A car that breaks early is a bigger gamble than one that wears out slowly, because the repair often lands while the loan is still running. CarComplaints tracks the average mileage and cost for each model year’s worst reported problem. Here are twelve model years whose biggest failure tends to appear well before the odometer gets old.
The day in tech, in one email: TLDR is the daily newsletter with links and TLDRs of the most interesting stories in startups, tech and programming.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. 2015 Jeep Grand Cherokee: Shifter Failure At Low Mileage
Electronic shifting problems on the 2015 Jeep Grand Cherokee are CarComplaints’ top Jeep trouble spot, averaging $7,500 to fix at just 12,000 miles.
Hitting a four-figure bill that early means many owners are still inside a warranty window or recently out of it. It is the lowest mileage on this list, which makes the 2015 Grand Cherokee a case study in how quickly an electronic part can go wrong. Buyers of used examples should ask whether the work was done.
2. 2019 Jeep Cherokee: Engine Shutdowns On A Compact
The 2019 Jeep Cherokee’s engine shutting down is Jeep’s top trouble spot on CarComplaints, averaging $6,000 to fix at 17,000 miles.
A vehicle that stalls without warning is more than an inconvenience, because it can cut power in traffic. The early mileage means such failures can arrive on a nearly new car. Anyone shopping for this year should confirm that repairs were completed and ask what the shop actually replaced.
3. 2019 Mazda CX-5: Acceleration Without Warning
Owners reported unexplained acceleration on the 2019 Mazda CX-5, averaging $2,600 to fix at 14,000 miles.
Unintended acceleration is among the more alarming complaints a driver can file, and it showed up early in this crossover’s life. The repair cost is lower than the Jeep failures, but the safety angle makes the report worth a close look, including a check for open recalls. Owners who notice any unexpected throttle behavior should have it checked promptly, and shoppers can verify that recall work is complete.
4. 2010 Mazda3: Clutch Gives Out Early
A failed clutch is Mazda’s top complaint on the 2010 Mazda3, averaging $1,200 at 39,000 miles.
That is a modest bill compared with engine or transmission work, yet a clutch should normally last far longer than this. A used 2010 Mazda3 with a manual gearbox deserves a careful test drive, with attention to slipping, a high pedal or difficult engagement. Manual-transmission cars are the likeliest to show this, so checking clutch feel is a quick screening step.
5. 2017 Chevrolet Silverado 1500: Truck That Surges And Jerks
Owners of the 2017 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 report surging and jerking reports that averaged $4,100 to fix at 22,000 miles.
Full-size pickups are bought for towing and daily work, so drivability problems at this mileage cut against the reason people buy them. A seller of a used 2017 truck should be able to show what was repaired. A test drive at varied speeds is the best way to spot trouble. Pairing that with a vehicle history report gives a clearer picture than the asking price alone.
6. 2018 Ford F-150: Costliest Repair On The List
Oil consumption on the 2018 Ford F-150 averaged a $10,300 repair at 28,000 miles, while hard shifting cost $7,200 at 35,000.
The $10,300 figure is the highest on this list, and it arrives while the truck is still young. Two serious problems on one model year raise a sensible question about how closely buyers should inspect it. Any used 2018 F-150 should come with documented service history. Checking the truck for oil level, leaks and shifting behavior during a test drive is a practical way to screen for either problem.
7. 2014 Ford Focus: Hesitation In A Compact Car
Hesitation on the 2014 Ford Focus averaged $1,200 to fix at 25,000 miles, and CarComplaints lists it among Ford’s worst trouble spots.
The repair bill is modest, but a car that hesitates under acceleration is frustrating and can be unsafe when merging. The early mileage suggests many owners meet the issue within the first couple of years, which is worth remembering when comparing used compacts. Checking a seller’s maintenance paperwork is a sensible first step.
8. 2006 Ford Explorer: Lunging Transmission Near The Line
Transmission lunging on the 2006 Ford Explorer averaged $1,800 to fix at 49,000 miles, per CarComplaints transmission data.
This is the closest entry to the 50,000-mile mark, so it only just qualifies as an early failure. The cost is moderate, but an SUV of this age may also have other wear items coming due, which makes a thorough pre-purchase inspection especially useful. Pairing the figure with a mechanic’s inspection is wise.
9. 2017 Chevrolet Cruze: Cracked Piston Risk
A cracked piston on the 2017 Chevrolet Cruze averaged $2,700 to fix at 33,000 miles.
Piston damage is an internal engine fault, the kind of failure shoppers usually associate with much higher mileage. For a compact sedan that many people buy as sensible transportation, it is a worrying result. Used buyers should ask for service records and any engine repair paperwork. Careful shoppers can treat the listed cost as a baseline for negotiating the price.
10. 2008 Chevrolet Cobalt: Grinding Gears In An Economy Car
Transmission grinding on the 2008 Chevrolet Cobalt averaged $2,600 to fix at 24,000 miles.
The Cobalt was an inexpensive small car, and a transmission bill of that size can approach what an older example is worth. Because the failure appears at such a low mileage, even low-use cars from that year deserve a close test drive through every gear. Documented repairs from a reputable shop are worth paying a little extra for.
11. 2013 Dodge Dart: Suspension That Wears Out Fast
Weak suspension on the 2013 Dodge Dart averaged $7,000 to fix at only 15,000 miles, according to Dart suspension complaints, and the model year drew 425 complaints.
A suspension bill that large on a compact sedan is unusual, and the complaint count shows the problem was not isolated. Shoppers considering a 2013 Dart should inspect for uneven tire wear and unusual noises, then ask whether the work was handled under warranty. The unusually low mileage makes a thorough inspection non-negotiable.
12. 2005 Chevrolet Equinox: Head Gasket Worries
For the 2005 Chevrolet Equinox, NHTSA engine and cooling complaints, 45 in all, put the average failure mileage at 41,847 miles, with blown head gaskets reported.
This entry rests on an average failure mileage and not a single repair price, but the pattern is clear: cooling problems that damage the engine arrive early. Any used 2005 Equinox should be checked for coolant loss, overheating and signs of past head gasket repair. Replacement of the head gasket, if documented, is a point in the car’s favor.
The day in tech, in one email: Get TLDR →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Two passengers died at an Ohio toll plaza, and the NTSB now wants the cash lanes shut
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
- Hybrids have 15% fewer problems than gas cars, while EVs and plug-in hybrids have about 80% more, Consumer Reports finds
