Anxiety is the product. A fraudster working the holiday shopping season does not need a perfect fake website so much as a customer who feels rushed, and FBI Boston says the rush itself is the thing to watch for. In interviews reported by Boston 25 News on Nov. 17 and WMUR on Nov. 19, the bureau’s Mario Fratantonio said scammers try to push people to move at a pace unlike their own.
“The fraudster is trying to create anxiety and trying to get [people] to move at a pace that’s uncharacteristic to [their] habits,” Fratantonio, an assistant special agent in charge at the FBI’s Boston office, told the station.
Nearly 230 New Hampshire victims, more than $2.5 million
The local number came from the same WMUR report published Nov. 19. In New Hampshire alone, the FBI told the station, nearly 230 people lost more than $2.5 million to holiday-season scams last year. WMUR did not name the year; with a 2026 publication date, “last year” points to 2025. The figure covers New Hampshire only.
The bureau’s New England footprint is wider. Boston 25 News, in its own account of the briefing, reported that the FBI says online fraudsters stole more than $11 million last year from victims in Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Maine.
The warning signs the agents listed
Fratantonio’s urgency tell sits in a short list. WMUR’s summary names online shopping, gift card and charitable giving scams as especially common in the season, and lists spelling mistakes, deals that seem too good to be true and a sense of urgency as the red flags. Fratantonio told the station fraudsters “are everywhere” and said they aim at people with money who may not know what to look for, singling out older and younger people.
The new element is artificial intelligence. WMUR reported that criminals are using AI to build websites that mirror legitimate ones, which removes one of the old tells, the badly spelled storefront. Boston 25 added that the scams run through fake retail sites with unbeatable deals, unsolicited texts, emails and calls impersonating credit card companies or banks, and requests for account numbers. Fratantonio’s answer to the AI problem was low-tech, as Boston 25 relayed it: common sense can defeat the criminals’ ability to use AI.
The advice from agents was the same in both reports. WMUR relayed that anyone with doubts should stop all communication immediately and contact the business directly, then monitor accounts and learn the bank’s fraud-alert procedures. Boston 25 said the FBI recommends pausing and verifying directly with the institution that claims to be calling or writing.
The FBI’s national alerts on the same scams
The Boston warnings repeat themes from the bureau’s Internet Crime Complaint Center. Its Nov. 15, 2023 public service announcement reported nearly 12,000 victims of non-payment and non-delivery scams during the 2022 holiday season, with reported losses above $73 million. It advised against paying by wire transfer, virtual currency, gift card or cash, and against clicking links in unsolicited email.
The IC3 notice also told shoppers to check that sites use HTTPS and show a padlock icon, to verify sellers through reviews and the Better Business Bureau rather than trust a flashy site, and to use a credit card dedicated to online purchases so statements are easy to review. Those steps address the same fake-storefront problem that Fratantonio described in Boston this month.
The pattern is older still. BleepingComputer’s Nov. 24, 2021 report on an FBI warning cited more than 17,000 complaints about non-delivered goods in the 2020 holiday season and losses above $53 million. Those national figures are not comparable year to year, since they cover different categories and reporting periods, and none of them is a New Hampshire number.
State-level data show how routine the exposure is. Manchester Ink Link, citing Federal Trade Commission figures in a Dec. 8, 2025 report, put New Hampshire’s 2024 online shopping scam reports at 1,657 with $1,575,646 lost, the state’s second-largest fraud category. U.S. Sen. Maggie Hassan of New Hampshire was quoted in the same piece saying “Scams generally are costing people millions and millions of dollars,” and Laurie Weaver, the state’s health and human services commissioner, was quoted saying “Scammers often try and create a false sense of urgency,” the same lever Fratantonio described.
Victims are asked to report. Fratantonio told WMUR that victims should forgive themselves and then report it, and that details such as the name the scammer used and the method of contact help investigators judge whether “a network of individuals is behind a mass fraud scheme.” Complaints go to ic3.gov, the Boston 25 report said. The FBI’s own Boston news release on the briefing could not be retrieved for this article, so every Boston-office statement here is as relayed by the two stations.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
- Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say
- Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge