A pilot and a passenger left Kansas City on the evening of Nov. 2 bound for a hunting trip in South Dakota. About an hour later their Piper PA-28 came down in a tree-filled ravine near Hamburg, Iowa, after what the National Transportation Safety Board describes as a spiral descent from 4,800 feet.
Both men aboard were killed. The NTSB’s preliminary report, released Nov. 18, lays out the flight in outline and does not say why the airplane spiraled.
The flight from Kansas City toward Webster
According to WOWT’s account of the NTSB report, the Piper took off from Kansas City Airport-Wheeler Field at about 6:46 p.m., based on flight data. Its destination was Webster, South Dakota, where the passenger planned to go hunting with a friend. The crash happened at about 7:35 p.m. in Fremont County, Iowa, in the southwest corner of the state.
The dead were identified as Brandon Schatz, 44, and Kyle Ginavan, 45, both of Kansas City, Kansas. WOWT’s report names one of them as the passenger but does not say which man was flying.
A friend of the pair told investigators the two had considered flying to Sioux Falls instead because of the weather, but did not know which airport they chose. That detail appears in the report as relayed by WOWT and leaves open whether the plane was still heading for its original destination when it changed direction.
The spiral descent in the NTSB report
After the change of direction, the report says, the airplane descended in a spiral from 4,800 feet above sea level and struck the ravine. Two witnesses reported hearing a loud engine sound followed by a “loud crash or bang.” Witnesses described the conditions as “wet and cloudy,” according to WOWT, and the report gave no other weather data in the portions WOWT summarized.
The sequence the report does lay out is short. The airplane changed direction, descended in a spiral from 4,800 feet and hit trees and ground in a ravine, and the two witnesses who heard a loud engine sound followed by a crash or bang gave investigators the only accounts from the ground. Neither account says what the engine was doing in the moments before impact, and wreckage examinations that could answer that have not been reported.
A preliminary report states what is known and stops short of cause. The NTSB has not said whether the engine, the airframe, the weather or the pilot’s handling of the aircraft was responsible, and the investigation is continuing.
Why cloud and darkness worry safety researchers
A spiral in cloud raises the question of spatial disorientation, in which a pilot without a visible horizon loses track of the airplane’s attitude. The Federal Aviation Administration says spatial disorientation may be a precursor to many general aviation accidents, especially at night or in limited visibility, because the body’s senses can conflict with what is seen. The agency’s advice to pilots is to trust the flight instruments over any conflicting signal from the body, and it notes that accidents usually happen when a pilot is indecisive about relying on them.
The FAA brochure also recommends instrument training and proficiency before flying in less than three miles of visibility, and says pilots should check the weather before and during a flight and avoid visual flight where deteriorating weather could trap them. It adds that at night or in reduced visibility, pilots should rely on flight instruments and test them during preflight and taxi. Whether the Piper’s pilot held an instrument rating, or how much experience either man had, is not in the portions of the report WOWT summarized.
No source reviewed says disorientation occurred in the Hamburg crash. The sunset timing, the cloud and the spiral are the elements that make investigators ask the question; they are not findings.
An FAA technical report covering 2003 through 2021 reexamined 367 fatal general aviation accidents involving spatial disorientation and found a fatality rate of 94 percent. Accidents were strongly associated with pilots who had fewer than 500 flight hours, and many pilots had entered instrument meteorological conditions while intending to fly by visual rules. The report also found that fatal accidents with positive toxicology results rose over time, particularly for drugs with potentially impairing effects, and its authors called for continued education and awareness in general aviation. The Hamburg report as summarized by WOWT mentions no toxicology result.
Two earlier Piper cases, two different outcomes
NTSB final reports from 2024 show how different the answers can be. In an April 1, 2024 crash near Muncie, Indiana, a Piper PA-28-236 pilot made repeated 360-degree turns in cloud while trying to realign with an approach; the NTSB found spatial disorientation and loss of control probable, with a controller’s failure to issue missed approach instructions contributing.
In a June 10, 2024 crash near Clinton, Michigan, a Piper PA-28-140 dropped off radar after beginning a descent and turn, then struck a field nose-down; examiners found the fuel selector between the left tank and the off position, and it did not flow during testing. A spiral-looking track, in other words, can come from very different causes.
For the Hamburg airplane, the NTSB has yet to publish a determination. Until the final report arrives, the weather, the decision between two airports and the reason the airplane left its course remain the open questions.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge
- Winter weather advisories cover I-80, I-70 and the Bighorns with up to 15 inches of snow
- Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA