Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Older Teslas mostly keep their batteries, and here’s what wears out instead

The fear that keeps many shoppers away from a used electric car is the battery: an expensive part that, in theory, fades until the car is worthless. Owners who have actually put six-figure mileage on early Teslas tell a different story, and the parts they keep replacing are mostly small, fussy and found in the cabin.

Read next on Morning Overview: Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA

The evidence here is owner testimony and individual car histories rather than a controlled study, so it describes what has happened to particular vehicles rather than what every car will do. Taken car by car, though, the pattern is consistent: modest battery loss, and a recurring list of door handles, screens and latches.

Battery loss in the single digits to low teens

The battery analytics company Recurrent combed through forums where Tesla owners with more than 100,000 miles compare notes, and collected what those drivers reported. One owner of a 2013 Model S P85 wrote: “Still going strong with original battery. Had a few drive units and various suspension bushings replaced. 2013 P85. 144,000 miles, 8% degradation.” Another, with a 2016 Model S 75 at 141,000 miles, said range loss on the original pack was about 10%, with power “like new.”

Recurrent notes that most cars in the group had already passed the mileage limit of their battery warranties, which are typically eight years or 100,000 miles. That makes their experience useful, because one of the common worries about EVs is that they become unusable as soon as the warranty runs out.

Independent tests point the same way. When the YouTube channel Ludicrous Feed had a third-party battery test done on its 2015 Model S 70D after 10 years and 75,000 miles, capacity had fallen to about 61 kWh, roughly 88.1% of the original. The same report mentions a Model S that reached more than 430,000 miles with about 23% degradation.

Not every pack lasts. A 2015 Model S 70D that worked as an Uber and reached 425,000 miles had its original battery replaced at 250,000 miles, for reasons the service records did not give. The replacement was free under warranty; out of warranty it would have cost an estimated $15,000 to $20,000. Some high-mileage owners also report that their cars limit power more as the battery ages, with one driver at over 300,000 miles describing a 12% reduction on good days and up to 17% on cold ones.

Door handles, screens and the parts that actually fail

The longer list of repairs is less dramatic. Recurrent’s forum review found that high-mileage owners routinely replace the retractable door handles, interior LCD screens, sliding armrests and the front trunk latch, and some warned about failed seals on drive units and coolant valves and moisture getting into exterior lights.

The 2016 Model S 75 owner itemized the costs: a window regulator for $332 at 88,000 miles, the frunk latch and a steering wheel scroll wheel for $503, a replacement main display LCD and trunk strut for $946, the instrument cluster LCD for $490, two front door handles for $283 and $301, and center armrest sliders for $134. The drive unit was replaced under warranty at 87,000 miles because of noise. Tires were replaced four times, about every 30,000 miles, while the brakes were still original.

Door handles are the most notorious item. The 425,000-mile Uber car needed its retracting handles replaced seven times, at $1,000 per handle once it was out of warranty, and a failed infotainment screen left that owner without turn signals, climate controls or the rear camera until it was fixed. The 10-year-old Model S 70D in the Ludicrous Feed test also needed an out-of-warranty door handle repair, a known issue for the 2015 model year.

What 400,000 miles of service records show

The most detailed history comes from a 2016 Model X 90D run by Tesloop, a shuttle service between Los Angeles, San Diego, Palm Springs and Las Vegas. Jalopnik’s David Tracy went through the full maintenance records for the vehicle’s 400,000-plus miles and tallied about $29,000 in maintenance. Air conditioning compressors were replaced at 72,384 and 115,362 miles. “AC compressors are one that… [Tesloop] realized early on, was that they are not designed to be used around the clock,” Tesloop’s Rahul Sonnad told him.

Tracy was careful about what the log proves. The records, he wrote, do not show that Tesla’s cars are more or less reliable than others, only what one hard-used vehicle needed.

For a used-Tesla shopper, the practical lesson from these histories is to budget for the small stuff and check the battery directly. Owners in Recurrent’s group commonly cap daily charging at 80% or 90%, a habit Recurrent itself recommends, and Tesla CEO Elon Musk has advised against routinely charging to 100%, telling one owner that 90% or 95% was the better choice partly because regenerative braking does not work at a full charge. A 10% or 12% loss after a decade is common in these accounts; a $300 door handle every few years is just as likely to be what actually hits the wallet.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.