Shopping for a late-model used car now means facing sticker prices that rival new ones. Karl Brauer, executive analyst at iSeeCars, says the average used car aged 1 to 5 years still costs more than $30,000. Against that backdrop, the cheapest way to buy years of driving in the latest iSeeCars ranking is a modest hatchback that Honda stopped building in 2020.
Read next on Morning Overview: Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
A 5-year-old Honda Fit lists for an average of $18,445 and is expected to keep running for another 10.9 years. Divide one by the other and the Fit costs $1,693 per remaining year, the lowest figure of any 5-year-old model in the study.
List price divided by remaining lifespan
The ranking comes from the iSeeCars “best used cars for the money” study, which analyzed prices of more than 900,000 five- and ten-year-old used cars sold between July and December 2025. For lifespan, iSeeCars drew on odometer readings from almost 400 million used cars in its separate longest-lasting-cars work. Each model’s average list price is divided by its expected remaining years, and the lowest price per year wins. Low-volume vehicles and sports cars were left out, and each segment list shows only models that beat the segment average.
That metric explains the oddity of the winner. The Fit is not cheap because it is old; at $18,445 it is hardly a bargain on the sticker. It wins because the expected lifespan is long relative to the price. A CarPro write-up of the study notes the Fit’s $1,693 is about half of the $3,310 average price per remaining year for a 5-year-old used car.
Run the same arithmetic on the runner-up SUV and the logic shows. Multiply the Buick Encore’s $2,084 by its 7.7 years and the implied list price is about $16,000, nearly $2,400 below the Fit’s average. The Fit still wins because it is expected to last about 3.2 years longer, so each year of use is spread across a bigger denominator.
Segment winners from SUVs to hybrids
The study splits the field by body style and age. Among 5-year-old SUVs, iSeeCars lists the Buick Encore at $2,084 per year with 7.7 years of life left. Among 5-year-old hybrids and EVs the leader is the Toyota Prius at $2,354. At 10 years old, the Jeep Compass leads SUVs at $1,647 and the Nissan Frontier leads trucks at $2,174.
The overall 10-year-old winner is a surprise on its own. The Nissan LEAF posts $1,108 per remaining year, from an average price of $5,675 and 5.1 years left, according to CarPro, which describes it as the first electric car to top the overall rankings. It is also a reminder that a low yearly figure can come from a very low price paired with a short remaining life, a very different purchase from a Fit with a decade ahead of it.
The study’s own framing of the Fit is also worth keeping in view: it compares a 5-year-old Fit with an average 5-year-old used car, not with a new one. At $3,310 per remaining year, the average 5-year-old car costs nearly twice as much per year of expected life, which is the real size of the Fit’s lead.
An earlier edition and the Fit’s slide in value
The Fit has won before. In the edition reported by Auto Remarketing, a 5-year-old Fit was expected to last another 11.6 years at an $18,336 list price, or $1,583 per remaining year, less than half the $3,426 average for 5-year-old used vehicles in that analysis. That earlier study drew on more than 700,000 used cars and over 368 million odometer readings and also put the Fit first among 10-year-old models at $1,358.
Brauer commented on prices then as well. In coverage of the February 2025 release on Fox 7 Austin, he said used car prices had dropped from their COVID-induced record highs but remained well above pre-COVID levels, and added that looming tariffs could push new and used prices up again. The Fit’s yearly cost has since moved from $1,583 to $1,693, a gap of $110 measured across different data windows and different lifespan estimates.
The lifespan inputs trace back to iSeeCars’ annual longevity research. Its 2024 edition, covered by Auto Dealer Today, evaluated more than 400 million vehicles, and Brauer said then that even 200,000 miles is not the end of the line for many cars. The Fit’s remaining-years estimate leans on that kind of odometer evidence rather than on any warranty or reliability rating.
Brauer’s own framing of the study is that reliability and remaining lifespan are the two most important factors for a used-car buyer. What the ranking cannot say is how any individual Fit has been treated. Because Honda discontinued the model in 2020, the supply of 5-year-old examples is fixed, and the study’s averages describe the cars that were actually sold from July to December 2025, not the ones a shopper will find on a lot next spring.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power