Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Some Honda engines won’t restart after stop/start shuts them off, and the feds are probing

A driver eases to a stop at a red light, the engine goes quiet the way it is designed to, and then nothing happens when the light turns green. More than 700 owners of recent Honda and Acura models have told federal regulators that exactly this kind of moment left them stuck in traffic.

Read next on Morning Overview: A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has now opened an investigation into the auto stop/start systems on 2024-2026 Honda Odyssey, Passport, Ridgeline and Pilot models and the Acura MDX, a group that adds up to over 1 million vehicles. The new probe sits on top of an older one, and the early signs are that the two problems are not the same.

A probe covering five nameplates and over 1 million vehicles

According to The Drive’s summary of the new NHTSA action, the investigation covers the 2024 through 2026 model years of four Honda nameplates plus Acura’s three-row MDX. The agency has logged 700 complaints from owners who say their engines did not fire back up in traffic after the system shut them off. Regulators were already examining earlier Honda vehicles with similar symptoms, but this newer group does not appear to share their root cause, and the repairs Honda developed for the older cars do not seem to apply.

The distinction matters for owners. A preliminary evaluation is the first formal stage of an NHTSA defect inquiry. It lets investigators gather complaint data, request information from the manufacturer and decide whether the evidence supports an escalation or a recall request. Nothing in the opening of a probe means a recall is certain, and no fix has been announced for the 2024-2026 vehicles.

The models named in the new probe are some of Honda’s highest-volume family vehicles. The Odyssey minivan, the Pilot and Passport SUVs and the Ridgeline pickup share Honda’s larger engine and transmission architecture, and the MDX is the Acura counterpart. A failure to restart is more than an inconvenience in vehicles that spend much of their lives in school pickup lines, suburban intersections and stop-and-go commutes.

Honda’s earlier stop/start trouble and the fixes that did not hold

Federal scrutiny of Honda’s Auto Idle Stop system goes back years. In 2022, NHTSA’s Office of Defects Investigation opened a probe into 2016-2019 Honda Pilots after 221 complaints, covering 194,731 vehicles with the 3.5-liter V6 and nine-speed automatic. Agency documents at the time described an “engine fails to restart on its own from a complete stop at a traffic light or road intersection.” Honda spokesperson Chris Martin said then that “Honda will cooperate with the NHTSA through the investigation process, and [it] will continue [its] own internal review of the available information.”

The inquiry kept widening. In March 2025, regulators upgraded it to an engineering analysis covering an estimated 2,209,466 Honda and Acura vehicles, after Honda service bulletins had pulled in the Passport, Ridgeline, Acura TLX and MDX. The ODI announcement said it had received at least 1,384 reports, including four incidents involving a crash or fire and two reports of injuries. It also said ODI “continues to receive complaints of the AIS failure to restart, with many complainants alleging the campaign countermeasures had been completed.”

Those countermeasures were extensive. The 2025 coverage of Honda’s service bulletins described a two-stage repair: a software update first, then, depending on model and year, replacement of the starter assembly and starter relays plus a valve adjustment, backed by a 10-year extended warranty on replaced parts. Owners reported that cars still failed to restart afterward.

The newer models arrived after that repair program was written. If the 2024-2026 failures have a different root cause, as early reporting on the new probe indicates, investigators will be starting from scratch rather than checking whether an existing fix was applied.

Why a stalled restart is a safety question, not a fuel-economy one

Stop/start exists to save fuel. The system shuts the engine off when the vehicle comes to a complete stop and restarts it when the driver releases the brake or presses the accelerator. Researchers at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, including Shean Huff and Stacy Davis, tested four vehicles with the feature on and off for the government’s fueleconomy.gov program and found that the benefit depends heavily on idle time: fuel economy improved 7.27% on the federal city test cycle and 26.4% on the stop-heavy New York City cycle.

The payoff is greatest in exactly the dense, slow traffic where a stalled vehicle is hardest to escape. A car that will not restart at a busy intersection leaves its occupants exposed to rear-end impacts and to cross traffic once the light changes. Some complainants in the earlier Honda probes said they needed a jump start before they could move again.

Most stop/start systems can be switched off with a button on the dashboard, though the setting usually resets each time the car is started. Owners of the affected Honda and Acura models can check whether a vehicle is covered by any open recall by entering its VIN with NHTSA or Honda, and the agency accepts new complaints that become part of the investigation file.

The open question is what is failing in the 2024-2026 vehicles. The earlier Honda cases pointed toward starters, relays and battery strain after repeated restarts. If the 700 complaints in the new probe trace to something else, the agency’s next filing should say what investigators believe it is, and whether Honda has agreed to act before a recall is requested.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.