Skip to main content

Morning Overview

9 EVs and the year drivers had the most trouble

Electric vehicles have fewer moving parts than gas cars, but that does not make them immune to problems. Owner reports collected by CarComplaints.com show that some EV model years drew far more complaints than others. Here are nine electric vehicles and the year their drivers reported the most trouble.

Read next on Morning Overview: Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating

1. Tesla Model 3: Creaks From the Front End

Tesla Model 3 — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2020 Tesla Model 3 as its worst model year, even though the 2019 Model 3 has more total complaints. According to the site’s Model 3 page, the most-reported problem is a creaking sound from the front wheels on the 2019 model.

Owners of early Model 3s described clunks and creaks from the front suspension, often traced to control arms that wore prematurely. The Model 3 ramped up to high-volume production quickly in those years, and build quality complaints were common. Buyers should listen for noises over bumps on a test drive and check service history for suspension work.

2. Tesla Model Y: A Car That Will Not Wake Up

Tesla Model Y — Image Credit: Calreyn88 - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Calreyn88 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

The 2021 Tesla Model Y is both CarComplaints.com’s worst model year and the year with the most complaints. According to the Model Y page, the most-reported problem is a car that will not connect to the server to wake from sleep mode.

Teslas rely heavily on connectivity, and owners use the phone app as a key and remote control. When the car fails to wake, drivers can be locked out of features or unable to precondition the cabin. The 2021 was an early production year for the Model Y. Software updates have addressed some connectivity issues over time.

3. Tesla Model S: Door Handles That Quit

Tesla Model S — Image Credit: Niels de Wit from Lunteren, The Netherlands - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Niels de Wit from Lunteren, The Netherlands – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

For the Tesla Model S, CarComplaints.com rates 2013 as the worst model year, and that year also carries the most complaints. According to the site’s Model S page, the most-reported problem is a door handle or latch that stopped working.

The early Model S used motorized flush door handles that extend when the driver approaches. Owners reported handles failing to present, which can make it hard to get into the car. Tesla redesigned components over the years, and many early cars have had the handles repaired. Buyers should test every door before purchase.

4. Tesla Model X: Damage on Delivery

Tesla Model X — Image Credit: Michel Curi - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Michel Curi – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

The 2017 Tesla Model X is both CarComplaints.com’s worst model year and the year with the most complaints. According to the Model X page, the most-reported problem is a new car delivered with paint and frame damage.

The Model X’s complex falcon-wing doors and ambitious design made early production difficult, and quality control issues showed up in owner reports. Paint defects and panel gaps were frequent complaints. Shoppers considering a used 2017 Model X should inspect the paint and doors carefully and ask about any body repairs.

5. Chevrolet Bolt: Reduced Power Warnings

Chevrolet Bolt — Image Credit: Kevauto - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Kevauto – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

For the Chevrolet Bolt, CarComplaints.com rates 2017 as the worst model year, and that year also has the most complaints. According to the site’s Bolt page, the most-reported problem is a propulsion power reduced warning telling drivers to service the car immediately.

That warning can leave a driver with limited power on the road. The Bolt was also part of a major battery recall after a series of fires, and GM replaced battery packs in many cars. Anyone buying a used Bolt should confirm whether the battery has been replaced under the recall, which can make an older car a better buy.

6. Nissan Leaf: A Sensor That Fails

Nissan Leaf — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2015 Nissan Leaf as its worst model year, even though the 2011 Leaf has more total complaints. According to the Leaf page, the most-reported problem is an occupant classification system sensor failure on the 2011 model.

That sensor tells the airbag system whether someone is sitting in the passenger seat, so a failure can disable the passenger airbag. Nissan issued a recall for the problem on early Leafs. Battery capacity loss has also been a common concern for older Leafs, which lack active battery cooling, so a battery health check is wise.

7. Ford Mustang Mach-E: Rodents Eating Wiring

Ford Mustang Mach-E — Image Credit: Oleg Yunakov - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Oleg Yunakov – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2023 Ford Mustang Mach-E as its worst model year, even though the 2022 Mach-E has more total complaints. According to the site’s Mach-E page, the most-reported problem on the 2023 model is rodents eating the wiring.

Wiring damage from rodents is a problem that affects many modern vehicles, and some owners believe soy-based wire insulation attracts them. On an EV, damaged wiring can cause warning lights or leave the car undrivable. Owners in rural areas sometimes use deterrents. A pre-purchase inspection should include a look at under-hood wiring.

8. Rivian R1T: Repeated 12-Volt Battery Failures

Rivian R1T — Image Credit: Charles from Port Chester, New York - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Charles from Port Chester, New York – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

The 2023 Rivian R1T is both CarComplaints.com’s worst model year and the year with the most complaints. According to the R1T page, the most-reported problem is multiple failures of the 12-volt battery.

Even electric vehicles use a small 12-volt battery to power electronics and wake the main systems. When it fails, the truck may not start or unlock. Rivian has addressed some issues with software updates and service campaigns. The R1T is an early product from a young automaker, and owners have reported a range of first-generation glitches.

9. Ford F-150 Lightning: No Heat in the Cabin

Ford F-150 Lightning — Image Credit: WMrapids - CC0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: WMrapids – CC0/Wiki Commons

CarComplaints.com rates the 2023 Ford F-150 Lightning as its worst model year, even though the 2024 Lightning has more total complaints. According to the site’s Lightning page, the most-reported problem on the 2023 model is no cabin heat, with the heat set at 80 degrees but blowing cold.

A heater that fails in winter is more than an annoyance in an electric truck, where cabin heat also affects defrosting and visibility. The Lightning was Ford’s first electric pickup and an early high-volume EV truck. Buyers should test the heater thoroughly and ask whether any related software updates or repairs were completed.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.