Skip to main content

Morning Overview

We Energies customers face a sixth straight rate hike on their power bills

For a typical household served by Wisconsin’s largest electric utility, the next two Januaries come with a bigger bill: about $7 to $8 more per month in 2027 and $6 to $7 more in 2028. On Thursday, Nov. 5, the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin approved a roughly 7 percent increase in We Energies’ electricity rates across the two years, the company’s sixth consecutive rate hike.

The vote cut the request but did not stop it. Regulators trimmed what the company wanted, reassigned some costs to data centers and told shareholders to absorb more of the risk, all while one commissioner said outright that years of increases cannot be ignored.

The commission’s cut to the original request

According to Wisconsin Watch, the utility had initially proposed about a 9 percent overall increase over two years, including 16 percent for residential customers. The Citizens Utility Board, the consumer advocate, put the request at $449 million over two years. Wisconsin Public Radio reported that the utility sought base electric increases of 4.6 percent for 2027 and 4.5 percent for 2028, and the commission approved 3.9 percent and 3.5 percent.

In its April 1 filing, the company said a typical residential customer would pay about $13 more per month in 2027 and $8 to $9 more in 2028, the company said in its release. Mike Hooper, the utility’s president, said then that the plan would invest in reliability and make sure data centers pay their fair share. The approved bill impact is $7 to $8 in 2027, according to the estimates WEC Energy Group gave Wisconsin Public Radio.

Wisconsin Public Service, a sister utility under WEC Energy Group, fared differently: electric increases of 0.3 percent for 2027 and 2.9 percent for 2028, with a typical bill rising about $1 or less in 2027 and $5 to $6 in 2028.

The streak has a visible history. When regulators last set two-year rates in December 2022, they approved an 8.8 percent electric increase for the company, nearly 11 percent for its residential customers, or $11 to $12 more per month in preliminary figures, and cut the allowed return to 9.8 percent, Wisconsin Public Radio reported at the time. The 2027-2028 increases are smaller each year, but they arrive on top of that base.

The return on equity fight

The profit margin was one of the sharpest disputes. the utility asked for a 9.9 percent return on equity, which it called a conservative increase needed to attract capital. Walmart called the request “unjustified” in September testimony, and the Citizens Utility Board urged cutting it by nearly a percentage point. Commissioners set it at 9.5 percent, saving ratepayers roughly $60 million over two years, Wisconsin Watch reported.

Commissioner Kristy Nieto warned against ignoring “the cumulative impact of years of increases.” Chair Summer Strand said that anyone who benefits from an expense should pay for it, and that no action from state policymakers had helped with stranded assets, which are plants still being paid off after they stop running. Commissioner Marcus Hawkins said the utility’s leaders “chose to put their head in the sand” about cost-overrun risks.

Data centers, overruns and old plants

The utility first proposed billing ratepayers for a quarter of the costs of new power plants built for data-center customers. Commissioners rejected that plan about a month later and ordered those costs assigned directly to large data-center customers. In its own filing, the utility counted nearly $1.9 billion in costs paid by data centers in 2027 and 2028.

Cost overruns drew a harder line. The 2022 Kenosha County solar and battery purchase cost $433 million, nearly 40 percent over the approved figure. The commission allowed full recovery but barred profit on $166 million of unapproved spending. Darien Solar is 35 percent over budget and Koshkonong Solar 42 percent over; both will be revisited in the next rate case, with recovery capped at original prices.

Customers still owe roughly $1 billion on retired plants, including $775 million for Pleasant Prairie, which closed in 2018. The commission extended the recovery period by six years and limited shareholder profits on those plants, which the Wisconsin Industrial Energy Group estimates will save at least $30 million by 2028.

Bills, disconnections and the people paying

Wisconsin Watch reports that about 60,000 customers were disconnected last year, compared with about 51,000 in 2019. Reconnection once required 80 percent of arrears, with a $600 maximum for low-income households; it is now 50 percent, with a $100 cap.

Opponents were not mollified. A Nov. 5 release from the Clean Economy Coalition of Wisconsin called it the sixth straight annual increase since 2020, and Antonio Butts of Walnut Way Conservation Corp. said the increase remains unaffordable for his community.

A company spokesperson, Brendan Conway, told Spectrum News the increases pay for closing coal plants and opening new generation. Tom Content of the Citizens Utility Board said the commission “did some things that the PSC has been reluctant to do in the past in the name of affordability.” The written order that sets final rates is expected in a few weeks, Wisconsin Public Radio reported.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview


Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.