Some volcanoes pour out slow, glowing rivers of lava. Others, from the same kind of magma, throw it hundreds of metres into the air. A team led by the University of Manchester now reports that the difference may hinge on a delay measured in hours: magma that has been heated well above the temperature at which crystals are stable can hold off forming crystals for more than eight hours, against about 20 minutes for magma that has not been superheated.
The finding, published in Nature Communications, came from lava produced by the 2021 Tajogaite eruption on La Palma in Spain’s Canary Islands. A ScienceDaily summary of the work ran on Nov. 13, 2026; the university’s own release and the paper date to June.
Crystals that arrive in minutes or in hours
Lead author Dr. Barbara Bonechi and co-author Dr. Margherita Polacci, both at Manchester, describe experiments that recreated underground conditions using Tajogaite material at controlled temperature and pressure. Magma that was not superheated began forming crystals after about 20 minutes. Strongly superheated magma delayed the onset of crystallization by more than eight hours.
The paper, titled “Superheating in mafic magmas controls clinopyroxene nucleation delay and magma ascent dynamics,” gives the numbers behind that contrast. In the published version, the offline experiments held the melt at 1200 degrees Celsius for an hour, about 90 degrees above the temperature at which the key mineral, clinopyroxene, begins to crystallize at 275 megapascals of pressure, then cooled it by 1 degree per minute. Crystals appeared only after about eight hours at 1100 degrees.
Why a delay changes how magma rises
Superheating appears to dissolve the microscopic crystal seeds that normally trigger new growth, and it makes the melt more uniform. Without seeds, crystals have trouble starting once the magma cools again, so it stays fluid as it climbs.
Fluid magma travels quickly. The authors fed the measured delays into a computer model of magma rising through the crust. In the eight-hour-delay scenario, magma ascends from 13 kilometres depth in about 30 minutes with little crystallization on the way, a mass eruption rate of roughly 40,000 kilograms per second, which the paper calls consistent with lava fountaining. In the 20-minute-delay scenario, the climb takes about 11.5 hours, and about 20 percent of the magma by volume turns to microscopic crystals. The eruption rate drops to around 2,000 kilograms per second, compatible with effusive flows.
Crystals stiffen magma and slow it down, which gives gas time to escape quietly. A University of Manchester release dated June 8, 2026, puts the contrast in the same terms: long delays let magma rise quickly while staying fluid, which may promote lava fountaining, while earlier crystallization favours gentler effusive eruptions.
Watching crystals grow in real time
The real-time part of the work took place at Diamond Light Source, the UK’s national synchrotron in Oxfordshire. According to Diamond’s news release, the team used an X-ray-transparent, internally heated pressure vessel on the I12-JEEP beamline, paired with fast X-ray microtomography, to watch crystallization as it happened. The Tajogaite cone on the Cumbre Vieja ridge began erupting on Oct. 2, 2021, and the paper describes hot, low-viscosity magma from a deep source. Longer experiments were run separately in Prague so the slow, hours-long delays could be observed. Bonechi told ScienceDaily that the setup makes it possible to observe these processes in situ.
The University of Bristol’s petrology group, whose Richard Brooker is a co-author, supplied the pressure-vessel design used at the beamline and describes the study on its research page. The group’s summary names the thermal history of magma before it begins its journey to the surface as an underappreciated control on eruption style.
The work was international. The paper’s author list spans Manchester, the universities of Camerino, Milano-Bicocca, Bristol, Grenoble Alpes, Charles University in Prague and Leibniz University Hannover, Italy’s INGV Etneo observatory, Italy’s CNR and Diamond Light Source, which is an unusual mix of petrologists, beamline scientists and modellers for a single experiment on one volcano’s lava.
Limits the researchers set on their own result
Bonechi, in the same Manchester release, said: “The history of crystal and bubble growth can dramatically control how a magma erupts.” The claim is about timing and thermal history, not about any single volcano’s next eruption.
Polacci frames the result as an addition to hazard modelling rather than a replacement. In Manchester’s release she said: “Current volcanic hazard models typically focus on magma chemistry, gas content and pressure changes.” ScienceDaily’s summary quotes her saying the work suggests that pre-eruptive thermal history and crystallization kinetics may also play an important role.
The paper is careful about its limits. Its authors state that the results do not directly explain the variations seen at Tajogaite, where multiple vents produced ash emissions, lava fountains, Strombolian activity and sustained lava flows. Whether superheating happens at other volcanoes, and how often, remains the open question that forecasters would need answered before a magma’s heating history could enter an eruption warning.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating