Skip to main content

Morning Overview

8 pickups whose transmissions shift hard or let trucks roll

A pickup’s transmission works harder than almost any other part of the truck, especially when towing. Some modern multi-speed gearboxes have drawn lawsuits, recalls and long complaint files for harsh shifts, shudder and a failure to hold the truck in Park. Here are eight pickups whose transmissions shift hard or let trucks roll.

Read next on Morning Overview: The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power

1. Ford F-150: Costly Hard Shifts

Ford F-150 — Image Credit: Kevauto - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Kevauto – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

Owners of the 2018 Ford F-150 with the 10-speed 10R80 automatic have filed shifting-hard complaints on CarComplaints, where 18 reports list an average repair cost of $7,250. The average failure arrived at about 35,850 miles.

That mileage means many trucks were still young when the problems began, though some owners fell outside powertrain coverage. Owners of 2018 F-150s should keep records of every transmission visit, since a documented history can help if Ford offers extended coverage or a goodwill repair later. A fluid change on schedule is cheap insurance. Records matter.

2. Chevrolet Silverado 1500: Slipping, Bucking and Jerking

Chevrolet Silverado 1500 — Image Credit: Rjluna2 - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Rjluna2 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

The 2015 through 2019 Chevrolet Silverado with the 8L90 or 8L45 eight-speed automatic is part of a lawsuit over GM’s eight-speed transmissions. The suit alleges that the gearboxes slip, buck, kick, jerk and engage harshly, and it cites more than 60 technical service bulletins.

Technical service bulletins are repair instructions sent to dealers, and a count that high suggests a long-running effort to fix the same behavior. Buyers looking at used Silverados from these years should ask whether the transmission fluid has been replaced under GM’s updated procedures. A test drive should include light-throttle cruising.

3. GMC Sierra 1500: The Same Suit, the Same Complaints

GMC Sierra 1500 — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

The 2015 through 2019 GMC Sierra 1500 is named in the same eight-speed shudder lawsuit as its Chevrolet twin. The plaintiffs allege that GM knew about the problem since at least September 2014, before many of these trucks were sold.

The Sierra shares its 8L90 and 8L45 transmissions with the Silverado, so the alleged defects are the same. A shudder that feels like driving over rumble strips is the symptom owners most often describe, and it tends to appear at moderate speeds when the converter locks. A long test drive is the best way to feel it.

4. Chevrolet Colorado: A Six-Speed in Court

Chevrolet Colorado — Image Credit: Mr.choppers - CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Mr.choppers – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons

The 2015 through 2017 Chevrolet Colorado and GMC Canyon with the 6L50 six-speed automatic were the target of a lawsuit filed in August 2018. It accused the transmission of slipping, jerking, shuddering and shifting hard.

The Colorado’s return in 2015 brought the midsize pickup back into GM’s lineup, and many early trucks are now affordable used buys. Shoppers should take a long test drive with stops and starts, because harsh shifts often show up only once the transmission is fully warm. A pre-purchase inspection is worth the modest cost. It is money well spent.

5. Ram 2500: Overheating While Towing

Ram 2500 — Image Credit: Noah Wulf - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Noah Wulf – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

Ram 2500 heavy-duty trucks from 2019 through 2023 with the 68RFE automatic can overheat while towing, according to a roundup of pickup transmission problems. Recall 20V-043 in January 2020 covered 84,978 trucks, and a November 2022 recall covered 280,000 trucks with a warning to park outside.

A park-outside warning means the risk extends to fire, not just a failed transmission. Owners of affected heavy-duty Rams should confirm both recalls have been completed, especially if the truck is parked in an attached garage at night. Both campaigns are free repairs at Ram dealers.

6. Toyota Tundra: A Truck That Could Roll in Neutral

Toyota Tundra — Image Credit: Mr.choppers - CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Mr.choppers – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons

The 2022 through 2024 Toyota Tundra’s 10-speed automatic could let the truck roll while in Neutral, prompting recall 24V-125 in February 2024. That campaign covered 280,663 trucks and SUVs and was fixed with a software update.

A pickup rolling unexpectedly can strike people or property, particularly on a sloped driveway or boat ramp. The fix is quick, but owners should still use the parking brake on any incline, a habit that protects against many kinds of drivetrain failure. A VIN check confirms whether the update has been done. It takes seconds online.

7. Nissan Frontier: A Parking Pawl That Fails to Engage

Nissan Frontier — Image Credit: Charles from Port Chester, New York - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Charles from Port Chester, New York – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

Nissan’s 2020 through 2022 Frontier with the Jatco nine-speed automatic could suffer what the company called non-engagement of the parking pawl, letting trucks move while in Park. Recall 22V-671 in September 2022 grew to 203,223 vehicles, covering the Frontier and the larger Titan.

The parking pawl is the small metal pin that locks the transmission when the shifter is in Park. If it fails to engage, the truck can roll away with no one at the wheel, so Frontier owners should confirm the recall repair has been completed and use the parking brake as a backup.

8. Toyota Tacoma: Hesitation Before the Shift

Toyota Tacoma — Image Credit: Kevauto - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Kevauto – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

Owners of the 2016 Toyota Tacoma have posted hesitation and hard-shift complaints on CarComplaints, where 13 reports describe the problem at an average of just 6,650 miles. That is unusually early for a transmission concern on a Toyota truck.

Many early complaints about this generation focused on the six-speed automatic hunting for gears and hesitating before downshifts. Toyota addressed some of the behavior with software updates, so owners who notice it should ask a dealer whether their truck has received the latest calibration. A used-truck buyer should feel for it during a test drive.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.