Skip to main content

Morning Overview

12 big family SUVs and their most troubled year

A three-row SUV often carries the whole family, so a bad model year can mean more than an expensive repair bill. Owner complaints collected by CarComplaints.com point to the years that gave drivers the most grief. Here are twelve big family SUVs and the model year that site flags as their most troubled.

Read next on Morning Overview: A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned

1. Ford Explorer: Avoid the 2006

Ford Explorer — Image Credit: Ethan Llamas - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Ethan Llamas – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2006 Ford Explorer as its worst model year, even though the 2002 Explorer has more total complaints. Transmission problems are the top complaint category, according to the site’s Explorer page.

The most-reported problem is a cracked panel below the rear window, a common complaint on Explorers of the early 2000s. The 2006 was the first year of a redesigned generation, and transmission failures drew heavy criticism from owners. Shoppers should ask for documentation of any transmission repairs.

2. Jeep Grand Cherokee: Electrical Gremlins in 2011

Jeep Grand Cherokee — Image Credit: Michael Gil from Calgary, AB, Canada - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Michael Gil from Calgary, AB, Canada – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

The 2011 Jeep Grand Cherokee is both CarComplaints.com’s worst model year and the year with the most complaints. Electrical problems are the top category, according to the Grand Cherokee page.

The most-reported issue involves the totally integrated power module, or TIPM, going bad and leaving the engine unwilling to start or hard to start. The module controls many electrical functions, so a failure can cause a cascade of problems. The 2011 was the first year of the redesigned Grand Cherokee.

3. Honda Pilot: A First-Year Ignition Problem

Honda Pilot — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

For the Honda Pilot, CarComplaints.com rates 2003 as the worst model year, and that year also carries the most complaints. Transmission problems are the top category, according to the site’s Pilot page.

The most-reported specific problem on the 2003 model is an ignition switch problem, which can make a vehicle difficult to start or cause it to stall. The 2003 was the Pilot’s debut year, and first-year vehicles often have the most issues. Buyers of an early Pilot should check that transmission and ignition work has been done.

4. Toyota Highlander: Stripped Engine Bolt Threads

Toyota Highlander — Image Credit: HJUdall - CC0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: HJUdall – CC0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2003 Toyota Highlander as its worst model year, even though the 2015 Highlander has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the Highlander page.

The most-reported problem on the 2003 model is stripped threads for engine bolts, a repair that can require special inserts and labor to fix properly. Toyota’s reputation for durability makes those complaints stand out. An inspection for oil leaks around the engine is a smart step before buying an older Highlander.

5. Chevrolet Traverse: Engine Failure in 2011

Chevrolet Traverse — Image Credit: Cutlass - CC0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Cutlass – CC0/Wiki Commons

The 2011 Chevrolet Traverse earns CarComplaints.com’s worst-model-year label, although the 2010 Traverse has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the site’s Traverse page.

The most-reported specific problem on the 2011 model is outright engine failure, one of the most expensive repairs an owner can face. Early Traverses used a V6 that drew complaints about timing chains. Anyone shopping for a 2009 to 2011 model should look for records of timing chain service.

6. Chevrolet Tahoe: The Cracked Dashboard

Chevrolet Tahoe — Image Credit: order_242 from Chile - CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: order_242 from Chile – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2015 Chevrolet Tahoe as its worst model year, even though the 2007 Tahoe has more total complaints. Interior accessory problems are the top category, according to the Tahoe page.

The most-reported problem is a cracked dashboard on the 2007 model, a common sight on GM full-size SUVs of that era after years in the sun. The 2015 was the first year of a redesigned Tahoe. While a cracked dash is cosmetic, replacing it can be surprisingly expensive and time-consuming.

7. Nissan Pathfinder: Coolant in the Transmission

Nissan Pathfinder — Image Credit: OSX - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: OSX – Public domain/Wiki Commons

For the Nissan Pathfinder, CarComplaints.com rates 2005 as the worst model year, and that year also has the most complaints. Transmission problems are the top category, according to the site’s Pathfinder page.

The most-reported problem on the 2005 model is coolant leaking into the transmission, a failure in which the radiator’s internal cooler cracks and contaminates the fluid. That can destroy an automatic transmission. Owners often replaced the radiator preemptively, so buyers should look for proof that was done.

8. Dodge Durango: Shutting Down While Driving

Dodge Durango — Image Credit: Cutlass - CC0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Cutlass – CC0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2004 Dodge Durango as its worst model year, while the 1999 Durango has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the Durango page.

The most-reported problem on the 1999 model is the SUV shutting down while driving, a dangerous failure that can leave drivers without power steering or power brake assist in traffic. The 2004 was the first year of the second-generation Durango, which grew larger than its predecessor.

9. Kia Sorento: Engine Failure Reports in 2016

Kia Sorento — Image Credit: RL GNZLZ from Chile - CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: RL GNZLZ from Chile – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons

The 2016 Kia Sorento is both CarComplaints.com’s worst-rated model year and a leader in engine complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the site’s Sorento page, though the 2011 Sorento has more complaints overall.

The most-reported problem on the 2016 model is engine failure. Kia’s engines from this period were covered by recalls and extended warranties after widespread complaints about bearing failures. Shoppers should verify that any recall work was done and ask whether the engine has been replaced.

10. Hyundai Santa Fe: A Failed Fuel Level Sensor

Hyundai Santa Fe — Image Credit: Elise240SX - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Elise240SX – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2012 Hyundai Santa Fe as its worst model year, even though the 2007 Santa Fe has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the Santa Fe page.

The most-reported problem is a failed fuel level sensor on the 2008 model, which can make the gauge read inaccurately and leave drivers unsure how much fuel remains. The 2012 was the last year of the second-generation Santa Fe. A gauge that reads empty on a full tank is a clue that the sensor needs replacement.

11. Ford Expedition: Spark Plugs That Blew Out

Ford Expedition — Image Credit: order_242 from Chile - CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: order_242 from Chile – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2004 Ford Expedition as its worst model year, even though the 2003 Expedition has more total complaints. Engine problems are the top category, according to the site’s Expedition page.

The most-reported problem on the 2003 model is a spark plug that blew out of the cylinder head, a known issue with some Ford engines of that era. It can damage the threads and require an expensive repair. Owners of 2003 and 2004 Expeditions often had threads repaired with inserts.

12. GMC Acadia: Transmission Failure in 2008

GMC Acadia — Image Credit: order_242 from Chile - CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: order_242 from Chile – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons

The 2008 GMC Acadia is both CarComplaints.com’s worst model year and the year with the most complaints. Transmission problems are the top category, according to the Acadia page.

The most-reported problem on the 2008 model is transmission failure. The 2008 was the Acadia’s debut year, and its six-speed automatic drew numerous complaints. Anyone considering an early Acadia should ask whether the transmission has been rebuilt or replaced and look for a warranty on the work.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.