Skip to main content

Morning Overview

A retiring Michigan coal plant is set to cost ratepayers $303 million under emergency orders

The J.H. Campbell coal plant in Michigan was supposed to close on May 17, 2025. More than 530 days later it is still on call, held open by a string of federal “emergency” orders, and the bill keeps growing for the electricity customers who will ultimately pay it.

Read next on Morning Overview: Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record

The Department of Energy has now issued a seventh order keeping Campbell available, this time through mid-February, even though a federal appeals court ruled in September that the first order was unlawful. The plant’s owner, Consumers Energy, puts the cost of the orders at $303 million through the end of September.

A seventh order after a court said the first was unlawful

As Electrek’s Jameson Dow reported, the latest order is another 90-day directive, issued 534 days after the plant’s planned retirement. The department is simultaneously asking the appeals court to rehear its earlier decision. In a recent filing, Consumers Energy said: “From the date the first emergency order became effective through September 30, 2026, the amount Consumers expects to seek recovery from FERC associated with the emergency orders, including amounts already requested, is $303 million.”

The recovery request goes to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which decides how the costs are shared among utility customers. In other words, the $303 million is the figure the utility intends to pass through to ratepayers, not an amount it plans to absorb. The costs have climbed quickly: in March, the company said it had spent $42 million keeping the plant ready over a single 90-day order, and by September the running total cited in court coverage had passed $259 million.

On September 11, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit sided with Michigan, Minnesota, Illinois and nine public interest groups and vacated the department’s first order for Campbell, finding that no emergency justified it. After that ruling, Environmental Defense Fund lead counsel Ted Kelly said he hoped the department “will recognize that this decision eliminates its basis for arguing that any of the renewals are lawful” and would let Campbell and the other plants retire.

Section 202(c), a last-resort power used for over a year

The orders rely on Section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act, a provision that lets the Energy Department require a plant to run during a genuine grid emergency. In normal use, it grants a few hours or days of extra operation during events such as winter storms. EDF’s analysis of the orders describes it as a last resort meant for imminent, unexpected shortfalls and limited to the minimum operation necessary.

The administration has used it far more broadly. For over a year, the department has applied 202(c) orders to units at six aging coal plants and one natural gas plant in six states, each of them past a long-planned retirement date. The owners of some of those plants have filed objections of their own; in Colorado, the owners of a broken plant ordered to reopen asked the department to reconsider, and in Washington the order covers a plant that is not even running, and every order faces legal challenges similar to the one that succeeded against Campbell.

Campbell stands out among them. EDF found that the plant emitted the most nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide and particulate matter of any plant under the orders, a direct result of how long it has been kept running. By June 30, 2026, Campbell’s unit 1 alone had produced well over 1,000 tons of nitrogen oxides and over 2,000 tons of sulfur dioxide, and the plant as a whole had emitted almost 140 tons of particulate matter.

Who pays as the costs climb past $600 million nationwide

Campbell’s $303 million sits on top of costs from the other plants under emergency orders. Electrek puts the national total above $600 million from the orders alone. EDF’s coal costs tracker estimates that $593 million will be billed to ratepayers under the department’s coal plant mandates, in addition to more than $950 million in direct taxpayer support the department has committed to 24 coal plants, including help financing two new plants and bringing one retired plant back online.

The administration argues the orders protect grid reliability. Opponents, including the states that sued, argue there was no emergency to begin with, a position the D.C. Circuit accepted in September. The practical result for Michigan customers is that a plant scheduled to close in the spring of 2025 is still generating costs nearly two years later.

The $303 million figure also stops at September 30, so it does not yet include any of the costs from the latest order. The new order runs into February, and the rehearing request will decide whether the appeals court revisits its ruling. If the court holds to its decision, the remaining question is whether the department keeps issuing 90-day orders against it, and how much higher than $303 million the Campbell tally climbs before the plant is finally allowed to retire.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.