Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Progress Residential renters are in line to share $48.5 million over hidden ‘smart home’ fees

A renter in one of Progress Residential’s single-family houses could open the lease and find a monthly rent that looked fixed, then watch a “smart home” charge and a utility-management charge appear on top of it. The Federal Trade Commission and four states say that pattern was routine, and on Nov. 6 they announced that Progress and its private-equity owner would pay $48.5 million to the FTC for redress to harmed renters.

The money is part of a $49.75 million settlement that has been filed but, as of the FTC’s case page, is still listed as pending.

The $48.5 million and the court that must approve it

The FTC’s press release splits the $49.75 million into two pieces: $48.5 million to the FTC, to be used for redress to consumers harmed by the companies’ conduct, and $1.25 million to Arizona. Arizona, Colorado, Indiana and Utah joined the agency as plaintiffs. The defendants are Progress Residential, which the FTC calls the largest property manager of single-family rental homes, with more than 90,000 homes in 17 states, and its owner, Pretium Partners.

The complaint and a stipulated order were filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia. The FTC case page lists civil action No. 1:26-cv-06782-VMC and a status of “Pending.” The agency says such an order becomes enforceable once the judge approves and signs it, which is why the payout to renters cannot yet be called final.

Nothing the FTC has published explains how renters will be paid, when, or whether anyone must file a claim.

Smart home, utility management and the renter’s insurance exemption

According to the FTC, the advertised monthly rent left out mandatory recurring fees. The release names monthly “smart home” fees, monthly “utility management” fees and a “renter’s insurance exemption fee,” along with one-time and situational charges. The agency says hidden fees have cost consumers tens of millions of dollars since at least 2021.

The FTC’s separate consumer alert describes the mechanics for renters: the charges were mandatory yet absent from the advertised price, and such fees often sit in footnotes, hyperlinks or fine print. It describes the “smart home” and “utility maintenance” fees as costing tenants tens of millions of dollars over five years.

Christopher Mufarrige, director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, said in the release: “Transparency regarding rental prices and fees helps consumers compare options and make informed choices.”

Move-in inspections and withheld deposits

Fees are only part of the complaint. The FTC alleges that homes were advertised as “move-in ready” and as inspected, although many needed serious maintenance, repair or cleaning. It further alleges that security deposits were withheld for normal wear and tear, for preexisting conditions and for repairs the companies were responsible for, and that itemized deposit statements often never arrived.

The complaint adds customer-service failures, including billing errors, repair requests left unfulfilled and unresolved deposit disputes. Form contracts, the agency says, carried nondisparagement provisions that restricted negative reviews.

The proposed order answers each allegation. It would require Progress to advertise a “true total monthly rental price” that includes every mandatory recurring fee, bar it from misrepresenting that homes were inspected or passed inspection before move-in, and require itemized deposit statements within 30 days of move-out or as state law requires. Deductions for normal wear and tear and for preexisting conditions would be barred, and so would standardized nondisparagement clauses.

Invitation Homes as precedent, and the FTC advice for renters

Progress is not the first corporate landlord to face this theory. On Sept. 24, 2024, the FTC announced a proposed settlement under which Invitation Homes would turn over $48 million for refunds to harmed consumers. That case also centered on mandatory monthly fees for “smart home” technology and “utility management,” which renters could not opt out of, plus nonrefundable application fees of up to $55 and reservation fees of up to $500.

Then-FTC Chair Lina M. Khan said at the time: “No American should pay more for rent or be kicked out of their home because of illegal tactics by corporate landlords.”

Reuters-sourced coverage carried by Claims Journal placed the Progress deal in that line, citing an FTC official, and reported that the agency’s cost-of-living work includes possibly requiring landlords to list mandatory fees upfront. The same report cited a Zillow survey in which 60% of renters paid a recurring fee on top of rent last year, a figure the FTC itself did not publish.

The FTC’s alert advises prospective tenants to confirm in writing with the leasing agent the full monthly rent, including mandatory fees, before paying application or holding fees. It also suggests photographing a unit at move-in and again at move-out, sending move-in photos to the landlord promptly, and requesting a pre-move-out inspection and an itemized list of any deposit deductions. Reports of hidden fees can be filed at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

The open question is timing. Until the judge signs the order, the $48.5 million remains a proposed payment, and the FTC has not said how it will find the renters it covers.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview


Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.