Around 3000 B.C., when the first kings of a unified Egypt were buried at Abydos, rows of smaller graves were dug around their tombs. The people placed in them were the king’s attendants, and a century ago the archaeologist who excavated them suspected they had been killed to accompany their ruler in death.
Read next on Morning Overview: Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge
A new forensic study of their skulls supports that grim idea. Of 46 skulls examined, 18 show fractures that happened at or around the time of death, injuries that Purdue University bioarchaeologist Roselyn Campbell concludes are consistent with retainer sacrifice.
Petrie’s Abydos skulls in the Duckworth Collection
The skulls come from excavations by Flinders Petrie in the 1920s at the First Dynasty royal burial complexes of Abydos, where some royal sites were surrounded by hundreds of subsidiary graves. Most of the remains Petrie dug up were reburied, but he kept a selection of skulls, some of which ended up in the Duckworth Collection at the University of Cambridge. Petrie found grave markers with names and titles for some of the individuals, mostly lower- or mid-level officials and artisans, not captives or foreign enemies. That detail matters for interpretation: these were people who had served the court, and their burial in an orderly ring around the king suggests they were interred at the same time as part of a planned funeral.
Campbell’s paper, “New data from old bones: using bioarchaeology and forensics to reassess legacy data from ancient Abydos, Egypt,” was published in Frontiers in Environmental Archaeology. ScienceDaily carried the release on Nov. 13, 2026, and Frontiers’ own announcement describes it as an application of modern forensic methods to century-old evidence.
The royal cemetery at Abydos, known today as Umm el-Qa’ab, holds the tombs of Egypt’s earliest pharaohs, along with funerary enclosures closer to the floodplain where ceremonies for the dead kings are thought to have taken place. Abydos remained one of Egypt’s most sacred places for thousands of years afterward, later becoming the center of the cult of Osiris, god of the dead. The subsidiary graves laid out in neat rows around the First Dynasty tombs are among the earliest evidence of how those first rulers displayed power, and why they did so with human lives has been argued over since Petrie’s day.
18 of 46 skulls with perimortem fractures
Petrie had noticed cracks in the skulls but attributed them to natural processes after burial. Re-examining the collection, Campbell identified the damage on 18 of the 46 skulls, about 39 percent, as perimortem, meaning it occurred around the time of death rather than long after. “The injuries on the preserved crania are generally linear fractures,” she said, and some of the 18 also show sharp-force trauma, including a chopping injury near one individual’s eye.
“Modern forensic methods made it possible to identify the fractures as perimortem injuries,” Campbell said. Bone that breaks while still fresh and moist fractures differently from dry, old bone, leaving edges and patterns that forensic anthropologists can distinguish.
The case for retainer sacrifice
“Retainer sacrifice is a type of human sacrifice where those close to a ruler are killed when the ruler dies,” Campbell explained, possibly so they could continue serving the ruler in the afterlife. Petrie proposed that interpretation for Abydos, but evidence for it has been debated, and Campbell noted that the retainers have mostly been relegated to footnotes in the grander narrative of early Egypt.
Campbell weighed other explanations. The fractures do not match blows from a mace, which tend to leave depressed fractures, and the people buried were not enemy combatants. Accidental falls cannot be ruled out completely, but a fall hard enough to fracture a skull would likely have left other skeletal damage, and none was documented. The pattern of linear fractures among people buried at the same time beside a king is what fits the sacrifice explanation best.
Limits of century-old evidence
The study has clear gaps that come from its source material. Most of the bodies below the skull were not kept, so injuries elsewhere on the skeleton cannot be checked. The causes of death for the other 28 individuals are unknown; some may have died naturally, and others may have been killed by methods that leave no mark on bone, such as asphyxiation. The sample is also only what Petrie chose to keep, not a random selection of the graves.
Campbell is expanding the work into a book, State-sanctioned Violence and Human Sacrifice in Early Dynastic Egypt, for Routledge. She has said that with unlimited resources she would want to find where the bodies of the reburied retainers ended up, which could fill in the injuries the skulls alone cannot show. The practice of retainer burial at Abydos appears to have faded after the First Dynasty, and the question of how many of those attendants died willingly, if any, is one the bones may never fully answer.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating