Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Washington is forcing coal plants from Colorado to Washington state to keep running

The coal plant outside Centralia, Washington, was supposed to be the end of coal power in the Pacific Northwest. Its owner planned to shut it down last December. It is still standing by, along with coal units from Colorado to Florida, because the federal government keeps ordering them to.

Read next on Morning Overview: Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman

The Department of Energy has used emergency powers under section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act to keep a string of retiring coal units available to run, including Craig Unit 1 in Colorado and Centralia Unit 2 in Washington state. Its most recent coal order, issued November 13, renewed the requirement for Michigan’s J.H. Campbell plant through February 12, 2027.

The orders and the plants they cover

The Energy Department’s list of 2026 section 202(c) orders shows how far the program now reaches. Craig Unit 1, in Craig, Colorado, is under an order effective from September 27 through December 25, 2026. Centralia Unit 2 is covered from September 13 through December 11. Two Indiana coal plants, F.B. Culley Unit 2 in Warrick County and R.M. Schahfer Units 17 and 18 in Wheatfield, are covered through December 18. Stanton Unit 1 in Orlando, Florida, is also on the list, under an order that took effect September 2.

The orders run for about 90 days at a time, and the department has renewed them repeatedly. Craig Unit 1 was originally scheduled to retire at the end of 2025, but Energy Secretary Chris Wright issued orders keeping it available in December 2025 and again three times in 2026, according to the department’s September 25 announcement. Each order directs the plant’s operators and the regional grid operator to keep the unit available and to run it only when needed, using economic dispatch to limit costs.

Wright frames the orders as protection against blackouts. Announcing the Craig order, he said the administration would keep acting to prevent the loss of critical generation sources and argued that Americans deserve reliable power “regardless of whether the wind is blowing or the sun is shining.” The department says more than 17 gigawatts of coal generation have been kept from going offline since 2025.

A plant that is not running, and a bill that keeps growing

Centralia shows the tension in the policy. TransAlta’s plant near Centralia, the only remaining coal-fired power plant in the Northwest, appears to have burned its last coal in December, the Washington State Standard reported, even as federal orders required it to remain available. TransAlta’s first invoice for costs under the order, submitted April 30, came to nearly $20 million, and the company estimated it would need $23 million more to repair and refurbish the 55-year-old plant.

On October 1, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission rejected TransAlta’s plan for recovering those costs but ruled that the nearly $20 million for the first 90-day order must still be paid, and only by utilities in the Northwest, Utility Dive reported. “If this coal plant is supposedly essential to keeping the lights on, then why has it been sitting idle while families and businesses pay the enormous costs of keeping it online?” Ted Kelly of the Environmental Defense Fund said earlier this year.

State officials have been just as blunt. Will Toor, executive director of the Colorado Energy Office, compared the orders to “Soviet-style central planning” in a March interview with Stateline, arguing that regulators and utilities, not Washington, should decide how to meet energy needs. Utilities, states and grid operators have described the plants as expensive, in poor repair and no longer needed, and consumer advocates fear the costs could reach billions of dollars across dozens of states, Stateline reported. Washington state has formally sought rehearing of one of the Centralia orders.

Coal’s share keeps shrinking anyway

The orders slow the retirement of coal plants but do not reverse the broader trend. The Energy Information Administration forecasts that coal’s share of U.S. generation will fall from 17% in 2025 to 15% by 2027, with 13 gigawatts of coal capacity scheduled to retire by the end of 2027, according to its November outlook. U.S. coal consumption is forecast to fall 7% this year, driven by growth in wind and solar and lower natural gas prices.

The program is still expanding to other fuels and regions. On November 17, the department issued another 202(c) order for Unit 4 at the Wagner Generating Station in Maryland, in the PJM region. For the coal units in Colorado, Washington and Indiana, the current orders expire in December, and the pattern so far, with Craig and Centralia each renewed several times since their first orders, suggests renewals will follow. Who ultimately pays for keeping idle plants ready, local customers or entire regions, is the question FERC and the courts are still sorting out.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.