Compact SUVs are some of the best-selling vehicles in America, which means plenty of owners are ready to report when something goes wrong. CarComplaints.com sorts those reports by model year and names the year it considers the worst for each nameplate. Here are twelve compact SUVs whose worst year shoppers should know before buying used.
Read next on Morning Overview: The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
1. Honda CR-V: 2011 Is the One to Watch

CarComplaints.com rates the 2011 Honda CR-V as its worst model year, even though the 2017 CR-V has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top complaint category, according to the site’s CR-V page.
The most-reported problem is a high oil level with gas in the oil on the 2017 model, a fuel-dilution issue tied to the turbocharged engine in cold weather. Honda addressed it with software updates and extended warranty coverage in some regions. Buyers of either year should check service records closely.
2. Toyota RAV4: The 2019 Leads the Warnings

The 2019 Toyota RAV4 earns CarComplaints.com’s worst-year label, while the 2002 RAV4 has more total complaints. Transmission problems lead the complaint categories, according to the RAV4 page.
The most-reported specific problem is excessive oil consumption on the 2007 model. The 2019 was the first year of a fully redesigned RAV4, and complaints about that generation have focused on drivetrain behavior. For a model famous for reliability, those years stand out as the exceptions.
3. Chevrolet Equinox: A 2013 With Engine Trouble

CarComplaints.com rates the 2013 Chevrolet Equinox as its worst model year, even though the 2006 Equinox has more total complaints. Engine problems top the complaint list, according to the site’s Equinox page.
On the 2006 model, the most-reported problem is heat that blows out cold air, an irritation in winter climates. The 2013 belongs to a generation whose four-cylinder engine drew many owner complaints about oil use. Shoppers should ask for records showing how often oil was added between changes.
4. Ford Escape: Rust and Transmission Gripes

The 2014 Ford Escape carries CarComplaints.com’s worst-model-year rating, while the 2008 Escape has more complaints overall. Transmission problems are the top category, according to the Escape page.
The most-reported specific problem on the 2008 model is excessive rust in the wheel wells and shock towers, a structural issue in salty climates. The 2014 was one of the early years of a redesigned Escape, and owners reported a range of powertrain issues. A careful underbody inspection is wise on older examples.
5. Nissan Rogue: A Loss of Acceleration

For the Nissan Rogue, CarComplaints.com rates 2013 as the worst model year, and that year also has the most complaints. Transmission problems lead the categories, according to the site’s Rogue page.
The most-reported problem on the 2013 model is a loss of acceleration, a complaint often linked to the continuously variable transmission. A sudden lack of power can be unnerving when merging onto a highway. Anyone shopping for a used 2013 Rogue should ask whether the transmission has been serviced or replaced.
6. Hyundai Tucson: Hesitation From a Stop

The 2017 Hyundai Tucson earns CarComplaints.com’s worst-model-year label, even though the 2016 Tucson has more total complaints. Transmission problems are the top category, according to the Tucson page.
The most-reported problem is hesitation when starting from a stop, a complaint associated with the dual-clutch automatic used on some trims in those years. A delay pulling into traffic can create risky moments at intersections. Test drives should include several stop-and-go starts to feel for that lag.
7. Kia Sportage: An Engine That Quit While Driving

CarComplaints.com rates the 2012 Kia Sportage as its worst model year, even though the 2017 Sportage has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the site’s Sportage page.
The most-reported problem is an engine that stopped working while driving, one of the most dangerous failures a vehicle can have. Hyundai and Kia engines from this period were the subject of major recalls and warranty extensions. Shoppers should check whether any engine recall work was completed on a used Sportage.
8. Mazda CX-5: LED Light Failures

The 2016 Mazda CX-5 is both CarComplaints.com’s worst model year and the year with the most complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the CX-5 page.
The most-reported specific problem on the 2016 model is a daytime running LED light failure, which can be expensive because the lights are often built into the headlight assembly. The CX-5 otherwise has a solid reputation, so a single year with a cluster of complaints is worth knowing about before buying.
9. Subaru Forester: Oil Consumption in 2014

CarComplaints.com rates the 2014 Subaru Forester as its worst model year, even though the 2015 Forester has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the site’s Forester page.
The most-reported problem on the 2014 model is high oil consumption, a concern that has affected several Subaru engines from this era. An engine burning oil between changes can run low without warning and suffer damage. Owners and shoppers should check oil levels frequently and look for records of any related repairs.
10. Jeep Cherokee: Rough Shifting Complaints

The 2019 Jeep Cherokee earns CarComplaints.com’s worst-year rating, while the 2014 Cherokee has more total complaints. Transmission problems are the leading category, according to the Cherokee page.
The most-reported problem on the 2014 model is rough shifting from the nine-speed automatic, which drew numerous complaints and several software updates. The 2014 was the debut year of the redesigned Cherokee. A test drive that includes low-speed shifts can reveal whether a particular vehicle still has the issue.
11. Jeep Compass: Suspension Parts Wear Out

For the Jeep Compass, CarComplaints.com rates 2007 as the worst model year, and that year also has the most complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the site’s Compass page.
The most-reported specific problem on the 2007 model is control arm and bushing failure, which can cause clunking noises, uneven tire wear and vague handling. The 2007 was the Compass’s first model year. Anyone considering an early Compass should have the front suspension inspected before buying.
12. Volkswagen Tiguan: Engine Failure Reports

CarComplaints.com rates the 2018 Volkswagen Tiguan as its worst model year, even though the 2009 Tiguan has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the Tiguan page.
The most-reported problem is engine failure on the 2010 model, a costly outcome for any owner. The 2018 was the first year of the larger, redesigned Tiguan sold in the US. Buyers should check maintenance history carefully, since timing chain and oil-related issues can lead to expensive repairs on turbocharged engines.
More from Morning Overview
- Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found