Wholesale electricity across the PJM Interconnection cost 40.9% more in the first nine months of 2026 than in the same stretch of 2025, rising from $79.19 to $111.61 per megawatt-hour. The grid’s own independent market monitor says a large share of the jump traces back to one decision: counting forecast data center demand in the capacity auctions.
Read next on Morning Overview: A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
That monitor, Monitoring Analytics, put a dollar figure on the damage on Thursday, Nov. 12, in its third-quarter market report. Its verdict on PJM, the largest U.S. grid operator, was blunt enough that trade outlets described the grid as having failed to protect ratepayers.
The $29.4 billion capacity-market estimate
The monitor estimates that including data center load in PJM’s capacity market has produced an irreversible increase of about $29.4 billion in capacity costs for all customers so far, by its own wording in the Nov. 12 press release. Energy News Beat’s breakdown of the monitor’s analysis spreads the figure across four auctions that have already run: $9.33 billion for the 2025/26 delivery year, $7.27 billion for 2026/27, $6.50 billion for 2027/28 and $6.27 billion for 2028/29.
The full quarterly report goes further than the cost tally. It rates the capacity market as not competitive, pointing to structural market power and design flaws, and it attributes the poor results mainly to forecast data center demand in the auctions for the 2025/2026 through 2028/2029 delivery years. Without those data center effects on capacity prices, the report says, the nine-month wholesale figure for 2026 would have been $101.66 per megawatt-hour instead of $111.61.
Data center load behind the 40.9% increase
Capacity is only one slice. The report puts the rise in energy costs at 46.3%, capacity costs at 81.1% and transmission at 4.6%, and those three components make up 98.1% of the total cost of wholesale power. The real-time load-weighted average locational marginal price climbed 48.4% to $74.98 per megawatt-hour. The monitor rates the energy market as competitive overall, though it flags problems with transmission constraint penalty factors and local market power.
Reliability fared no better. PJM fell short of its reliability target for the June 2025 and June 2026 delivery years, and the projected shortfall grows from 208.7 megawatts for 2026/2027 to 6,831.3 megawatts for 2028/2029. Customers are paying more while the grid procures less margin than its own standard calls for, which is the core of the monitor’s complaint.
Joseph Bowring’s analysis concludes the capacity auctions were not competitive, primarily as a result of the inclusion of forecast demand for data centers, according to the same Energy News Beat account. The monitor’s report also projects a further $5 billion to $10 billion in added costs from the 2029/2030 auction, a forecast rather than a result.
The report also lists fixes beyond data centers: improving the effective load carrying capability method PJM uses to rate generators, eliminating performance-assessment interval risk, strengthening market power mitigation, and addressing transmission, fuel supply and dual-fuel capacity problems. It adds two new recommendations, a standard demand response contract and changes to regulation opportunity cost calculations, and marks both as not adopted by PJM so far. Those items show the monitor treating the data center problem as one failure inside a market it believes needs broader repair, not as the only defect. Together with the shortfall figures, they frame the December auction as a test of whether the grid can add supply fast enough to match the load it is forecasting.
PJM’s answer and the December auction
The monitor is asking for specific changes. It wants forecast data center load removed from upcoming auctions, a postponement of the auction scheduled for Dec. 9 to 15 considered, and a requirement that data centers bring their own new generation, backed by a targeted backstop auction and an interconnection queue that holds projects until adequate capacity exists.
PJM does not accept the premise that it controls who bears the cost. Spokesman Jeffrey Shields told the Pennsylvania Capital-Star that how data center costs are shared is a matter for state regulators, and that PJM’s proposals include clear pathways for states to allocate those impacts, as relayed in the Energy News Beat report. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has not required a delay of the December auction, and PJM has not postponed it.
Bloomberg ran the story on Nov. 12 as a rebuke of the largest U.S. grid, while Energy Central’s summary framed the same findings as PJM having failed to protect ratepayers from data center-driven price spikes. The word “failed” is the outlet’s framing; the monitor’s own release speaks of an irreversible cost increase and recommends fixes.
One caveat matters when reading the numbers. The $29.4 billion mixes existing and forecast data center load, and it is a capacity-market figure, not a household bill total and not comparable to the $70.81 billion wholesale cost the monitor reports for January through September. Whether the December auction goes ahead unchanged will show how much of the monitor’s advice PJM and its regulators accept.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part