Minivans and family crossovers are bought to be dependable, so a bad model year can hurt a household budget. Owner reports gathered by CarComplaints.com point to specific years that drew the most trouble. Here are 11 family haulers, the year the site flags as worst and the problem owners reported most.
Read next on Morning Overview: A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
1. Honda Odyssey: Transmission Trouble

CarComplaints.com rates the 2002 Honda Odyssey as its worst model year, even though the 2005 Odyssey has more total complaints. According to the site’s Odyssey page, transmission problems lead the complaint categories, and failed transmissions are the most-reported problem on the 2002 model.
A transmission failure is among the costliest repairs a minivan owner can face. Shoppers looking at an older Odyssey should ask for service records and pay attention to how the van shifts on a test drive.
2. Toyota Sienna: A Cracking Dashboard

CarComplaints.com rates the 2007 Toyota Sienna as its worst model year, though the 2004 Sienna has more total complaints. According to the Sienna page, interior accessory problems lead the categories, and a cracking dashboard is the most-reported problem on the 2004 model.
A cracked dash is mostly cosmetic, but it is costly to replace and hard to ignore. Toyota’s reputation for durability keeps older Siennas in demand, so buyers should check the dashboard closely before paying a premium.
3. Chrysler Pacifica: Rust Under the Engine

CarComplaints.com rates the 2018 Chrysler Pacifica minivan as its worst model year, while the 2005 Pacifica, an earlier crossover that shared the name, has more total complaints. According to the site’s Pacifica page, body and paint problems lead, and a rusted motor cradle is the most-reported problem on the 2006 model.
The motor cradle supports the engine, so corrosion there is more than a cosmetic issue. Anyone shopping an older Pacifica should have the underside inspected on a lift.
4. Dodge Grand Caravan: Locks That Stop Working

CarComplaints.com rates the 2011 Dodge Grand Caravan as its worst model year, even though the 2008 Grand Caravan has more total complaints. According to the Grand Caravan page, electrical problems lead the categories, and power door locks that stop working are the most-reported problem on the 2005 model.
The Grand Caravan was one of the best-selling minivans for decades, so plenty of used examples are on the market. Testing every lock, sliding door and switch is a quick way to spot electrical gremlins.
5. Kia Sedona: An Engine That Ran Out of Oil

CarComplaints.com rates the 2016 Kia Sedona as its worst model year, though the 2015 Sedona has more total complaints. According to the site’s Sedona page, engine problems lead the categories, and the most-reported problem on the 2016 model is oil running out and the engine burning up.
Owners describe engines that consumed oil until they failed. Checking the oil level often and keeping receipts for oil changes can matter, especially if a warranty claim is ever needed.
6. Nissan Quest: Jerky Shifting

CarComplaints.com rates the 2007 Nissan Quest as its worst model year, even though the 2004 Quest has more total complaints. According to the Quest page, transmission problems lead the categories, and a transmission that jerks while driving is the most-reported problem on the 2007 model.
The Quest of this era had a bold, futuristic design, but owner reports point to drivetrain complaints. Buyers should feel for harsh or delayed shifts on a test drive and ask about past transmission repairs.
7. Kia Carnival: A Battery That Drains

CarComplaints.com rates the 2022 Kia Carnival as its worst model year, and that year also has the most complaints. According to the site’s Carnival page, the most-reported problem is a battery that drains to empty within two days of a full charge, reported on the 2025 model.
The Carnival replaced the Sedona and is styled to look more like an SUV than a traditional minivan. A battery that keeps dying can leave a family stranded, so owners should ask a dealer about any software updates or service campaigns.
8. Ford Edge: A Door Light That Stays On

CarComplaints.com rates the 2017 Ford Edge as its worst model year, though the 2013 Edge has more total complaints. According to the Edge page, electrical problems lead the categories, and a door ajar light that stays on is the most-reported problem on the 2013 model.
A stuck door ajar warning can keep interior lights on and drain the battery. Testing each door and watching the dash warning lights on a test drive can reveal the problem.
9. Buick Enclave: Transmission Failure

CarComplaints.com rates the 2008 Buick Enclave as its worst model year, and that year also has the most complaints. According to the site’s Enclave page, transmission problems lead the categories, and transmission failure is the most-reported problem on the 2008 model.
The 2008 was the Enclave’s first model year, and first-year vehicles often carry teething problems. Buyers considering an early Enclave should ask whether the transmission has already been repaired or replaced.
10. Nissan Murano: Broken Door Handles

CarComplaints.com rates the 2015 Nissan Murano as its worst model year, even though the 2004 Murano has more total complaints. According to the Murano page, transmission problems lead the categories, while a broken door handle is the most-reported single problem on the 2004 model.
The Murano was one of the early stylish midsize crossovers, and its continuously variable transmission drew complaints from owners. A thorough test drive and a check of each door handle are worth the time.
11. Honda HR-V: Seats Owners Disliked

CarComplaints.com rates the 2016 Honda HR-V as its worst model year, and that year also has the most complaints. According to the site’s HR-V page, interior accessory problems lead the categories, and uncomfortable seats are the most-reported problem on the 2016 model.
The 2016 was the HR-V’s first model year in the United States. Seat comfort is personal, so anyone shopping a used HR-V should take a longer test drive to see whether the seats suit them.
More from Morning Overview
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating