Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Curiosity’s air samples hint at hidden films of liquid-like water in Mars’ soil

Each Martian spring, the thin carbon dioxide air above Gale Crater changes in a way nobody planned to look for. A little more of the heavy oxygen isotope, oxygen-18, shows up in the gas, then fades as the year turns. NASA’s Curiosity rover has now logged that rhythm across 13 years, and a team led by a NASA scientist says the best explanation is water.

The water they propose is not ice and not a pond. Heather Franz, an isotope geochemist at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, and colleagues point to thin, liquid-like films on the surface or clinging to soil grains.

Thirteen years of Gale Crater air

The study appeared in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences on Nov. 16, titled “A decadal record of isotopic trends in martian atmospheric CO2.” Gizmodo’s report says the data come from Curiosity’s Sample Analysis at Mars instrument suite, which measured atmospheric carbon dioxide from 2012 through 2025. Franz described it as the first time measurements of this type “have been possible on Mars.”

NASA’s mission page says Curiosity launched on Nov. 26, 2011, and landed on Aug. 6, 2012, and that it explores Gale Crater while acquiring rock, soil and air samples for onboard analysis. By the mission’s 14th year the rover had climbed 1 kilometer in elevation up the slope of Mount Sharp.

The oxygen-18 pattern and the water explanation

The team found no significant difference between day and night. What they did see was a rise in the proportion of oxygen-18 during spring and summer, according to Gizmodo. They then tested several explanations in computer models. Only the exchange of oxygen isotopes between carbon dioxide and water could reproduce the observed oxygen-18 levels, Franz said, and the water involved, per the paper’s modeling, would have to appear during the warmest part of the Martian year rather than sit locked in ice.

The films could be several molecules thick, and the exchange may involve individual molecules rather than anything resembling a puddle, Gizmodo reports. Franz, who said the work has the researchers following the water again, called the result unexpected: “This is not what anyone expected” when the measurements began at the start of the mission, she said.

A seasonal clue that has surprised the team before

Curiosity’s air measurements have produced seasonal puzzles before. A NASA visualization of the rover’s data records that molecular oxygen, 0.16% of the air, rose by as much as 30% in spring and summer, then fell back in autumn to the levels predicted by known chemistry. Carbon dioxide, 95% of the air by volume, freezes over the poles in winter and returns to the atmosphere in spring and summer. Researchers concluded that “something was producing it and then taking it away.” The pattern repeated each spring across three Mars years, nearly six Earth years, and scientists could not yet explain it through known chemical processes.

Liquid water on today’s Mars has a contested history too. In 2015, JPL reported that Curiosity’s weather and soil data, combined with perchlorate salt, suggested small amounts of liquid brine could form in the soil on some nights near the equator and evaporate after sunrise. Javier Martin-Torres of the Spanish Research Council and Lulea University of Technology led that study. Curiosity was the first mission to measure near-surface relative humidity at all times of day and across all seasons, with readings from about 5% on summer afternoons to 100% on autumn and winter nights. Ashwin Vasavada of JPL was blunt about the limits, saying brines had not been detected.

Later that year, NASA announced that orbital data suggested briny water flows intermittently on steep slopes. John Grunsfeld, an astronaut and associate administrator of NASA’s Science Mission Directorate at the time, said it appeared “to confirm that water — albeit briny — is flowing today on the surface of Mars.” The article hedged, calling the flows likely shallow, and the perchlorate identification an interpretation of spectral signatures.

Limits of the isotope evidence

The new evidence is indirect. It rests on isotope ratios in the atmosphere rather than a detection of water, and the films are described as extremely thin. The exchange of oxygen isotopes between carbon dioxide and water was the only process Franz’s models found capable of matching the data, which is a statement about the mechanisms tested, not about every possible one. Gizmodo adds that the water would be a different thing from the ice at the polar caps or the subsurface reservoirs usually discussed.

Franz said she hopes future missions collect similar data elsewhere on Mars to show how widespread the carbon dioxide and water exchange is, and the work could reveal more about subsurface water in other regions. Until another mission makes such a measurement away from Gale Crater, one rover’s record from one crater remains the only evidence of the seasonal thin-film cycle.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview


Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.