Skip to main content

Morning Overview

A Cirrus SR22 declared an emergency a minute after departure clearance, its parachute still bagged

A Cirrus SR22 had been cleared for departure from a Lake of the Ozarks airport in Missouri for about a minute when its pilot radioed Springfield Approach, said the flight was returning to the airport and declared an emergency. Controllers got one short, distressed transmission when they asked what was wrong. Radio and radar contact were then gone.

Read next on Morning Overview: Tesla’s Cybercab has already crashed 8 times, and the worst one came at highway speed

The plane crashed into woods less than half a nautical mile from the runway. Investigators later found the airplane’s whole-airframe parachute still in its deployment bag, heat-damaged, under the tail.

A minute after clearance

The facts come from the preliminary report of the National Transportation Safety Board, case CEN27FA037, as summarized by AeroCorner on Nov. 14. The NTSB docket page could not be reached for this article, so every detail here rests on that summary and on local accounts. The report is marked preliminary and subject to change, and it assigns no cause.

The airplane, a 2005 SR22 registered N313DG and operated by Thoroughbred Flying Club Inc. on a personal flight, had left Clark Regional Airport in Jeffersonville, Indiana, bound for Wichita, Kansas. It landed at Lee C. Fine Memorial Airport at about 12:57 p.m. Central on Nov. 3 for fuel. The pilot asked for the tanks to be topped off, and a truck dispensed 47 gallons of 100LL.

At about 2:07 p.m. the pilot called Springfield Approach for an instrument clearance to Wichita and was told to fly heading 240 degrees on entering controlled airspace. About a minute after receiving the departure clearance came the emergency call. The NTSB puts the accident at 2:09 p.m. The report gives no altitude for when the emergency was declared, and a nearby driver saw the airplane pitch down and descend in a right turn, though the witness did not see the impact.

Wreckage and the unopened parachute

The airplane came down in woods about 0.43 nautical miles southwest of the departure end of runway 22. A post-impact fire destroyed most of the composite fuselage, wings and tail, so some questions may stay unanswerable: the fire prevented examination of the fuel system, though post-accident fuel samples were blue with no sign of contamination. Flaps were fully retracted. Control cable continuity could not be confirmed, with separations consistent with overstress, heat or cuts made during recovery.

The engine, a Continental IO-550-series, showed continuity of the crankshaft, and a borescope check of all six cylinders found no mechanical failure of pistons or valves. Two of three propeller blades remained on the hub, bent aft and twisted toward low pitch, and all three showed rotational scoring. Three tree branches at the site had 45-degree angular cuts; the report, per AeroCorner, does not say what that indicates. Visual conditions prevailed at the airport at 1:56 p.m.: 10 miles of visibility, a few clouds at 1,600 feet and wind from 180 degrees at 12 knots, gusting to 19.

The parachute

The SR22 carries the Cirrus Airframe Parachute System, and the report’s findings on it are specific. The chute was found under the horizontal stabilizer still in its deployment bag, with its enclosure cover about 5 feet north of the tail. The rocket was not found at the site. In the cockpit, the activation handle had melted around the cable end and no safety pin was observed; the cable was continuous from the handle to the ignition switch, and the switch’s fire-pin actuator was found pulled down. The NTSB has not said whether the handle was pulled in flight.

The system works by a pilot pulling the overhead handle, which drags a cable to an igniter that fires a solid-fuel rocket to extract the canopy, as AeroCorner’s explainer describes it. The same explainer says Cirrus advises deploying at or above 2,000 feet above ground when possible and that the airplane’s handbook sets no minimum altitude, though Cirrus testing showed altitude loss of under 400 feet from level flight. The Cirrus Owners and Pilots Association states that “No person has died when CAPS deployed higher than 1000 feet above the ground,” and the association’s CAPS page pairs that with the slogan “Pull Early, Pull Often!”

The AOPA’s account of the system’s record says official minimum deployment altitude is 400 feet above ground in level flight, and notes that some past pulls came at too high an airspeed or too low an altitude to work. That AOPA review from 2016 counted 79 deployments up to that date.

Who was aboard, what comes next

The Missouri State Highway Patrol said troopers responded to the crash at about 3 p.m. and confirmed two deaths. The Miller County Coroner’s Office identified the dead as John Peterson, 52, and Michelle Peterson, 51, of Simpsonville, Kentucky, according to AeroCorner’s earlier crash report. Neither the NTSB nor officials have said who was flying.

The NTSB’s spokeswoman, Jennifer Gabris, said investigators would examine the pilot, the aircraft and the operating environment. Damaged flight displays, an autopilot controller and navigation and communication units went to the agency’s Vehicle Recorder Laboratory, and Cirrus, Hartzell, Continental and the FAA are parties to the probe. The agency generally aims to finish within 12 to 24 months, leaving open the central question of whether anyone reached for the handle.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.