The idea has a romantic appeal: comets, loaded with simple carbon and nitrogen chemistry, rained on the young Earth and handed it the raw material for life. Cambridge astronomers ran the numbers on one of those molecules, hydrogen cyanide, and found that most comets would have ruined their own cargo on arrival.
Read next on Morning Overview: Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman
Dr. Richard Anslow of the Cambridge Institute of Astronomy led the simulations. His verdict on the delivery scenario was blunt: it would really have to be a one-in-a-million occurrence. The paper appeared in Scientific Reports in 2026.
Hydrogen cyanide and the problem of surviving impact
Hydrogen cyanide, or HCN, is a carbon- and nitrogen-bearing molecule common in comets, and it is a staple of origin-of-life chemistry, which is why the study treats it as the test case for whether comets could have supplied a key ingredient. The study, published in Scientific Reports by Anslow with Catriona McDonald, Amy Bonsor, Paul Rimmer and Auriol Rae, combined three kinds of modeling: comet impact simulations, calculations of how comets interact with planetary atmospheres, and models of how comet populations formed and changed as the Solar System developed. The ScienceDaily summary of the Cambridge release says the work was funded by the Royal Society, the Leverhulme Centre for Life in the Universe and the Science and Technology Facilities Council.
Comets generally hit Earth at speeds and angles that destroy delicate organic molecules. Even where HCN survived, the impact had to leave it in a concentration useful for chemistry, and deposited material would likely have spread or diluted quickly.
A handful of chances in 500 million years
Comet impacts were far more frequent early in Earth’s history, but their rate fell sharply across the first 500 million years. The researchers estimate that only a handful of favorable delivery opportunities existed in that entire window, a point Anslow described as the core obstacle: the right comet would have to arrive at the right speed and angle, at the right time.
Coverage of the paper adds detail on the model runs. Sci.News reports that the team simulated 100,000 histories of Earth’s cometary bombardment, and in 54 percent of them no impact delivered HCN at concentrations sufficient for prebiotic chemistry. Nature World News reports that survival was best for comets more than about 100 meters across, moving relatively slowly and striking at a shallow, oblique angle, and that on average about one meaningful delivery occurred over more than a billion years. Those figures come from press coverage; the Cambridge summary gives none of them. Neither outlet gives exact speeds, so the paper itself is the place to check the thresholds.
The same coverage lists where the cargo went missing. Comets broke apart in the atmosphere, lost their HCN to impact heat, which was the largest factor, or landed in the ocean and were diluted. Earlier work by the group had already found that HCN survival was extremely limited at high impact speeds unless the angle was very shallow, so the new result extends a known problem across the whole bombardment rather than a single impact.
Mars gets better odds, and the alternatives
Mars is smaller, with a much thinner atmosphere, so incoming comet material could more easily reach the surface intact. Nature World News reports more than five times as many successful HCN deliveries on Mars as on Earth in the model, while Venus destroyed most comets even when they were several kilometers wide. The Cambridge summary says the simulations do not show that deliveries occurred there. Anslow was careful, saying it is not to say it definitely happened on Mars, and suggested the process may have happened on neither planet, perhaps the more likely outcome.
Anslow also told Sci.News that the comet idea is a romantic one, but that the results suggest it is highly unlikely. He characterized the delivery scenario as, at best, a one-off fluke, a phrase that matters because origin-of-life arguments need chemistry that could happen repeatedly or at least plausibly, not once.
If comets were a poor courier, the ingredients had to come from somewhere else. The paper points to asteroid impacts, which were more frequent than comet impacts and may have produced prebiotic molecules through impact chemistry, and to natural chemical processes on the early Earth itself.
The same group has argued the opposite side before. A 2023 study of bouncing comets found that comets must travel slower than about 15 kilometers per second to deliver intact organic molecules, and that tightly packed multi-planet systems offer the best odds because a comet can be passed between planets and slowed until it survives entry. That work did not claim comets were necessary for life. The new result applies the same survival logic to Earth, and leaves open what Anslow calls, at best, a one-off fluke: whether any single comet ever dropped usable HCN into a pond that could host the first chemistry of life.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned