Repair spending is one of the least predictable parts of owning a car, but RepairPal’s averages give a rough sense of what to expect. The models below all come in under $500 a year, spanning subcompacts, compacts and midsize sedans from Toyota, Honda, Mazda, Kia and Hyundai. Here are twelve cars, ranked from the lowest annual repair bill to the highest.
1. Toyota Yaris: Cheapest Repair Bill of the Bunch
The Yaris sets the low mark for this list at $333 a year, according to RepairPal’s Yaris comparison. That figure earns a 4.5 out of 5 rating, labeled Excellent, and the top spot among 21 subcompact cars. That figure is RepairPal’s estimate of average annual repair costs for the Yaris.
For a buyer shopping at the small end of the market, the number shows that a low purchase price does not have to be followed by a steady stream of shop invoices. Individual results still vary with age, mileage and driving conditions, so the average is a guide rather than a guarantee.
2. Toyota Corolla: A Compact Class Leader
RepairPal puts the Corolla at $362 a year in repairs, a 4.5 rating and first place among 36 compact cars, as FinanceBuzz reported. Only a 7% chance exists that any given repair is severe, which keeps the bigger-ticket surprises rare.
Winning a field of 36 competitors matters more than the dollar figure alone, because the compact segment is crowded with similarly priced alternatives. Owners who budget a few hundred dollars a year for repairs have a reasonable basis for it here, though the average still blends many model years together.
3. Honda Civic: Rarely in the Shop
The Civic averages $368 a year in repairs, lands third among 36 compact cars with a 4.5 rating, and visits a shop for unscheduled work only 0.2 times a year, per FinanceBuzz’s roundup of RepairPal data.
That visit rate works out to roughly one surprise trip every five years, which is the number commuters and delivery drivers tend to care about most. Missed workdays and loaner arrangements cost money that never appears in a repair bill, so a low frequency adds value beyond the annual dollar total.
4. Toyota Camry: Midsize Comfort, Small Repair Bills
RepairPal lists the Camry at $388 a year with a 4.0 rating, third among 24 midsize cars, as this FinanceBuzz list notes. That sits only a few dollars above the compact leaders, even though the car is larger and heavier.
Families who need rear-seat room and trunk space usually pay more to maintain a bigger sedan, so the small gap here is the selling point. The 4.0 score is a step below the 4.5 earned by several smaller cars on this list, which suggests the totals are low but not the absolute best.
5. Honda Fit: A Subcompact Runner-Up
The Fit averages $390 a year in repairs, holding a 4.5 Excellent rating and fourth place among 21 subcompacts, according to RepairPal’s side-by-side page. Only about $57 separates it from the Yaris at the top of that class.
Shoppers weighing the two small hatchbacks face a close contest on running costs, so cargo flexibility, condition and price are likelier tiebreakers than repair spending. With an average this low, a well-kept example should rarely become a financial burden.
6. Honda Accord: Midsize Winner at $400
RepairPal ranks the Accord first among 24 midsize cars at $400 a year, with a 4.5 rating, based on figures carried by FinanceBuzz. Its chance of a severe repair is 9%, higher than the Corolla’s 7% but still low.
Beating the Camry for the top midsize slot comes down to a $12 annual difference and a higher rating, so the two are close rivals. Anyone choosing between them can reasonably treat reliability as a draw and decide on ride, equipment and local dealer service.
7. Toyota Prius: Hybrid Without the Repair Penalty
The Prius averages $408 a year in repairs and carries a 4.0 out of 5 rating, placing tenth among 24 midsize cars, per RepairPal’s Prius page. A hybrid system might be expected to raise those costs, yet the average sits close to ordinary gasoline sedans.
The tenth-place rank shows how tight the midsize field is, since a few dollars separate many of its members. Buyers drawn by fuel savings can read the figure as evidence that the added hybrid hardware has not translated into outsized shop bills.
8. Mazda3: Sporty Feel, Modest Upkeep
RepairPal gives the Mazda3 an average of $433 a year in repairs and a 4.0 out of 5 rating, ninth among 36 compact cars, according to its Mazda3 comparison.
Ninth of 36 puts the car comfortably in the upper quarter of its class, even though it trails the Corolla and Civic by roughly $65 to $70 a year. Drivers who prefer sharper handling and a more upscale cabin are paying only a small premium in expected repairs, and the figure still falls well under $500.
9. Kia Rio: Few Trips to the Shop
The Rio averages $434 a year in repairs with a 4.5 Excellent rating, and RepairPal counts just 0.21 shop visits annually, as shown on its Rio versus Accent page.
That visit rate is nearly identical to the Civic’s 0.2, which means the cheap bill comes from rare breakdowns as much as from inexpensive parts. Budget-minded shoppers get a small sedan with a low purchase price and a reliability record that holds up beside far better-known nameplates.
10. Hyundai Accent: Close Behind Its Kia Cousin
RepairPal lists the Accent at $444 a year, a 4.5 Excellent rating and fifth among 21 subcompacts, with 0.21 shop visits annually, according to the same comparison page. Its numbers sit only $10 above the Rio.
The near tie makes sense for two related small cars, and it gives shoppers a clean choice between them based on price, styling or warranty terms instead of reliability. Both stay well under the $500 mark that defines this list, so neither demands a big repair cushion.
11. Kia Forte: Compact Reliability on a Budget
The Forte averages $451 a year in repairs and earns a 4.5 Excellent rating, sixth among 36 compacts, with only 0.19 shop visits annually, per RepairPal’s Forte comparison.
That 0.19 is the lowest visit rate among the cars on this list that report one, a useful sign for owners who value fewer interruptions over the smallest invoice. The cost is a bit higher than the Corolla’s, but the gap is under $100 a year.
12. Hyundai Elantra: Last on the List, Still Under $500
RepairPal puts the Elantra at $452 a year, a 4.5 Excellent rating and eighth place among 36 compact cars, as its Elantra versus Forte page shows. It finishes just a dollar behind its Kia cousin.
Sitting at the top of a list of cars under $500 is not much of a handicap, since the Elantra still beats most of the market by a wide margin. Shoppers can treat it as an equal of the Forte and choose between them on features, dealer proximity and the price negotiated.
More from Morning Overview
- Tropical Storm Rachel is dumping up to 12 inches on four Mexican states on its way to major hurricane strength
- The FTC says Lens.com doubled the price shoppers saw in Google ads
- Common allergy, bladder and sleep pills tied to sharply higher dementia odds
- NOAA now gives this winter a 75% chance of the strongest El Nino since 1950
