Of the 6,258 e-scooter riders in a new national trauma analysis, only 13% had a helmet use recorded on their charts. Those who landed in a trauma center were 10% more likely to suffer a serious head or neck injury than injured bicycle riders, even after the researchers adjusted for differences in who rides and how they crash.
The comparison covers 47,102 adults treated at participating U.S. trauma centers in 2023 and 2024, and it cuts in more than one direction.
What the trauma database shows
The work, “Micromobility Injury Patterns and Resource Use in US Trauma Centers,” appeared in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons and was announced on Nov. 17 by the American College of Surgeons. Lead author Behzad Abbasi, a postdoctoral fellow at the University of California, San Francisco, and senior author Benjamin Breyer, a UCSF urology professor, drew on the ACS National Trauma Data Bank, which collects submissions from more than 900 emergency departments, trauma centers and other institutions.
Bicycles accounted for 32,100 cases, or 68%. E-bikes made up 8,744, or 19%, and e-scooters 6,258, or 13%. Recorded e-bike cases rose 44% from 2023 to 2024. The team compared injury severity, body regions hurt, in-hospital deaths and use of services such as emergency surgery and blood transfusion.
Head and neck risk, and where scooters fared better
The adjusted risk of a serious head or neck injury was 10% higher for e-scooter riders than for bicycle riders. On other measures, scooters looked less dangerous. Their adjusted risk of a severe or critical injury overall was 7% lower, and the adjusted risks of emergency surgery, early transfusion and in-hospital death were also lower. Sixteen percent of injured e-scooter riders had severe or critical injuries, against 21% of bicycle riders and 19% of e-bike riders, and 3.2% of bicycle riders died in the hospital. After adjustment, e-bike riders did not differ significantly from cyclists in the risk of severe or critical injury.
Circumstances differed sharply. Only 33% of e-scooter injuries were traffic-related, compared with 72% of bicycle injuries and 74% of e-bike injuries. Collisions caused 48% of scooter injuries, 63% of bicycle injuries and 59% of e-bike injuries.
Helmets and alcohol
Helmet use was documented for 33% of bicycle riders and 32% of e-bike riders but just 13% of e-scooter riders. Across all three devices, wearing one was tied to a 12% lower adjusted risk of severe injury and fewer craniofacial fractures. For e-scooter riders specifically, a helmet was associated with a 69% lower adjusted risk of skull fracture and a 45% lower adjusted risk of facial fracture. Abbasi called helmet use “One of the clearest findings” of the study.
Alcohol appeared in the records as well. A blood alcohol level of 0.08% or higher, the U.S. legal driving threshold, was recorded for 19% of e-scooter riders, 16% of e-bike riders and 9.4% of bicycle riders. After adjustment, that level was not significantly associated with severe or critical injury, and the authors noted the recorded percentages may understate actual intoxication. Breyer’s advice was blunt. Riders, he said, should treat the devices “like a car,” meaning obey traffic laws, stay sober and wear a helmet.
Limits and the wider injury picture
The authors list their own limits. Only injured adults treated at participating trauma centers were included, and the database does not record trips taken on each device, so it cannot show which one carries the highest injury risk per trip. It also lacks details such as riding speed and road conditions.
The study joins a rising count. The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s micromobility report for 2017 to 2024 estimates 698,500 emergency-department-treated injuries over the period, including 380,000 from e-scooters and 155,200 from e-bikes, and 533 deaths, up from 5 in 2017 to 135 in 2024. A 2024 UCSF analysis of emergency-department data, with Breyer as senior author, found e-scooter injuries growing about 45% a year from 2017 to 2022, reaching 56,847 in 2022, and noted that helmet use was lower among electric-vehicle riders.
Earlier work found a different pattern in hospital admissions. A January 2024 analysis of 92,815 admissions from 2016 to 2020, led by Peyman Benharash of UCLA Health, found scooter hospitalizations nearly tripled and that traumatic brain injury risk was similar between scooter and bicycle patients. Its authors noted that helmet use and intoxicants were not captured in that database. Children appear in the newest conference data. An abstract presented Oct. 3 at the American Academy of Pediatrics conference, released Oct. 2, reviewed 379 patients at a single Los Angeles pediatric hospital between 2019 and 2025. Annual cases rose from 33 to 124, e-scooters accounted for 77% of them, and head injuries were the third most common location at 39%. It was an abstract rather than a peer-reviewed article.
The College’s own September release on a separate set of studies found e-scooter trauma admissions rose 92%, from 2,311 in 2021 to 4,430 in 2023, with helmet use documented in 12.1% of admissions. Those abstracts had not been peer reviewed when released.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power