The sun does not need to aim directly at Earth very often to cause real damage, but on the rare occasions when it does, the consequences can outlast the storm itself by months or years. A solar eruption on the scale of the 1859 Carrington Event, history’s most intense recorded geomagnetic storm, would strike a modern electrical grid that is far more interconnected, and far more exposed, than the telegraph lines it disrupted more than a century and a half ago. Space weather scientists have spent years modeling exactly what that kind of storm would do if it hit today.
What Actually Happened in 1859
The Carrington Event was named for the British astronomer Richard Carrington, who observed an intense solar flare shortly before the geomagnetic storm reached Earth. The storm was strong enough that telegraph systems across Europe and North America malfunctioned, in some documented cases sparking fires, and operators reported that lines kept transmitting even after they had disconnected their own batteries, apparently powered directly by currents the storm induced in the wires. Auroras were reported as far from the poles as the Caribbean, a sign of just how deeply the storm’s charged particles penetrated Earth’s magnetic field.
A Much Bigger, Much More Fragile Grid Today
The 1859 telegraph network was a simple point-to-point wiring system with nothing comparable to the modern power grid’s dependence on large, interconnected, high-voltage transformers. According to NOAA’s assessment of the risk, a storm of Carrington intensity today would induce strong geomagnetically induced currents in long transmission lines, currents that can overheat and permanently damage the large transformers that keep regional power grids running. Those transformers are custom-built, expensive, and slow to manufacture, with few spares kept in reserve, which is precisely what turns a temporary storm into a potentially long-term outage.
The 1989 Preview: Nine Hours Without Power in Quebec
A far weaker geomagnetic storm already demonstrated the mechanism in March 1989, when currents induced by a solar storm collapsed Hydro-Quebec’s power grid in roughly 90 seconds, leaving about six million people without electricity for around nine hours, with some areas of the province going considerably longer. That storm was a fraction of the strength of the Carrington Event, yet it was enough to trip protective relays and black out an entire provincial grid almost instantly, illustrating how quickly a strong geomagnetic disturbance can cascade through interconnected power infrastructure.
Modeling the Cost of a Direct Hit
Insurance and risk-modeling firms have tried to put a number on what a direct Carrington-class hit would cost the United States today. A widely cited risk assessment from Lloyd’s of London estimated the total economic impact at somewhere between roughly 0.6 trillion and 2.6 trillion dollars, with the largest uncertainty tied to how many extra-high-voltage transformers would need to be replaced and how long replacements would take to build and ship. Separate estimates built on similar assumptions have placed the figure in a comparable range, with tens of millions of Americans potentially losing power for anywhere from around two weeks to well over a year depending on the scenario and the region affected, with the Northeast and northern-latitude regions considered the most exposed.
The Storm That Missed by Nine Days
The scenario is not purely hypothetical. In July 2012, an eruption on the sun sent a coronal mass ejection of comparable strength to the Carrington Event across the orbit of Earth, but Earth itself had moved out of the way just over a week earlier, so the storm passed harmlessly through the spot Earth had occupied days before. The event was measured directly by a NASA spacecraft positioned in the CME’s path and is now treated by space-weather researchers as evidence that a modern Carrington-scale storm is not a remote statistical possibility but a matter of when, not if, the sun aims one directly at Earth again.
How Grid Operators Try to Get Advance Warning
Agencies including NOAA’s Space Weather Prediction Center now track solar activity continuously and issue geomagnetic storm warnings specifically so grid operators can take protective steps before a major storm arrives. Those steps can include temporarily lowering the load on vulnerable transmission lines, reconfiguring parts of the network to reduce the length of exposed circuits, and pulling sensitive equipment offline for the duration of a forecasted storm. The warning window is typically measured in minutes to a few days, since the initial flare’s light reaches Earth in about eight minutes while the slower-moving charged particles that actually threaten the grid can take one to three days to arrive, giving operators a narrow but genuine chance to reduce damage before the worst of a storm hits. That narrow window is now the main line of defense against a repeat of 1859, since no technology currently exists to stop a coronal mass ejection once it leaves the sun, only to blunt its effect on the ground below.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors.
More from Morning Overview
