th Fleet cited “a loss of confidence in his ability to command” and said that “sufficient findings of fact emerged during the investigation to warrant the relief,” with no injuries or major damage reported. In South Dakota’s case, the Navy’s own statement so far covers only one of the three removals.
Whether South Dakota is sidelined for repairs, whether an investigation has concluded, and whether the shoaling incident was the trigger for the Oct. 14 removals all remain open. Courtney and Smith’s deadline passed with the Navy’s explanation still unpublished.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Czech Skyfox jets could become Ukraine’s cheap answer to Shahed attack drones
- A windstorm slammed western Washington, blocking I-5 and knocking out power for thousands
- Tesla’s Cybercab has already crashed 8 times, and the worst one came at highway speed
- Hidden wear was found inside a New Jersey nuclear reactor during its outage