Nearly 200 people packed a Carbon County, Utah, meeting room on Thursday, Nov. 12, expecting to be heard on a plan to put reactors, a gas plant and data centers on a 640-acre parcel near Price. They were not. The county planning commission took no public comment before it approved a conditional use permit for Valar Atomics.
Read next on Morning Overview: The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
The county attorney, Christian Bryner, told the room at the outset that no public hearing was required for this kind of application. A few attendees were later removed by sheriff’s deputies after repeatedly shouting, and the vote went ahead with one commissioner opposed.
A permit for the Raceway Energy Campus, with strings attached
The approval covers what Valar calls the Raceway Energy Campus, built on state trust land managed by the Utah Trust Lands Administration. By the company’s own figures the campus would draw about 3 gigawatts, a load the Salt Lake Tribune noted is comparable to the roughly 4 gigawatts all of Utah uses. The data centers would run first on a natural gas plant, with the company aiming to add somewhere between 40 and 120 nuclear reactors later, according to the Salt Lake Tribune’s account of the meeting.
Planning Commissioner Lisa Simmons cast the only “nay” vote and asked about emergency protocols before the roll was called. The permit comes with conditions: an emergency response plan coordinated with the sheriff’s office and fire marshal and filed with the county building department, added emergency-management staffing, workforce housing, community engagement, and management plans covering noise, water and waste. The Moab Times republished the same report with the conditions listed in the same order.
None of that amounts to permission to build. Valar still needs a county building permit with approved plans, including a traffic plan, an air quality permit from the Utah Division of Air Quality, and a construction permit from the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
Roads, water and waste: what commissioners and Valar said
Much of the discussion that did take place was between commissioners and company staff, and it centered on East Coal Creek Road, the route trucks would use at first. Commissioner Kurt McFarlane said the road’s asphalt is too thin to carry that traffic. Cory Gardner, Valar’s head of commercial development, answered that the company is willing to pay for upgrades and that the long-term plan is a new road across federal land off Airport Road, so the campus would stop using the county road.
Water was the other practical question. Gardner told the commission that Valar plans to use “zero local water,” relying mainly on trucked-in supply, and would buy private industrial water rights and non-culinary municipal water shares if trucking is not allowed. Reactor cores would use closed-loop helium cooling, and the data centers would use closed-loop systems that are filled once and topped up.
Radioactive waste drew the least concrete answer. The application says low-level waste would sit on site only until it ships to a licensed facility elsewhere, but it does not say where it would be held in the interim or over the long term. Max Ukropina, Valar’s head of projects, said nuclear energy is safe and that the federal permitting process is rigorous. Justin Needles, formerly the county’s emergency manager and now the emergency manager for Valar’s test site, will oversee emergency planning for the campus.
Residents who could only watch
Price resident MariAnne Lawrence, worried about nuclear waste, said her community’s biggest concern was that nobody was telling residents anything. Elizabeth Trostle questioned why the project sits so close to homes and argued it belonged on land that was already disturbed. Debbie Durrant called out from the audience that the road in question is where she lives.
Opposition had been building for weeks before the vote. In September, the Salt Lake Tribune reported residents arming themselves with petitions, and Canary Media’s October report quoted Cheryl Lupo, a county commission candidate, warning of “torches and pitchforks” because residents felt unheard. Cindy O’Neil objected to nondisclosure agreements around the project. All three county commissioners had voiced support at a September meeting, and Commissioner Larry Jensen said the “silent majority” is who the commission represents.
Raceway sits beside a far larger proposal
The Raceway permit is one piece of a bigger push. Valar has separately proposed Project Beehive, about 9,000 acres of adjacent federal land managed by the Bureau of Land Management. The American Nuclear Society’s October summary put Beehive at 456 reactors, citing NPR’s Sept. 30 report that the reactors would produce around 9.6 gigawatts, and said the BLM was still reviewing the application for completeness. Valar has said no construction begins before permits and approvals.
Whether the county’s conditions amount to real oversight is now the open question. The Utah Division of Air Quality and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission have yet to rule, and the commission’s decision to skip a hearing means the first formal chance for the public to speak may come only if one of those agencies, or the county building department, opens one.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found