A used car can look like a bargain until the first big repair bill arrives. Mechanics see the same problems again and again, from oil-burning engines to transmissions that shudder and fail. These are the used cars, SUVs and pickups that people who fix vehicles for a living say they would steer clear of.
Read next on Morning Overview: Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say
1. Ford Fiesta (2011-2019): The PowerShift Problem

Ford’s PowerShift dual-clutch transmission made these cars lurch and vibrate, and Ford knew about the defects before the cars reached showrooms but shipped them anyway, Gadget Review reported.
Some drivers found that pressing the brake did not always stop the car from creeping forward. The problems led to $30 million in cash settlements, plus a $10 million fine in Australia. Anyone considering an older Fiesta, or the Focus that shared the transmission, should budget for a transmission replacement rather than just routine maintenance.
2. Chevrolet Equinox (2010-2017): A Quart of Oil Every 1,000 Miles

Equinox SUVs from 2010 to 2017 with the 2.4-liter Ecotec engine consumed one quart of oil every 1,000 miles because of defective piston rings, according to Gadget Review.
Ignoring the oil level could lead to engine seizure and leave owners stranded. The defective rings led to a class-action settlement, but frequent shop visits for oil leaks and engine failures became a normal part of owning one. When a manufacturer’s answer is to keep watching the dipstick rather than fix the problem, mechanics say it is time to walk away.
3. Dodge Dart (2015): Stalling at Highway Speed

The Dodge Dart’s engines consumed excessive oil because of failing piston rings and valve seals, and the 2015 model in particular could stall at highway speeds, Gadget Review reported.
That turned a routine merge onto the highway into a gamble. Multiple recalls addressed engine and electrical issues, but the underlying problems persisted through the compact sedan’s brief production run. Mechanics on the list say the safest way to avoid trouble with a Dart is to skip it entirely when shopping the used market.
4. Fiat 500: Cute but Unreliable

The Fiat 500’s 1.4-liter MultiAir engine developed timing chain problems that left owners stranded on the roadside, according to the mechanics’ warnings compiled by Gadget Review.
Build quality also declined when production shifted to Mexico and Poland, and Consumer Reports consistently gave the little car low reliability ratings. The 500’s styling still wins fans, but Gadget Review’s verdict is blunt: cuteness cannot make up for constant breakdowns, and mechanics would rather see buyers choose something sturdier.
5. BMW X3: Luxury Repair Bills on a Depreciated SUV

BMW X3 models built since 2003 have complex electronics that demand BMW-specific diagnostics and premium labor rates, which makes routine repairs expensive, Gadget Review reported.
The SUVs can depreciate 50% to 70% over five years, yet maintenance costs stay at luxury levels. Earlier X3s also suffered timing chain problems alongside electrical faults. Mechanics warn that paying luxury repair costs on a vehicle that has lost most of its value rarely adds up, especially once diagnostic fees start to approach what the SUV is worth.
6. Tesla Model 3: Repairs That Exceed Its Value

Mechanics warn that Model 3 owners can face battery and motor repairs that exceed the car’s depreciated value, partly because of unique materials and large single-piece castings that require Tesla-specific expertise.
Gadget Review noted that Tesla’s control of service, enforced through software restrictions, keeps many independent shops from doing repairs, turning simple fixes into expensive trips to the company. Insurance rates reflect that reality, with premium pricing for proprietary parts and a limited service network. As Gadget Review put it, Tesla owners drive the car on the company’s terms.
7. Chrysler 200: A Transmission Mechanics Dread

The Chrysler 200 is a frequent source of frustration for mechanics, mainly because of its problematic automatic transmission, AutoGuide reported.
Owners often report jerky shifting, hesitation and even complete transmission failure, sometimes before 100,000 miles. Replacement costs can easily run into the thousands, wiping out whatever was saved by buying used. Add a reputation for electrical gremlins, and most mechanics agree there are more reliable midsize sedans for the money.
8. Chevrolet Cruze: Coolant Leaks That Do Not Stop

Mechanics often warn that the popular Chevrolet Cruze compact has a tendency toward persistent coolant leaks, according to AutoGuide.
Left unchecked, those leaks can lead to overheating, blown head gaskets and even complete engine failure. The repairs are inconvenient and can get expensive, especially if the engine itself is damaged. Anyone shopping for a used Cruze should treat coolant problems as a common and costly pitfall and check the car’s service history for signs of trouble before buying.
9. Subaru Outback (pre-2014): Head Gasket Nightmares

