The Altar Stone at Stonehenge weighs about 6 tons, and a new geological study says none of the Scottish locations examined so far have the same set of characteristics. Duncan Pirrie of the University of South Wales led the work, which reopens the question of where the central slab was quarried.
The tech news worth your time: 400,000+ professionals from Google, Apple and OpenAI read Techpresso, a daily email with the most interesting tech news and insights.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
A 2024 paper had proposed the Orcadian Basin in northeast Scotland, a source some 700 kilometers or more from the monument. The new paper does not dismiss the dating behind that claim. It argues that age data on mineral grains cannot settle provenance alone.
Six Scottish areas and the tests that failed them
The study, published in the Journal of the Geological Society, compares the stone’s sedimentology, petrography, mineralogy, geochemistry and isotopes with candidate rocks. As Sci.News reported on Nov. 5, the Scottish areas covered were Orkney, Caithness, the Moray Firth and Shetland, all within the Orcadian Basin, plus the Southern Uplands and the Midland Valley. Each failed on different grounds. Old Red Sandstone in Orkney, Caithness, the Moray Firth and Shetland contains little chrome spinel, a mineral the Altar Stone carries. Clay values below 10 percent exclude Caithness and Orkney. The Southern Uplands are ruled out because the stone lacks the low-grade metamorphism found there, and the Midland Valley fails on its abundance of rock fragments. Four of the six areas named sit inside the Orcadian Basin, the region the 2024 team had already pointed to. The study reports that the examined parts of those areas do not match the stone, so the most consequential result in the paper cuts against the best-known proposed source, even though the basin as a whole is not abandoned.
Baryte, spinel and clay as the stone’s fingerprint
The authors point to a distinctive mix in the slab: baryte, chrome spinel, illite and smectite clay, and a rare clay mineral called tosudite. A match must reproduce all of them together. Lead author Pirrie put it plainly, saying that so far none of the locations examined share the Altar Stone’s full set of characteristics. Baryte is a barium sulfate mineral, and tosudite is a clay that blends two clay types, which is why a rock carrying both alongside chrome spinel is a narrow target. At about 6 tons and roughly 4.9 meters long, the slab was also no casual import: wherever it came from, moving it took a deliberate haul. Earlier work had already removed West Wales and the Anglo-Welsh Basin from contention, and the stone is estimated at roughly 4.9 meters long. The authors still accept a Laurentian, meaning ancient North American-linked, origin for the heavy minerals, which is why the search remains in Scotland even though the specific outcrop is unidentified.
Provenance work of this kind eliminates candidates one at a time. Each test in the paper, from clay percentage to metamorphic grade, works as a gate, and a source must pass every gate rather than most of them. Of the Scottish areas named, none has cleared them all in the data reported so far, which is the study’s central finding and the reason a firmly located quarry cannot yet be claimed.
From the 2020 study to the 2024 Curtin claim
Richard Bevins of Aberystwyth University, a co-author, said earlier research overturned the old assumption of a Welsh source and pointed to Scotland as the likeliest origin. That 2020 work appeared in the Journal of Archaeological Science. Then a team led by Anthony Clarke of Curtin University used the ages of tiny mineral grains to conclude, in a study covered by Sci.News in 2024, that the stone came from the Orcadian Basin and traveled about 700 kilometers or more. The two accounts also differ on distance. The 2024 coverage gave at least 750 kilometers, and the 2026 report gives 700 kilometers or more, and the 2024 article placed the transport around 2600 BCE. Either figure implies a journey across most of Britain, which is why the origin question matters for understanding how Neolithic communities moved heavy stone. The disagreement is about method rather than direction. Grain ages can say a rock belongs to a broad basin; the Pirrie team says the finer chemistry and texture should match too, and those tests have not found a quarry. Nick Pearce, also of Aberystwyth, said every eliminated location narrows the search and brings the team closer to the answer.
The Sci.News report names only Pirrie, Bevins and Pearce, so the full author roster sits in the journal record. Two lines of evidence, grain ages and bulk mineral and clay chemistry, now point at the same general region but not the same outcrop, and neither side calls the other’s data wrong. Reconciling them most likely means sampling more outcrops, the stepwise elimination Pearce described.
The unresolved piece is the outcrop itself. With the Orcadian Basin areas, the Southern Uplands and the Midland Valley all failing at least one test, the researchers have not named a replacement, and the full paper is available at its DOI record for anyone checking the sampling.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
The tech news worth your time: Subscribe to Techpresso →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Two passengers died at an Ohio toll plaza, and the NTSB now wants the cash lanes shut
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
- Hybrids have 15% fewer problems than gas cars, while EVs and plug-in hybrids have about 80% more, Consumer Reports finds