Every year, thousands of American motorcyclists die on the road, and the toll has been climbing. In 2024 the count reached 6,228, close to the highest number on record and about triple the deaths of the late 1990s.
Read next on Morning Overview: A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
A new generation of smaller, cheaper electric motorcycles has prompted an unusual question: could the shift to batteries make riding less deadly? Not because electric power is inherently safer, but because it may change which motorcycles new riders buy in the first place.
6,228 deaths and the riders behind the numbers
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s 2024 fatality figures put the problem starkly. The 6,228 motorcyclists killed that year were close to the record of 6,366 set in 2023, up 23% since 2019, and accounted for 16% of all motor vehicle crash deaths. The federal government estimates that per mile traveled in 2024, deaths on motorcycles were almost 27 times those in cars. IIHS sums up why: “Motorcycles are less stable and harder for other drivers to see than cars, and they often have high performance capabilities. When motorcycles crash, their riders lack the protection of an enclosed vehicle, so they’re more likely to be injured or killed.”
Behavior drives a large share of those deaths. As Electrek’s Micah Toll writes, citing IIHS and NHTSA data, around 35% of motorcyclist deaths in 2024 happened in single-vehicle crashes, where no other vehicle hit the rider, and among riders killed in single-vehicle crashes, 40% were alcohol-impaired. IIHS also found that 36% of fatally injured motorcycle drivers were unlicensed, compared with 17% of passenger vehicle drivers who died.
The type of bike matters too. Of riders killed on supersport motorcycles in 2024, 59% were under 30, compared with 19% on cruisers and standard motorcycles and 7% on touring bikes. Toll is careful about what that proves: the numbers do not show that powerful bikes cause the deaths, and the kind of rider drawn to each machine is a confounding factor. Engine sizes differ sharply too: IIHS found that 95% of touring bikes in fatal crashes had engines larger than 1,400 cc, while virtually all supersports were 1,000 cc or smaller. Figures such as “motorcycles are 27x more deadly than cars” might be true in a broad sense, he writes, but they do not mean every rider faces a 27-times-higher chance of death, especially riders who are not, in his words, “a 25-year-old hooligan on a second-hand liter bike.”
Electric bikes built for the city, not the track
For years, electric motorcycle makers chased gasoline bikes up the performance ladder, producing fast, powerful machines from companies like Energica and LiveWire. Toll’s argument is that the more important trend now runs the other way, toward modest machines meant for commuting.
LiveWire’s S4 Honcho is the clearest example. The Harley-Davidson spinoff set prices of $4,999 for the S4 Honcho Trail and $5,499 for the street version, far below its flagship models. The bike is expected to top out around 59 mph, which puts it in the role of a traditional 125cc gasoline motorcycle: built mainly for urban riding, suburban commuting and short hops on smaller highways rather than hours at interstate speed. Smaller brands such as Ryvid, Land and Maeving are filling the same space between an e-bike and a full-size motorcycle.
The contrast is the core of the argument. A used supersport can weigh around 400 pounds, make well over 100 horsepower and approach three times a typical U.S. highway speed limit, and it is cheap and easy for an inexperienced rider to buy. A desirable, affordable bike that tops out at 60 or 70 mph could change what a beginner considers normal. “If younger riders grow up progressing from e-bikes to small e-motos and then to highway-capable electric motorcycles, perhaps [the industry will] wind up with a generation that sees a lightweight 60 or 70 mph motorcycle as a perfectly legitimate machine,” Toll writes.
Seatbelts, helmets and the limits of the data
Some manufacturers are attacking the problem from the vehicle side. At the EICMA show this month, Segway introduced the X Cruiser, an electric two-wheeler with a roll cage and seatbelts, which the company says was designed around automotive crash scenarios, with energy-absorbing structures and blind spot detection.
The proven tools are older. IIHS says helmets are about 37% effective in preventing motorcycle deaths and about 67% effective in preventing brain injuries, yet only 17 states and the District of Columbia require all riders to wear one. In 2024, 89% of motorcyclists killed in states with universal helmet laws were helmeted, compared with 40% in states with no helmet law.
Toll concedes the key limitation himself: “There also simply isn’t enough data yet to demonstrate that electric motorcycles have meaningfully lower fatality rates than comparable gasoline motorcycles.” Until crash data for small electric motorcycles exists in volume, the case that they can cut the toll rests on who rides them and how fast they can go.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Winter weather advisories cover I-80, I-70 and the Bighorns with up to 15 inches of snow
- Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25