Outbacks built before 2014 often come up as a cautionary tale among mechanics because of chronic head gasket problems that can appear as early as 60,000 miles, AutoGuide reported.
The fix usually means a major and costly repair. The Outback is known for its versatility and all-wheel drive, but mechanics say the persistent head gasket failures overshadow those strengths. Their advice is to steer clear of older Outbacks unless there is clear evidence that the head gaskets have already been replaced.
10. GMC Terrain (2010-2017): Burning Through Oil

Many owners of first-generation Terrain SUVs built from 2010 to 2017 with the 2.4-liter engine report that they burn through engine oil much faster than expected, according to AutoGuide.
If oil levels are not watched closely, that can lead to catastrophic engine failure. The excessive oil consumption defect triggered massive class-action lawsuits and expensive repair bills for drivers whose warranties had run out. The Terrain is popular for its roomy interior, but mechanics often recommend choosing a different compact SUV.
11. Nissan Pathfinder (2013-2015): Transmission Failures in Key Years

Mechanics say used-car shoppers should be cautious with Pathfinders from 2013 to 2015, which have a reputation for transmission failures and other mechanical headaches, AutoGuide reported.
Transmission repairs are especially expensive and can wipe out any savings from buying used. For buyers who put reliability and long-term value first, mechanics say these model years of the Pathfinder are best avoided altogether.
12. Nissan Altima: CVT Headaches

Altimas from the last decade have gained a reputation among mechanics for troublesome continuously variable transmissions, according to AutoGuide.
Owners often experience shuddering, delayed acceleration and, in the worst cases, total transmission failure. Repairing or replacing a CVT can be extremely costly, sometimes more than the car is worth. The Altima promises good fuel economy, but mechanics say the risk of a major transmission bill makes it a risky bet on the used market.
13. Hyundai Sonata (2013-2014): Engine Recall Woes

Sonatas from 2011 to 2014 may look appealing for their price and features, but these model years are notorious for engine issues, especially severe bearing failures, AutoGuide reported.
Those failures can lead to expensive repairs or even complete engine replacements, and Hyundai issued major recalls for engine defects during those years. Mechanics say anyone considering a Sonata from that era should factor in the risk of costly repairs, and many suggest looking elsewhere for better long-term value.
14. Jeep Renegade: Everything Fails Too Often

Certified mechanic Chris Pyle told Parade that Jeep Renegades are overall very unreliable, with expensive maintenance, poor fuel mileage and a weak engine.
He noted that the small SUV is based on a Fiat 500 platform and said it needs a sturdier engine and undercarriage. Parts are getting tougher to find, so repairs can be costly or impossible. Anyone buying one used, Pyle said, should expect problems inside and out, because nearly everything fails too often, from the engine and transmission to the steering, suspension and electronics.
15. Dodge Journey: A Weak Engine and Cheap Plastics

The Dodge Journey landed on the do-not-buy list of experts consulted by Parade, with mechanic Chris Pyle citing a weak engine and poor handling.
Pyle said the cabin quality is disappointing, with cheap plastic parts almost everywhere, and that for a fairly large SUV it can tow only 1,000 pounds. As a mechanic, he added, he gets many questions about the Journey’s engine issues and oil consumption, which is one more reason to look at other midsize SUVs when shopping used.
16. Ford F-150 (2018): Transmission and Stalling Complaints

Truck1 CEO Tomasz Mazurkiewicz told MoneyLion that transmission issues have seemingly plagued the 2018 Ford F-150, affecting both driver comfort and safety.
He cited reports of early stall-outs and malfunctioning engines, with EcoBoost models apparently the most affected, and warned that unrepaired problems can become costly. The 2018 truck may be one of the best-looking F-150s, he said, but between transmission failures and downshifting issues it has too many problems to recommend.
17. Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (2019): Dynamic Fuel Management Trouble

The 2019 Silverado has one significant setback, according to Tomasz Mazurkiewicz: its dynamic fuel management system, which many owners link to misfires and lifter failures.
Lifter replacement and related repairs start in the thousands of dollars, he told MoneyLion, which turns buying this model into a gamble. Add complaints about interior quality and tech glitches, and he called the 2019 Silverado an extremely hard sell for anyone looking for value in a used full-size pickup.
18. Nissan Titan (2020): Shifting Problems and Weak Towing

Tomasz Mazurkiewicz said the 2020 Titan did not earn dependability scores close to some of its competitors, even though its entry-level price was lower than theirs.
He told MoneyLion that its nine-speed automatic transmission had shifting problems and was severely inconsistent, making the driving experience unpleasant. On top of that, the Titan lacks the towing and payload ability of its rivals, he said, so it is not a good choice for buyers who need a real workhorse pickup.
More from Morning Overview
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die