A failing transmission can turn a reliable daily driver into a four-figure repair bill almost overnight. For some popular trucks, SUVs and cars, transmission trouble is the single biggest category of owner complaints on CarComplaints.com. Here are twelve models whose transmissions draw the most gripes, and the year the site rates worst for each.
Read next on Morning Overview: Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
1. Chevrolet Silverado 1500: Transmission Gripes Lead the List

Transmission problems are the top complaint category for the Chevrolet Silverado 1500, according to CarComplaints.com’s Silverado page, which rates 2017 as the worst model year. The single most-reported problem, though, is an air conditioning system that stopped working on the 2014 model.
Owners of this generation have described harsh or delayed shifts and shuddering from the automatic transmission. A full-size truck that tows and hauls puts extra strain on its gearbox, so service history matters. Buyers should ask when the transmission fluid was last changed.
2. Chevrolet Colorado: A Shudder at Speed

The Chevrolet Colorado’s top complaint category on CarComplaints.com is the transmission. The site’s Colorado page rates 2016 as the worst model year, and the most-reported problem is a shudder or vibration on the 2018 model.
Many owners traced the sensation to the eight-speed automatic used in some trucks, and GM issued service bulletins involving transmission fluid changes. The vibration can feel like driving over rumble strips. A long test drive at highway speeds is the best way to check for it.
3. Nissan Frontier: A Radiator That Ruins Transmissions

For the Nissan Frontier, transmission problems lead the complaint categories on CarComplaints.com, which rates 2005 as the worst model year. According to the Frontier page, the most-reported problem that year is a radiator that causes transmission failure.
A crack inside the radiator’s built-in transmission cooler can let coolant mix with transmission fluid, which can destroy the transmission. Owners nicknamed the result a strawberry milkshake because of the fluid’s pink, foamy look. Shoppers should confirm the radiator has been replaced.
4. Nissan Rogue: Losing Power on the Road

The Nissan Rogue’s leading complaint category on CarComplaints.com is the transmission, and the site’s Rogue page rates 2013 as the worst model year. The most-reported problem that year is a loss of acceleration.
Many of those complaints involve the continuously variable transmission, which can overheat or slip and leave a driver with little power. Nissan extended warranty coverage on CVTs in a number of models. Buyers should check whether any transmission work was done under warranty.
5. Hyundai Tucson: Hesitation From a Standstill

Transmission problems top the complaints for the Hyundai Tucson on CarComplaints.com, which rates 2017 as the worst model year. The Tucson page says the most-reported problem that year is hesitation when starting from a stop.
Some Tucson trims from that period used a seven-speed dual-clutch transmission, which owners said could lag when pulling away. That delay can be dangerous when turning across traffic. Hyundai issued software updates aimed at the issue, so shoppers should ask whether they were applied.
6. Jeep Cherokee: Rough Shifts From the Nine-Speed

For the Jeep Cherokee, transmission problems are the top complaint category on CarComplaints.com, which rates 2019 as the worst model year. According to the site’s Cherokee page, the most-reported problem is rough shifting on the 2014 model.
The Cherokee’s nine-speed automatic drew complaints about clunky shifts and odd gear selection, and it received several software updates over the years. The 2014 was the first year of the redesigned Cherokee. A test drive in stop-and-go traffic can reveal whether a particular example still shifts poorly.
7. Infiniti QX60: A Shuddering CVT

The Infiniti QX60’s top complaint category on CarComplaints.com is the transmission. The QX60 page rates 2014 as the worst model year, and the most-reported problem that year is transmission shudder.
The QX60 used a continuously variable transmission closely related to those in Nissan models, and owners reported shuddering at low speeds. For a luxury SUV, that kind of roughness is especially frustrating. Buyers should check service records for transmission repairs or software updates.
8. Nissan Pathfinder: Coolant Where It Should Not Be

For the Nissan Pathfinder, transmission problems lead the complaint list on CarComplaints.com, which rates 2005 as the worst model year. The site’s Pathfinder page says the most-reported problem is coolant leaking into the transmission on the 2005 model.
Like the Frontier of the same era, the Pathfinder used a radiator with an internal transmission cooler that could crack and mix fluids. Once contaminated, the transmission often needs replacement. Many owners swapped the radiator before trouble started, so ask for proof that was done.
9. Buick Enclave: Transmission Failure in the First Year

The Buick Enclave’s top complaint category on CarComplaints.com is the transmission, and the Enclave page rates 2008 as the worst model year. The most-reported problem that year is outright transmission failure.
The 2008 was the Enclave’s debut year, and it shared a six-speed automatic with GM’s other large crossovers of the time. Owners reported failures that required expensive repairs. Shoppers considering an early Enclave should ask whether the transmission has been rebuilt or replaced.
10. Honda Accord: A 2003 Transmission Problem

For the Honda Accord, transmission problems are the top complaint category on CarComplaints.com, which rates 2003 as the worst model year. According to the site’s Accord page, the most-reported specific problem is premature brake wear on the 2008 model.
The 2003 Accord, especially with the V6 engine, was known for automatic transmission failures. Honda extended warranty coverage for some models in that period. Buyers of an early 2000s Accord should look for receipts showing transmission work or a replacement unit.
11. Honda Civic: Failure in the Early 2000s

The Honda Civic’s top complaint category on CarComplaints.com is the transmission. The Civic page rates 2001 as the worst model year, and the most-reported problem that year is transmission failure.
The 2001 was the first year of a redesigned Civic, and its automatic transmission drew many complaints about slipping and failing. For a car many people buy for low running costs, a transmission replacement can be a major blow. Records of a replacement are worth asking about.
12. Ford Focus: A Key That Will Not Turn

For the Ford Focus, transmission problems are the top complaint category on CarComplaints.com, which rates 2014 as the worst model year. The site’s Focus page says the most-reported specific problem is a key that will not turn in the ignition on the 2003 model.
The later Focus used a dual-clutch automatic that drew widespread complaints about shuddering, slipping and hesitation, and it became the subject of lawsuits and extended warranties. The 2014 sits in the heart of that period. Shoppers should check whether the clutch has been replaced under warranty.
More from Morning Overview
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power