Shoppers who skip the third row often want an SUV that simply keeps running without costly surprises. Two data sources, iSeeCars reliability scores and RepairPal annual repair costs, point to a consistent set of winners. Here are twelve five-seat models that earn strong marks for staying out of the shop.
Stay ahead on AI: Join 600,000+ professionals who read The Deep View, the daily newsletter that keeps you up to date with artificial intelligence.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Toyota Land Cruiser: Top Of The Class
iSeeCars’ five-seat ranking puts the Toyota Land Cruiser first for 2026 with an 8.7 out of 10, drawing on data from more than 312 million vehicles. No other two-row SUV in the study scored higher.
A score based on such a large pool of cars is hard to dismiss as a fluke. Land Cruiser buyers also tend to keep their trucks for a long time, which fits a reputation for durability. The ranking covers only two-row models, so three-row rivals are judged separately.
2. Honda HR-V: Subcompact Standout
The Honda HR-V is iSeeCars’ top subcompact, carrying an 8.4 reliability rating among the smallest SUVs on the market. It combines low entry cost with a record that beats many larger, pricier rivals.
Subcompact buyers are often first-time owners on tight budgets, so avoiding big repair bills matters more than for most. The HR-V’s score suggests that small size need not mean a compromise on dependability. As the subcompact leader, it sets the bar that other tiny SUVs are measured against.
3. Toyota 4Runner: Rugged And Reliable
The Toyota 4Runner earns an 8.1 out of 10 for reliability, placing fourth among all five-seat SUVs in iSeeCars’ dependability study. Its body-on-frame construction is a rarity in a field dominated by car-based crossovers.
That tough setup suits off-road use and towing, and the rating shows it has not come at the expense of longevity. Owners who want ruggedness without constant repairs have few better alternatives. Scores like these are statistical summaries, so an individual truck with poor maintenance can still disappoint.
4. Mazda CX-3: Mazda’s Small Contender
The Mazda CX-3 scored 8.1 in iSeeCars’ subcompact comparison, second only to the Honda HR-V among the smallest SUVs. Few rivals in the class manage to stay that close to the leader.
The pairing shows that the tiny-SUV segment offers more than one dependable choice. Shoppers who prefer sharper handling over cargo space can pick the Mazda without giving up much on reliability. The model remains a useful reference point for anyone comparing the smallest SUVs side by side.
5. Honda CR-V: Compact Crowd Favorite
The Honda CR-V is iSeeCars’ top small SUV, rated 8.0 out of 10. As one of the best-selling vehicles in its class, it has built a record that spans many owners and many years.
A high score among popular cars is especially meaningful, since a large sample leaves less room for luck. It also means parts and independent mechanics are easy to find when service is due. Anyone cross-shopping compact SUVs will likely meet it on the short list sooner or later.
6. Mazda CX-5: Midsize Cost Leader
RepairPal ranks the Mazda CX-5 first among midsize SUVs, with RepairPal’s midsize list showing average repairs of $447 a year against $573 for the class. That is a gap of well over a hundred dollars annually.
Over a decade of ownership, the savings can add up to a meaningful sum. The result also supports the idea that the CX-5 delivers a premium feel without a premium repair bill. Annual averages smooth out the occasional large repair, so they work best as a guide to typical costs.
7. Toyota Venza: Cheap To Fix
The Toyota Venza averages just $444 a year in repairs, according to RepairPal’s midsize ranking, which makes it even cheaper to keep than the leading CX-5. It also finishes ahead of the Hyundai in the same ranking.
Low annual costs reflect both fewer breakdowns and modest repair charges when something does go wrong. Buyers drawn to efficiency can treat the Venza as a practical pick as well. Its figure also lands under the CX-5, so the cheapest repair bills in this class belong to the Toyota.
8. Hyundai Santa Fe: Korean Runner-Up
The Hyundai Santa Fe ranks second on RepairPal’s midsize SUV list at $515 a year, according to RepairPal’s reliability data. That figure sits below the class average of $573 mentioned for the segment.
Hyundai’s rise in dependability rankings has been gradual, and this result adds to the case. Shoppers who value warranty coverage and feature content can find the Santa Fe is also affordable to maintain. Cost data of this kind complements the iSeeCars scores, since one measures failures and the other measures bills.
9. Subaru Outback: Wagon With Traction
The Subaru Outback earns a 7.9 iSeeCars rating, seventh among five-seat SUVs in the iSeeCars reliability list. The wagon-like body and standard all-wheel drive make it a favorite in snowy regions.
Many buyers assume that all-wheel drive means extra complexity and cost, yet this score argues otherwise. For practical drivers who want ground clearance and traction, the Outback is a reliable bet. A seventh-place finish still sits comfortably above many popular competitors in the broader five-seat field.
10. Jeep Wrangler: Trail Rated Dependability
The Jeep Wrangler is rated 7.7 for reliability, ahead of every other Jeep in the iSeeCars five-seat ranking. For a brand that often struggles in dependability surveys, it is a bright spot.
Its simple, trail-focused design may help, as fewer electronics leave fewer things to break. Buyers should still remember that the same rating places it below the leading Toyotas and Hondas. Even so, the figure is a reminder that reputation and measured reliability do not always line up.
11. Toyota RAV4: Under The Segment Average
The Toyota RAV4 costs around $429 a year to maintain, per SlashGear’s maintenance analysis built on RepairPal data, which is $92 below the $521 segment average. That makes it a standout for low running costs.
As another high-volume seller, the RAV4 benefits from abundant parts supply and widespread mechanic familiarity. The savings are modest each year, but they are steady and predictable over long ownership. For households choosing between compact SUVs, that kind of gap is worth a second look before signing.
12. Subaru Crosstrek: Segment Leader For Repairs
The Subaru Crosstrek costs about $492 a year to maintain according to RepairPal, and SlashGear’s cheap maintenance list says that ranks it first in its segment. It is a compact SUV with standard all-wheel drive.
A first-place finish in its segment shows that a capable drivetrain does not have to inflate upkeep. For buyers on a budget who still want weather confidence, the Crosstrek is a solid candidate. The result reinforces how competitive the small SUV class has become on ownership costs.
Stay ahead on AI: Subscribe to The Deep View →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
- Hybrids have 15% fewer problems than gas cars, while EVs and plug-in hybrids have about 80% more, Consumer Reports finds
- Regulators cleared the first U.S. small modular reactor, 4 months early
