Bigger and taller does not always mean safer. An iSeeCars analysis of federal fatal-crash data ranked vehicles by fatal accidents per billion miles driven, and a surprising number of popular SUVs and pickups landed well above their class averages. Here are sixteen of them, from small crossovers with top crash-test scores to off-roaders and midsize trucks.
Read next on Morning Overview: Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge
1. Hyundai Venue: Top of Every List

The Hyundai Venue posted 13.9 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles, the worst rate among SUVs and among all vehicle types combined, Jalopnik reports from the iSeeCars study of NHTSA data.
That is 4.9 times the 2.8 average for all vehicles and 6.3 times the 2.2 SUV average. Oddly, the Venue carries no flashing red warnings from IIHS or NHTSA, and Consumer Reports still recommends it as a cheap buy.
2. Honda CR-V Hybrid: A Family Favorite Stings

The Honda CR-V Hybrid came in second among SUVs at 13.2 fatal accidents per billion miles, according to Jalopnik’s breakdown of the iSeeCars figures.
It holds five stars from NHTSA, and its 2025 IIHS results were dinged only by the tougher updated front crash test. The data is a little murky, Jalopnik notes, because the study singled out the hybrid while that variant was not always counted separately elsewhere.
3. Tesla Model Y: Safe on Paper

Few crossovers have better lab scores than the Tesla Model Y, which holds an IIHS Top Safety Pick+ and five stars from NHTSA. Real-world data still put it at 10.6 fatal accidents per billion miles, Jalopnik found.
The site offers possible reasons rather than proof: drivers using Autopilot where it was not designed to work, and door handles that can become inoperable after a crash, trapping occupants, with up to 15 deaths attributed to that scenario.
4. Buick Encore GX: A Puzzling Buick

Introduced in 2020 to replace the original Encore, the Buick Encore GX logged 9.8 fatal accidents per billion miles, according to Jalopnik.
That is more than quadruple the rate for SUVs as a whole. NHTSA gave it five stars, it improved in IIHS testing over the previous generation, and Jalopnik found no glaring safety concerns, calling it a puzzling entry it could not fully explain.
5. Buick Envision: Younger Drivers Than You Think

The Buick Envision recorded 8 fatal accidents per billion miles despite respectable crash ratings and no glaring negative IIHS marks since its 2016 U.S. debut, Jalopnik reports.
Its buyers may surprise you. Most Envision buyers were new to Buick and represented the youngest demographic across all General Motors products, leading GM buyers aged 18 to 35. The SUV also comes loaded with driver-assistance safety features.
6. Kia Seltos: Where the Ratings Slip

At 6.8 fatal accidents per billion miles, the Kia Seltos is the first model on Jalopnik’s list whose IIHS results include Marginal and Poor ratings.
Marginal marks came for seat belt reminders and side impact, and Poor marks for front crash prevention and one of its headlight options, which vary by trim. In fairness, Jalopnik notes, the Seltos was largely dinged for how well its driver-assistance features worked.
7. Ford Bronco: The Big Brother Fares Worse

The reborn Ford Bronco, which took the enthusiast world by storm in 2021, logged 6.6 fatal accidents per billion miles, 3.1 times the 2.2 average for SUVs, Torque News reports from the iSeeCars study.
It is one of only two larger SUVs on that deadliest list. Jalopnik adds that the Bronco earns middling, not-great-but-not-bad IIHS scores and was the first model on its ranking to cross three times the SUV average.
8. Ford Bronco Sport: The Smaller Sibling

The Ford Bronco Sport recorded 6.2 fatal accidents per billion miles in the iSeeCars data, 2.8 times the SUV average, according to Torque News.
That puts it just behind its bigger Bronco sibling, a small twist on the bigger-equals-safer idea. Like the full-size Bronco, it manages middling scores from IIHS, Jalopnik notes, and the two land side by side in the data.
9. Toyota Venza: A Toyota on the List

The Toyota Venza came in at 5.6 fatal accidents per billion miles, 2.5 times the SUV average, Torque News reports.
It was an IIHS Top Safety Pick for the 2024 model year but lost the distinction for 2025, Jalopnik notes, after significant changes to how the award is calculated. That shift left Toyota with only two SUVs of any size earning the award.
10. Chevrolet Trailblazer: Twice the Average

Among the smaller crossovers on the iSeeCars list, the Chevrolet Trailblazer posted 4.7 fatal accidents per billion miles, 2.1 times the SUV average, in the iSeeCars figures cited by Torque News.
iSeeCars analyst Karl Brauer said today’s models offer excellent occupant protection, but that distracted driving and higher speeds are countering those safety features, leading to rising accident and death rates in recent years.
11. Mercedes-Benz G-Class: Even the Tank

The Mercedes-Benz G-Class, which Jalopnik calls basically a tank on the road, logged 4.3 fatal accidents per billion miles, twice the SUV average, Torque News reports.
Along with the Bronco, it is one of two larger SUVs on the deadliest list, and its rate sits well above the 3.6 average for small vehicles. iSeeCars notes that an SUV’s higher center of gravity makes rollovers more likely, which substantially raises fatality risk.
12. Nissan Frontier: The Deadliest Pickup

The Nissan Frontier led the iSeeCars ranking of pickups at 5.0 fatal crashes per billion miles, 2.2 times the 2.3 truck average, MotorBiscuit reports.
The study covered 2018 to 2022 model-year vehicles in fatal crashes from 2017 to 2022, adjusted for miles driven. MotorBiscuit notes that the Frontier is a compact truck, and its smaller size can contribute to more severe impacts in collisions with larger vehicles.
13. Ford Ranger: A Lighter Ford

The Ford Ranger ranked second among pickups at 4.0 fatal crashes per billion miles, 1.7 times the truck average, in the iSeeCars data.
MotorBiscuit points to its size and lower weight, which can leave it more vulnerable in crashes with bigger vehicles. The contrast is with full-size pickups like Ford’s own F-150, which generally absorb impact better and offer more cabin protection.
14. Chevrolet Colorado: Third Among Trucks

The Chevrolet Colorado took third place among pickups at 2.9 fatal crashes per billion miles, MotorBiscuit reports, or 1.3 times the truck average.
Like the others on the list, it is at a disadvantage in collisions with larger, heavier cars and trucks. Bigger, heavier vehicles have a natural advantage in absorbing impact, MotorBiscuit explains, and the Colorado gives up some of that protection.
15. Toyota Tacoma: Tough Off-Road, Not On

Known for its off-road abilities, the Toyota Tacoma ranked fourth among pickups at 2.8 fatal crashes per billion miles, 1.2 times the truck average, MotorBiscuit reports.
It faces the same risk as its rivals because of a smaller, lighter frame. Height and build can also factor into crash severity, since smaller trucks often lack the same protection from higher-sitting vehicles, MotorBiscuit says.
16. Jeep Gladiator: Rugged, but Exposed

The Jeep Gladiator rounded out the five deadliest pickups at 2.7 fatal crashes per billion miles, 1.2 times the truck average, according to MotorBiscuit.
It pairs Jeep’s rugged reputation with a design that does not fare well in crashes, the site says. Smaller trucks trade some crash protection for maneuverability and fuel efficiency, while full-size models like the Ram 1500 generally do better.
More from Morning Overview
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
- Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say