Small and midsize pickups have become some of the most competitive vehicles on the market, with fresh designs, hybrid powertrains and unibody alternatives. Edmunds’ expert reviewers score each one out of ten, and the spread between the weakest and strongest is wider than many shoppers expect. Here are nine small and midsize pickups ranked from worst rated to top rated.
Read next on Morning Overview: Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
1. Nissan Frontier: The Lowest Score in the Class

The 2027 Nissan Frontier earns an Edmunds expert rating of 5.6 out of 10, the lowest among the small and midsize trucks in this ranking. The Frontier was fully redesigned for 2022 and still uses a naturally aspirated V6 with a nine-speed automatic.
A low expert score does not mean a truck is a poor buy for everyone. The Frontier’s simple V6 and conventional layout appeal to buyers who value familiar mechanicals, but reviewers rate rivals higher on refinement, technology and overall value, which explains the ranking.
2. Jeep Gladiator: Off-Road Hero, Low Overall Mark

The 2027 Jeep Gladiator receives a 5.7 out of 10 from Edmunds, only a tenth of a point ahead of the Frontier. Its removable roof and doors and trail-ready hardware make it unique among pickups, but those traits come with compromises on pavement.
Solid front axles, chunky tires and a boxy shape help on rocks and mud but tend to bring more wind noise and a busier ride on the highway. Buyers who plan to spend weekends on trails may find those trade-offs easy to accept, while daily commuters will notice them every day.
3. GMC Canyon: Premium Trims, Middling Score

The 2027 GMC Canyon earns an Edmunds rating of 6.4 out of 10. The Canyon shares its turbocharged four-cylinder and body with the Chevrolet Colorado but leans toward upscale trims such as Denali and the off-road AT4X.
The Canyon’s pricing tends to run higher than its Chevrolet twin, which can make the value case harder to argue. Shoppers who want GMC styling and features should compare it closely against a well-equipped Colorado before deciding. The Canyon’s strongest selling points are its trim-level features and its off-road AT4X version.
4. Chevrolet Colorado: Just Ahead of Its Twin

The 2026 Chevrolet Colorado scores 6.5 out of 10 in Edmunds’ review, one tenth of a point above the Canyon. The current Colorado arrived for 2023 with a turbocharged 2.7-liter four-cylinder in place of the old V6 and diesel options.
The Colorado’s ZR2 trim has earned praise as a capable off-roader, while lower trims give buyers a more affordable way into the segment. The middle-of-the-pack rating reflects a solid truck that faces very strong competition. Its score sits closer to the middle of the class than the top.
5. Toyota Tacoma: A Bestseller in the Middle of the Pack

The 2026 Toyota Tacoma lands at 6.8 out of 10 from Edmunds. The Tacoma was redesigned for 2024 with turbocharged four-cylinder engines, including a hybrid option, and remains one of the best-selling midsize pickups in America.
The Tacoma’s reputation for durability and strong resale value keeps buyers loyal regardless of expert scores, and it remains a common sight on job sites and trailheads alike. A rating just under seven places it in the middle of this group, behind several newer or more car-like rivals. Few trucks hold value better.
6. Honda Ridgeline: The Unibody Alternative

The 2026 Honda Ridgeline earns an Edmunds expert rating of 6.9 out of 10. Unlike most rivals, it is built on a unibody platform shared with the Honda Pilot, which gives it a smoother, car-like ride.
The Ridgeline also offers a lockable in-bed trunk and a dual-action tailgate, features that appeal to buyers who use a pickup more for home projects than for heavy work. Its towing capacity trails body-on-frame trucks, which limits its appeal for some. For many suburban owners, those trade-offs work in its favor.
7. Ford Ranger: The Top Traditional Pickup

The 2026 Ford Ranger scores 7.1 out of 10 from Edmunds, the highest rating among the traditional body-on-frame midsize pickups in this list. The current Ranger arrived in the U.S. for 2024 with turbocharged engines and a Raptor performance version.
The Ranger’s rating reflects a balance of capability, technology and price that reviewers find hard to beat. It sits just below two smaller, car-based trucks at the top of the list, both of which win points for efficiency and value. Ford also sells the Ranger in many global markets.
8. Hyundai Santa Cruz: A Pickup Built Like a Crossover

The 2027 Hyundai Santa Cruz earns 7.6 out of 10 from Edmunds, the second-highest score in this group. Hyundai calls it a sport adventure vehicle, and it rides on a platform related to the Tucson SUV with a short open bed.
The Santa Cruz is aimed at buyers who rarely need a full-size bed but want one for bikes, mulch or camping gear. Its car-like handling and comfortable cabin earn praise, though its small bed and modest towing limits keep it out of serious work duty.
9. Ford Maverick: The Highest-Rated Small Pickup

The 2026 Ford Maverick tops this ranking with an Edmunds expert rating of 7.7 out of 10. The compact pickup offers a hybrid powertrain as well as a turbocharged gas engine and has been one of the most popular new trucks since its debut.
Low starting prices and strong fuel economy made the Maverick a hit with buyers who had been priced out of larger pickups. Its success has pushed other automakers to reconsider small trucks, and the top rating confirms that reviewers share buyers’ enthusiasm.
More from Morning Overview
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power