Plenty of used cars look like bargains until the first big repair bill arrives. Mechanics and car-buying specialists keep naming the same troublesome models, and the evidence behind each warning ranges from complaint counts to recalls. Here are twelve used cars that experts advise shoppers to skip.
Help yourself and the planet: The Cool Down makes it easy to help yourself while helping the planet, with smart, simple changes to save more and waste less in your everyday life.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Tesla Model S: Aging EV Battery Risk
Certified mechanic Chris Pyle says Teslas and other EVs more than eight years old are among the worst used buys, with replacement motors and batteries in the $12,000 to $20,000 range.
A repair bill in that range can rival the price of the car itself, which turns a cheap older electric vehicle into a financial trap. The warning applies to the age of the battery pack more than to one badge. Buyers should demand battery health records before paying.
2. Chrysler 200: Shifting That Goes Wrong
Mechanics cite jerky shifting and outright transmission failure on the Chrysler 200, and CarComplaints owner reports describe 2013 transmission slipping at $4,000 by 39,000 miles.
A midsize sedan should not need a four-figure gearbox repair before 40,000 miles. The combination of expert warnings and owner data gives the criticism extra weight. Anyone considering a used 200 should test the transmission at several speeds and check for repair history. Prices on used examples often look attractive, but that discount is meant to reflect these risks.
3. Nissan Altima: CVT Shudder Complaints
Mechanics warn of continuously variable transmission shudder and failure in the Nissan Altima, and CarComplaints logs 5,369 Altima complaints, with 2013 shudder averaging $3,100 at 56,000 miles.
The Altima sells in large numbers, so a big complaint file is partly a matter of volume. Even so, a specific year with a predictable and costly failure is a clear red flag. Shoppers should avoid problem years or insist on proof of transmission service.
4. Mini Cooper: Small Car, Big Upkeep
Mechanics flag timing-chain issues, oil leaks and automatic-transmission trouble on 2000s and early-2010s Minis.
Timing-chain trouble is especially concerning because chain failures can damage the engine. Cheap used Coopers draw buyers who like the styling and handling, but the repair list explains why mechanics keep steering shoppers elsewhere. A specialist inspection is a must for any example. Independent shops that specialize in the brand can often spot these faults before a purchase is finalized.
5. Jeep Renegade: A Score Of Forty-Four
Mechanic Chris Pyle calls Renegades ‘overall very unreliable,’ and Consumer Reports gave the Renegade an overall score of just 44.
When a working mechanic and a consumer testing organization agree, the warning deserves attention. The Renegade has a fun, boxy look that appeals to younger buyers, but the evidence suggests that the savings on a used price may be offset by repair bills later. Cheaper alternatives with better records are easy to find in the same price range.
6. Dodge Journey: Weak Engine, Light Towing
Pyle says the Dodge Journey has a weak engine, poor handling and can only tow 1,000 pounds.
Those shortcomings matter for a family crossover that is supposed to carry people and gear. A tow rating that low rules out boats, campers and many trailers, so shoppers expecting more flexibility will be disappointed. The low price is the main attraction and may not justify the compromises. Shoppers who need real utility would do better with a competitor that handles both jobs.
7. Nissan Leaf: Outdated Charging Plug
CarEdge’s Zach Shefska warns that the outgoing Nissan Leaf has a ‘severely outdated’ CHAdeMO plug, and iSeeCars’ depreciation study found five-year-old Leafs lose 63.1% of their value.
Fast-charging networks are moving toward other connectors, which can make a Leaf harder to charge on road trips. Steep depreciation helps buyers on the entry price but leaves little residual value if the car is sold later. It suits short local trips better than long ones.
8. Jeep Wrangler 4xe: Software Update Stranding
Shefska notes that a software update left Jeep Wrangler 4xe owners stranded, and NHTSA campaign 25V741 also warned that the high-voltage battery may fail internally and catch fire.
A fire risk in a plug-in hybrid battery is the kind of defect that makes a used purchase uncomfortable. Recall remedies can resolve problems, so buyers should confirm that the work was finished and ask for proof before signing. Because the battery is a high-voltage part, the remedy matters, and buyers should treat the paperwork as seriously as the test drive.
9. Toyota Mirai: Hydrogen Fueling Shortage
Years after launch, there are just 54 hydrogen fuel stations operating across the country, Shefska warns, which complicates owning a Toyota Mirai.
Without a nearby station, a hydrogen car has nowhere to refuel and cannot be used as a daily driver. The Mirai may be well built, but the infrastructure around it limits its usefulness. Buyers outside the few areas with stations should look elsewhere. For most shoppers the practical choice is a conventional gasoline or hybrid model.
10. Nissan Ariya: Short Production Run
The Nissan Ariya was discontinued after just three years on the market, Shefska says, a red flag for used buyers.
A short production life can raise questions about parts supply, software updates and future resale values. An orphaned model is not automatically unreliable, but owners may face harder repairs and a smaller market when selling. Shoppers should weigh that uncertainty against the discount. Buyers tempted by a deep discount should ask the seller what warranty coverage, if any, remains and what the dealer will guarantee in writing.
11. 2014 Jeep Cherokee: Recall And Complaint Pile
The 2014 Jeep Cherokee drew 2,650 NHTSA complaints and 13 recalls, with power-transfer-unit repairs running up to $7,300.
The number of recalls signals a model year with a long list of known problems, and a repair bill that large can exceed the value of an older SUV. Buyers should check every open recall on a specific vehicle and look for evidence that the power transfer unit has been handled. Checking the vehicle identification number against the recall database takes minutes and is worth doing for any used car.
12. Porsche Cayenne: Luxury Upkeep Penalty
German Car Depot mechanic Alan Gelfand blames performance parts and high labor costs for the Porsche Cayenne’s pricey upkeep, and Consumer Reports ranks Porsche the second most expensive brand to maintain.
A used Cayenne can look affordable next to a new one, but the maintenance costs follow the badge and not the sticker price. Shoppers should budget well above typical SUV maintenance and use a specialist for any pre-purchase inspection.
Help yourself and the planet: Get The Cool Down →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
- Hybrids have 15% fewer problems than gas cars, while EVs and plug-in hybrids have about 80% more, Consumer Reports finds
- Regulators cleared the first U.S. small modular reactor, 4 months early
