Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Why flights nationwide were grounded: Duffy says a copper-to-fiber switch flooded the routers

Travelers who sat in terminals on Friday, Nov. 13, learned that planes across the country had been told to stay put, and for hours nobody could say why. The first official answer, delivered the next day, was almost mundane: a router at a remote federal site started talking too much.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said the trouble began when a contractor moved communications lines from old copper to fiber, and a router involved in that switch began sending more than 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds to other routers.

The router and the numbers

The Federal Aviation Administration’s question-and-answer page gives the preliminary account. Its legacy equipment became unstable when data flooded the FAA’s telecommunications network with connection attempts at roughly 1,000 every four to five seconds, disrupting aircraft communications and radar feeds. Instability began at 17 of the agency’s 22 Air Route Traffic Control Centers and spread to several terminal radar approach controls.

The FAA pointed to two sites: a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas. L3Harris, the agency’s network service provider, was working at El Dorado, including deploying a new router. L3Harris blocked both locations, the network stabilized, and the broadcasting function was disabled on all new routers.

It was not a full blackout. Some frequencies and feeds kept working, and military and life-saving flights were unaffected. About 3,500 aircraft were airborne when the stop was issued, and the FAA says every one of them landed safely.

Duffy’s account of the switch

In remarks released in a Department of Transportation statement, Duffy said L3Harris was doing routine maintenance at a remote location, moving telecom lines from copper to fiber and from analog to digital, when a router being replaced began flooding other routers. He said officials had not determined whether contractor error or faulty equipment was to blame, and that he did not believe a cyberattack was involved because systems recovered once the remote work was isolated.

FOX Weather quoted Duffy saying that during the copper-to-fiber change the new equipment “started flooding other routers” in the air traffic control system. On a Sunday television circuit summarized in a White House release, Duffy described the El Dorado line as “an old copper wire that basically was going to be decommissioned,” and called the findings preliminary.

The root cause remains open. The FAA says it and L3Harris are still investigating, and a trade report in Cabling Installation & Maintenance records Duffy’s own caveat that officials had not yet determined what the fault was.

Timing, scale and what changes

The FAA says air traffic resumed at 8:15 p.m. Eastern the same day, with recovery to normal operations described as “slow and steady.” Operators canceled about 12,462 flights on Nov. 13, including 9,082 by major airlines, although the FAA cautions that not every cancellation was a direct result of the stop. FOX Weather, citing FlightAware, counted more than 9,100 cancellations and more than 24,500 delays on Friday and more than 4,000 cancellations by Saturday afternoon. The last nationwide stop, on Jan. 11, 2023, lasted about an hour and a half.

The agency has ruled out some theories. It says it has no indication of a cyberattack or an outside nefarious actor, and that its SMART data aggregator, which does not feed the air traffic control system, was unrelated.

It also tied the failure to the age of the network rather than to recent upgrades. The FAA attributes the problem to the legacy time-division multiplexing system, and says towers that received modifications from the Working Families Tax Cuts funding did not go down.

Two changes followed. The work was done during the day at a remote facility, when such maintenance is usually done at night, and the FAA says it will reevaluate when it schedules it. It also disabled the affected functionality on the originating Juniper routers and on more than 60 others in the system, and has paused installing more of them.

The network’s age frames the whole episode. A ClearanceJobs analysis reports that the conversion from copper to fiber was about 70 percent complete as of Nov. 2, that the FAA network connects more than 4,400 facilities, and that L3Harris expects to finish in 2027. It adds that a similar misconfiguration in November 2009 caused a five-hour disruption, according to an inspector general review. FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford, the same report says, has warned that the system will keep breaking until it is replaced.

Duffy used the episode to press for money. He said the $12.5 billion from Congress covers radar, radios and related upgrades but not a new telecom network, and told Sunday audiences that AT&T, Verizon and Lumen are ready to build one if funded. What the investigation concludes about the Amarillo and El Dorado sites will decide whether the fault lay with the equipment, the installation or the people running it.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview


Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.