One man buried in medieval Svendborg, Denmark, was given a place of honor close to the monastery church. Radiocarbon dating then claimed he died between AD 1100 and 1155, which would put his death roughly a century before the Franciscan monastery existed.
The monastery was not founded until 1236, and the mismatch led Kaare Lund Rasmussen, professor emeritus at the University of Southern Denmark, to re-examine dates for 27 people buried at Danish monasteries. Six turned out to be wrong.
Svendborg skeleton III9B and the monasteries that did not exist yet
According to a university news release issued on Nov. 10, the 27 people were buried at some of Denmark’s roughly 140 medieval monasteries, in monastic cemeteries or inside churches. Because burial near the church was prestigious, every one of them must have been interred after the monastery and church were built. A date that predates the building, therefore, has to be an error.
Six dates failed that test, including the Svendborg skeleton, labeled III9B. A burial at a monastery in Viborg returned a date range ending no later than AD 976, more than 200 years before the monastery was built, and three burials at the Cistercian monastery at Øm showed the same problem, according to the university’s Nov. 5 article. Rasmussen worked with Johannes van der Plicht of the Center for Isotope Research in Groningen and Jesper Lie Boldsen of the university’s Department of Forensic Medicine.
Old carbon from rivers and lakes enters the bone
The mechanism lies in how radiocarbon dating works. Freshwater fish can carry old carbon from lake and river sediments, which has less carbon-14, and people who ate a lot of those fish end up with bones that look older than they are. “If someone ate a lot of freshwater fish during their lifetime, their bones can appear older than they really are,” Rasmussen said.
The size of the distortion varies. In an extreme case, a fish from the Rhine can appear up to 1,300 years older than a land organism from the same time. The freshwater effect across cases ranges from zero to about 1,000 years, so no fixed subtraction repairs it. At Dorestad on the Rhine in the Netherlands the discrepancy was 250 years, and in the Danube region, human bones appeared 300 to 500 years older than animal-bone arrowheads embedded in them.
The sea is easier to handle. The saltwater effect is about 400 years in the North Sea, and it is more predictable and can be corrected with a known value, according to the release. The researchers call the freshwater version the “freshwater trap,” Archaeology Magazine reported, because subtracting a fixed figure does not fix the error.
The Danish errors were catchable only because the burial context supplied a hard floor. A monastery’s founding year says that nobody could have been interred before it, so a date earlier than 1236 at Svendborg, or earlier than the building at Viborg and Øm, exposes itself. A skeleton from a site with no such anchor, dated to the same range, would pass without comment, and the release’s own headline for the work, “Archaeological trap: Fish can make skeletons appear hundreds of years too old,” describes that risk.
Fast days, Richard III and what a correction can and cannot repair
Medieval Catholic Europe supplied the demand for fish. There were around 180 fasting days a year when meat was off the menu, and freshwater fish was allowed because it was considered “cold” and “neutral.” In some places eating fish was prestigious, which helps explain the strong signal in some skeletons.
The new paper in npj Heritage Science carries Rasmussen, van der Plicht and Boldsen’s “word of warning” to archaeologists. The release links the pattern to the best-known case in English history, noting that radiocarbon dating of the bones of King Richard III placed his death between 1412 and 1460, though he died in battle in 1485.
Historic England’s case study of the 2012 Grey Friars excavation shows what the repair looks like. Four rib samples, measured at Oxford and SUERC, gave a weighted mean of 451 plus or minus 11 years before present. Uncorrected, that calibrates to cal AD 1432 to 1454, which at face value would predate Richard’s death in 1485 and exclude him. A diet model estimated that eel and freshwater fish made up 56.7 percent of his diet, and with a freshwater correction the range stretched to cal AD 1459 to 1539, no longer excluding him. The wide range, the authors say, reflects the uncertainty in the freshwater correction, which historical evidence then constrains. A Bayesian analysis combining genetic and non-genetic evidence, including mitochondrial DNA that matched a living relative exactly, gave what the case study calls “extremely strong support for the probability that the skeleton in the car park is that of King Richard III.”
What remains unknown is how many other medieval burials across Europe carry a similar hidden error, since the Danish team re-examined only 27 of them.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating