Parents shopping for a first car often face a tight budget and a long list of safety worries. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety publishes a list of used models it recommends for teens, each paired with a ceiling on what to pay. Here are twelve of those vehicles, along with the price caps attached to them.
Tech news worth reading: Get Techpresso, the daily email with the most interesting tech news and insights, read by 400,000+ professionals from Google, Apple and OpenAI.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Kia Soul: Cheapest Ticket In
The Kia Soul appears on the IIHS teen list with 2015-25 model years in the under-$10,000 tier, and its price cap of $5,300 is the lowest figure among the entries in this gallery.
A cap that low gives families a rare option for a safe vehicle without a large outlay. The cap works as a ceiling on what to spend, so a clean, well-maintained example needs to be found within it, and a pre-purchase inspection is a sensible precaution. The long model-year range, stretching from 2015 to 2025, means a wide pool of used examples to compare, which can also help a buyer negotiate.
2. Mazda 3: Hatch or Sedan
The Mazda 3 is recommended in two body styles on the IIHS list of teen vehicles: the 2019-25 hatchback and the 2020-25 sedan, both carrying a price cap of $13,200.
Having a choice between the two shapes lets a family pick whichever suits cargo needs and the teen’s taste. The model-year ranges differ by a year between body styles, so a listing should be matched carefully to the right row before any offer is made. Parents comparing the two body styles should read the list rows closely, because the earlier start year for the hatchback widens the supply of qualifying cars.
3. Subaru Legacy: Under-Twenty Sedan
On the institute’s under-$20,000 list, the 2020-25 Subaru Legacy appears with a price cap of $16,500, according to the IIHS teen vehicle ratings.
That places the midsize sedan in the upper-middle part of the recommended price range. Sticking to or below the cap is the point of the exercise, and a family that finds a Legacy priced above it may want to keep looking at other models instead. Shoppers should treat the number as a ceiling for this particular model, not as a typical asking price, and verify the model year against the 2020-25 range.
4. Acura RDX: Pricey but Listed
The 2019-25 Acura RDX is a midsize SUV that the IIHS teen list carries with a price cap of $19,600, one of the priciest entries among the tier-two picks.
A cap that close to $20,000 shows the list does not consist only of small, cheap cars. Families willing to spend near the ceiling get a larger vehicle, while those on a tighter budget can look further down the list at lower caps. Higher-priced vehicles can also carry higher insurance and repair costs, a point worth weighing alongside the purchase price.
5. Honda Civic: Coupe or Sedan
A 2014-25 Honda Civic coupe or sedan qualifies in the under-$10,000 tier, with a price cap of $8,100, Carscoops reported in its coverage of the May update.
The wide span of model years means many used Civics fit the recommendation, which widens the pool of candidates. Under-ten-thousand shoppers should still weigh mileage and condition, since the cap alone says nothing about how a given car was treated. Because the range begins in 2014, even the oldest qualifying Civics are more than a decade old, so wear items and maintenance history deserve extra scrutiny.
6. Nissan Maxima: Large Sedan Option
The Nissan Maxima makes the under-$20,000 list in 2020-23 model years, with a price cap of $15,200, according to Carscoops coverage of the IIHS update.
The shorter model-year window means fewer candidates than most entries, so the search may take patience. For a teen driver, the Maxima offers a bigger sedan option than the compact picks, as long as the price stays under the stated cap. Parents should also confirm the 2020-23 range carefully, since a 2024 or 2025 Maxima does not appear in that listing.
7. Ford Bronco Sport: Small SUV, Big Cap
The Ford Bronco Sport is listed for 2021-25 model years as a small SUV with a price cap of $18,100, per Carscoops’ summary of the teen recommendations.
Its inclusion shows that the IIHS list reaches beyond sedans into compact utility vehicles. Families drawn to the rugged styling should note that the recommendation depends on staying within the price cap and the listed model years. The 2021-25 range makes it a relatively recent design among the entries, which is useful for families wanting a younger vehicle within the cap.
8. Hyundai Tucson: Hybrid Included
The 2022-25 Hyundai Tucson qualifies under $20,000 with a price cap of $19,100, and the listing explicitly includes the hybrid, as Carscoops noted in its rundown.
The hybrid inclusion gives parents a way to hold down fuel costs for a young driver who may cover many miles. The cap sits very close to the tier ceiling, so there is little room for negotiation upward on a particular car. Because the cap sits only $900 below the $20,000 ceiling, shoppers should check each listing against the number before getting attached to a vehicle.
9. Nissan Altima: Family Sedan Pick
Several mainstream sedans appear together in AutoGuide’s roundup, and the 2021-24 Nissan Altima earns an IIHS teen recommendation with a price cap of $17,000.
The Altima sits in the middle of the pack on price, which suits households that want a recognizable midsize sedan without reaching the top of the tier. Checking that the specific model year falls within the listed range is the first step. Parents should compare the cap with local asking prices, since a car listed above $17,000 falls outside the recommended range.
10. Kia K5: Mind the Build Date
The Kia K5 is recommended for 2021-24 models built after November 2020, with a price cap of $17,500, according to AutoGuide’s coverage of the list.
The build-date condition is the detail most easily overlooked. A 2021 car produced before that month does not carry the recommendation, so buyers should confirm the production date on the door-jamb label before treating a listing as qualifying. The seller can usually supply the build date, and the label inside the driver’s door typically shows it, so the check takes only a minute.
11. Mazda CX-5: Cheapest Tier-Two SUV
At a $13,100 cap, the 2018-25 Mazda CX-5 is the cheapest tier-two SUV on the list, per AutoGuide’s breakdown. The recommendation applies to small SUVs built after March 2018.
That makes it the most budget-friendly route to an SUV among the picks. As with the K5, the build date matters, so a 2018 model built before March does not qualify even though the model year appears in the range. Families that want an SUV at a lower price than the other tier-two options can start the search here.
12. Nissan Rogue: Late-Model Rogue
The 2021-23 Nissan Rogue makes the under-$20,000 list, with a price cap of $17,200, according to AutoGuide’s roundup of cars parents can trust for teen drivers.
The three-year window is narrow, which can limit choices in a local market. Families that find one at or below the cap get a popular compact SUV on a list built around crash protection and sensible spending. The narrower 2021-23 window means a parent should expect a smaller number of qualifying vehicles when searching local listings.
Tech news worth reading: Get Techpresso →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- The FBI told the rest of ShinyHunters to surrender after a 24-year-old was arrested
- Two passengers died at an Ohio toll plaza, and the NTSB now wants the cash lanes shut
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
