Some cars put their own drivers at far greater risk than others, even on the same American roads. Crash-data researchers at the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety and iSeeCars track that risk two different ways, yet small, underpowered cars and heavy-duty pickups keep topping both lists for opposite reasons. Here are ten vehicles with the highest death rates on the road.
1. Kia Rio: The Highest Driver Death Rate on Record
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety puts the Kia Rio at the top of its latest driver death rate report, with 170 deaths per million registered vehicle years, the highest figure recorded for any vehicle in the study.
Subcompact cars like the Rio carry less mass and crush space than larger models, and safety researchers have repeatedly linked that size disadvantage to sharply higher occupant fatality rates in real-world crashes. The driver death rate tracks fatalities among a vehicle’s own driver per million registered vehicle years, so a high number here reflects how poorly a car protects the person behind the wheel, not how it affects anyone else.
2. Nissan Versa: A Close Second in Driver Deaths
IIHS driver death data ranks the Nissan Versa second among all vehicles tested, at 164 deaths per million registered vehicle years, just behind the Kia Rio and still far above the average for small cars.
Like the Rio, the Versa is a lightweight subcompact built to a low price point, and the same physics that punish minicars in a crash apply almost as severely to this slightly larger small car. IIHS measures this rate per million registered vehicle years rather than per mile driven, so it reflects how the car performs across its whole ownership base, not just how far it is typically driven.
3. Ram 3500 (Crew Cab Long Bed 4WD): The Deadliest Vehicle for Everyone Else
Carscoops’ analysis of IIHS data found the Ram 3500 Crew Cab Long Bed 4WD poses little risk to its own driver but the highest other-driver death rate of any vehicle tracked, at 204 deaths per million registered vehicle years.
That figure measures harm to people the truck hits rather than its own occupants, and regulators point to sheer mass and height as the reason heavy-duty pickups routinely top this side of the death rate ranking. Other-driver death rate counts fatalities among occupants of the vehicles a given model collides with, so a low risk to the Ram’s own driver says nothing about the danger it poses to everyone sharing the road with it.
4. Hyundai Venue: The Top Fatal Accident Rate of Any Car
iSeeCars’ fatal accident study found the Hyundai Venue has the highest fatal accident rate of any vehicle on the road, at 13.9 fatal crashes per billion miles driven, nearly five times the national average.
The Venue is Hyundai’s smallest, lightest crossover, and its size tracks with the same pattern IIHS sees in minicars: less structure sits between occupants and the outside world when a crash happens. iSeeCars measures its rate per billion miles driven rather than per registered vehicle, a mileage-based approach distinct from IIHS’s method but aimed at the same underlying question of relative crash risk.
5. Chrysler 300 (2WD): A Large Car With a Small Car’s Risk
the IIHS report lists the Chrysler 300 2WD at 132 driver deaths per million registered vehicle years, among the highest rates of any large car IIHS tracks.
Unlike the minicars atop the list, the 300 is a full-size sedan with a powerful V8 option, and IIHS analysts note that horsepower and the driving style it attracts can outweigh a bigger car’s structural advantage. The rate measures deaths of the 300’s own driver, so its size does little to offset the risk once an aggressive driving style and a powerful engine enter the equation.
6. Chevrolet Corvette: High Horsepower, High Fatality Rate
iSeeCars’ crash rate data ties the Chevrolet Corvette for the second-highest fatal accident rate on the road, at 13.6 fatal crashes per billion miles driven, 4.8 times the national average.
As a two-seat sports car built around high performance, the Corvette draws driving behavior that researchers say pushes its fatal accident rate well above that of an ordinary passenger car. The mileage-based rate treats every billion miles the same regardless of how those miles are driven, so a car built and marketed for speed shows up starkly against family sedans covering mostly routine commutes.
7. Dodge Charger HEMI (2WD): Powerful Engine, Aggressive Drivers
IIHS’s crash data puts the Dodge Charger HEMI 2WD at 127 driver deaths per million registered vehicle years, and the agency explicitly ties the number to the car’s powerful engine.
IIHS researchers note that a muscle car’s horsepower tends to attract more aggressive drivers, a combination the agency says shows up consistently in death rates for HEMI-equipped Chargers and similar performance sedans. Because the rate counts only the Charger’s own driver, the number reflects choices made behind the wheel of this specific car as much as anything about the car itself.
8. Mitsubishi Mirage: Tied for the Second-Highest Fatal Rate
the iSeeCars study ties the Mitsubishi Mirage for the second-highest fatal accident rate in the country, at 13.6 fatal crashes per billion miles driven.
The Mirage is one of the least expensive, lightest new cars sold in the United States, and its minimal size again lines up with the same small-car vulnerability seen elsewhere on this list. Measured per billion miles rather than per registered vehicle, the figure puts the Mirage alongside far more powerful sports cars near the very top of iSeeCars’ ranking, even though its risk stems from the opposite end of the market.
9. Chevrolet Silverado 3500 (Crew Cab 4WD): Another Heavy-Duty Pickup That Endangers Others
Carscoops’ report on pickups cites IIHS data showing the Chevrolet Silverado 3500 Crew Cab 4WD posts 126 other-driver deaths per million registered vehicle years, one of the deadliest rates for people outside the truck.
As with the Ram 3500, the risk here runs the other direction: the Silverado’s own driver is relatively safe, but its size and weight raise the odds for whoever it collides with. The two heavy-duty trucks land near the top of the other-driver measure for the same structural reason, even though neither ranks among the riskiest vehicles for its own occupant.
10. Porsche 911: A Sports Car With Sobering Numbers
iSeeCars’ latest findings put the Porsche 911 at 13.2 fatal accidents per billion miles driven, 4.6 times the national average and among the highest rates of any sports car.
The 911 is built for speed and precise handling, and iSeeCars researchers say that combination, like the Corvette’s, correlates with driving behavior that raises fatal accident rates well above the norm. Rounding out the iSeeCars side of this list, the 911 shows the same pattern as the Corvette: a car engineered for performance posting a mileage-based fatality rate far above an ordinary commuter vehicle.
More from Morning Overview
- The NSA is again telling phone owners to switch off one location setting
- Supplements now rank as the fifth-leading cause of death from liver disease.
- Herbal supplements are landing Americans in the hospital with liver damage, doctors warn
- General Motors is switching on cameras that record inside your vehicle by update
