Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Webb finally caught a ‘forbidden’ glow physicists predicted decades ago

For forty years a signal from one of the most abundant molecular ions in space existed only on paper. Astronomers had searched for it, and so had laboratory spectroscopists, without success. Now the James Webb Space Telescope has recorded it, 26 separate spectral lines of it, in a jet-driven shock about 700 parsecs away.

The molecule is the trihydrogen cation, H3+, and the glow Webb caught is its “forbidden” rotational emission, which ScienceAlert says Fu-Shih Pan and Takeshi Oka of the University of Chicago predicted in 1986 and which, in the outlet’s words, “has eluded every search.”

A transition physics calls forbidden

H3+ is an equilateral triangle of three hydrogen nuclei sharing two electrons. A symmetric shape like that has no permanent electric dipole moment, and without one a molecule normally cannot radiate by changing its rotation. ScienceAlert’s account explains the loophole: as the ion spins, centrifugal force slightly distorts the triangle, creating a tiny dipole that permits very weak transitions. The researchers’ own abstract describes a spectrum “made possible by centrifugal distortion.”

The ion matters because it sits at the start of interstellar chemistry. It forms when cosmic rays ionize molecular hydrogen, and the resulting H2+ reacts with H2, according to the paper’s introduction. H3+ then passes protons to other species. Its ordinary vibrational signature had been seen in Jupiter’s ionosphere and in interstellar absorption, where it helps astronomers measure the cosmic-ray ionization rate in diffuse clouds. A search for the rotational lines in Jupiter’s auroral emission had failed, and an upper limit set toward the Orion protoplanetary disk d203-506 had also come up empty of a detection. NASA’s Webb coverage of Jupiter’s aurora notes that H3+ forms there when high-energy electrons strike molecular hydrogen, and that its emission there is far more variable than previously believed. Lead researcher Jonathan Nichols described the whole auroral region as “fizzing and popping with light, sometimes varying by the second.”

What Webb’s Mid-Infrared Instrument recorded in HH 168

The detection comes from a team led by David Neufeld of Johns Hopkins University, with Joel Green of the Space Telescope Science Institute, Dan Watson of the University of Rochester and Paule Sonnentrucker of STScI and the European Space Agency. Their paper, posted to arXiv on Nov. 6 and accepted by The Astrophysical Journal Letters, reports “the first detection” of the pure rotational spectrum of H3+, toward the Herbig-Haro object HH 168 in the Cepheus A star-forming region.

Herbig-Haro objects are glowing patches where jets or winds from newborn stars slam into surrounding gas at high speed, NASA explains. HH 168 lies about 700 parsecs away, far from confusing starlight, and the team used the Medium Resolution Spectrometer on Webb’s MIRI instrument, covering roughly 4.9 to 27.9 microns, in observations dated Aug. 1, 2026.

The paper reports 26 lines detected above 5 sigma. The strongest, at 16.325 microns, reached 72 sigma in one field and 49 sigma in another. That line had been singled out in earlier work by Goicoechea and colleagues as the one JWST might be able to see.

Archival Webb data on a second object, the HH 211 bow shock, show the same forbidden spectrum, the authors add, so HH 168 is not a one-off. NASA’s earlier Webb imaging describes HH 211 as an outflow from a Class 0 protostar, an “infantile analog” of the Sun, only a few tens of thousands of years old with about 8% of the Sun’s current mass, and its jet shows bow shocks on both sides in Webb’s near-infrared images, with roughly five to ten times the detail of earlier pictures.

A brightness the shock models struggle to match

The emission shares the velocity and spatial distribution of hot shocked molecular hydrogen, the paper says, rather than that of ionized gas. A rotation diagram gives a temperature of about 730 kelvin, but the level populations are not thermal, and the authors favor sub-thermal excitation in gas hotter than 2,000 kelvin.

The models disagree. A dissociative J-type shock predicts H3+ emission within a factor of about 1.5 of what was seen, while a nondissociative C-type shock fits the molecular hydrogen lines better but falls short on H3+ by a factor of five to six. ScienceAlert adds that the model matching H3+ more closely used conditions outside its validated range, so the brightness remains unexplained. The authors also say the rates for exciting H3+ by energetic collisions are poorly known, which adds uncertainty.

What the field does not yet know is which shock picture is right. The J-type model reproduces H3+ but strains its own limits, and the C-type model respects them but misses the ion’s brightness by a factor of five or six. The authors flag the poorly known rates for H3+ excitation by energetic collisions as a source of uncertainty, and the 16.325-micron line, now measured at 72 sigma, gives theorists a measured benchmark to test against once those rates are firmer.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview


Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.