Skip to main content

Morning Overview

The Tesla Model Y finished dead last in Germany’s TÜV defect rankings

Germany’s mandatory roadworthiness inspection has a worst performer among two- to three-year-old cars, and it is a Tesla. The Tesla Model Y finished 109th of 109 models in the TÜV Report 2027, published on Nov. 18, with 18.5 percent of inspected cars showing significant or dangerous defects.

The age class average was 6.4 percent, so the Model Y failed at roughly three times the typical rate. Another way to put it: the best car in the class, the Mazda CX-60, was found with such defects in 2.3 percent of inspections.

Worn suspension joints and brake discs behind the 18.5 percent

The figures come from the TÜV Association’s press release on the report, which analyzed about 9.7 million passenger-car inspections carried out between July 1, 2025 and June 30, 2026, covering about 200 vehicle types. The Model Y’s rate, already the worst in its class a year earlier, rose 1.2 percentage points from the previous edition, and no model in its age class has recorded a higher defect rate since the 2015 report.

The faults are concentrated in two places. Worn load-bearing and guide joints in the axle suspension turned up 24 times more often than in comparison vehicles, and brake discs were defective in 3.4 percent of Model Ys against an age-class average of 1.0 percent, according to VISION mobility’s reading of the report. Front lighting also drew above-average complaints, though the MG4, one place above it, has an even larger brake-disc problem.

Mileage is a partial counterweight: the inspected Model Ys averaged 58,000 kilometers, against 47,000 for the comparison cars. TÜV itself says drive type alone does not explain defect rates, a point reported by GoingElectric, which also quotes the association on brakes: electric cars do much of their braking work through the motor, and the discs can corrode when they are rarely used.

A repeat finish, and a worsening one

This is the second year running at the bottom. The previous edition ranked the Model Y last of 110 models with a 17.3 percent defect rate, CleanTechnica reported in December 2025, and added that the report’s own caveats about mileage and maintenance mean the results are not an absolute assessment. Adding 1.2 points to that 17.3 percent gives this year’s 18.5.

The rest of the bottom three is also electric. The MG4, making its first appearance in the report, placed 108th at 16.0 percent, with faulty brake discs in 10.3 percent of cars against the 1.0 percent average. The Tesla Model 3 was 107th at 12.5 percent, and its numbers climb with age: 21.1 percent at the second inspection and 27.9 percent at the third, where it ranks last in its class.

The other end of the table

Electric cars are not uniformly weak. Twenty-six of the 109 models in the two- to three-year class are pure EVs, and four of them reach the top ten. The Mazda CX-60 leads at 2.3 percent, followed by the Mercedes GLA at 2.9 percent and the Mazda MX-30 e-Skyactiv at 3.0 percent; the Audi Q8 e-tron (3.2 percent), Mini Cooper SE (3.3 percent) and Mercedes EQA (3.5 percent) follow. Among four- to five-year-old electric cars, 12 of 18 models beat the 10.2 percent class average, with the Audi Q8 e-tron at 3.3 percent. Age is unkind to older electric designs, though: the Renault Zoe, at eight to nine years, reached 23.0 percent against a 17.4 percent average, with axle suspension and brakes as its common weak points.

Across all passenger cars, 20.9 percent carried significant or dangerous defects, down 0.6 points. Dr. Joachim Bühler, managing director of the TÜV Association, was not ready to call it progress: “Der leichte Rückgang der Mängelquote erscheint positiv, von einer Trendwende kann aber keine Rede sein,” meaning the slight drop looks positive but is no turnaround. The ADAC’s coverage adds that the average German car is now 10.9 years old, and that 38.7 percent of 20- to 21-year-old cars fail.

Inspections that look at the battery

For electric cars, the TÜV Association argues that the inspection itself is behind the technology. According to the association, the high-voltage battery is for now mostly inspected by eye. It wants tests of insulation resistance and potential equalization, uniform standards for judging battery health, checks of driver-assistance function and software configuration, and a digital record of each vehicle’s life.

The report does not say what Tesla thinks of the result, and the coverage read for this article carries no statement from the company. Matthias Moetsch, editor-in-chief of the AUTO BILD TÜV-Report, wrote in the release that a good first inspection result is only the start of what he called a successful TÜV career, and the Model 3’s climb from 12.5 to 27.9 percent over three inspections shows how fast a Tesla’s defect rate can rise as cars age. The report does not yet say whether the Model Y will follow the same path.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview


Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.