A burner that is running can look like one that is off. That is the finding from Adelaide University engineers who set out to learn why hydrogen flames, which are close to invisible on their own, sometimes show a faint orange glow and sometimes show almost nothing at all.
Over two weeks of measurements with the burner settings left alone, the sodium-related light from hydrogen flames varied by more than 28 times between its dimmest and brightest readings. The team’s conclusion, published in the journal Next Energy this month, is that judging by sight whether a hydrogen burner is lit “may be unreliable.”
Where the 28-fold swing came from
The work was led by Professor Paul Medwell of Adelaide University’s School of Electrical and Mechanical Engineering, with the University of New South Wales and Gas Infrastructure Research Australia, and was supported by the Future Fuels Cooperative Research Centre. The paper, “The role of sodium on hydrogen flame visibility in domestic settings”, lists Medwell, Jordan Kildare, Yilong Yin, Qing Chan, Michael Evans, Neil Smith, Peter Ashman and Douglas Proud as authors.
Pure hydrogen burns with very little visible light. What colour people do see usually comes from impurities, and the team traced much of it to sodium in the surrounding air, often from sea salt carried inland by wind, according to the ScienceDaily write-up of the university’s release. Air that had travelled over the ocean carried more sodium and produced a stronger orange glow. Air with little sodium produced a much fainter flame.
Funding came through the Future Fuels Cooperative Research Centre, which is supported by the Australian Government’s Cooperative Research Centres Program, and the paper appears as Next Energy 2026, volume 13, article 100962. Sodium was the variable the team isolated, which is why the sea-air comparison carries the study.
The group used controlled laboratory experiments and outdoor testing around Adelaide. Nothing about the burner changed during the two weeks; the weather and the air did.
Fainter than natural gas, even on a good day
The comparison with ordinary gas is what turns the finding into a household question. The university’s EurekAlert release says that even in conditions favourable to brighter flames, a hydrogen cooktop produced less visible light on average than a natural gas cooktop.
The faint blue and red emissions that hydrogen does give off were visible mostly in darkened surroundings, according to the Science Media Exchange summary of the study. In a lit kitchen, that leaves the cook with nothing dependable to look at.
The paper’s setting is domestic, and the release describes the aim as helping engineers design safer, more reliable home appliances. It does not say that any hydrogen burner in use has caused harm, and it does not address blending hydrogen into existing natural gas supplies. The household context it offers is that Australian Gas Infrastructure Group unveiled what it called Australia’s first 100 percent hydrogen-powered home in Victoria in 2023.
Medwell also framed the lesson as an engineering one. “Different energy sources have different properties,” he said, per the Science Media Exchange summary, and good design means building for those differences instead of assuming a new fuel behaves like the old one. In the Adelaide measurements, the brightness of the sodium-driven glow followed the sodium content of the air rather than anything the burner was doing.
The researchers’ answer to that variability is detection built into the appliance, not a better view of the flame.
Detectors instead of eyesight
Medwell’s team does not recommend abandoning hydrogen. “Hydrogen has significant potential as part of a lower-emissions energy future,” he said in the release, adding that the study does not diminish that potential. His recommendation is about design. Rather than relying on a flame looking a particular colour, engineers can investigate other ways of confirming that a burner is operating.
Those other ways, the researchers suggest, are specialised ultraviolet or infrared flame detectors and temperature sensors. A sensor that confirms combustion directly would not care whether sea air had made the flame glow orange that afternoon.
The study is also part of a longer line of work at Adelaide. CSIRO’s research directory records a Future Fuels CRC project at the University of Adelaide on hydrogen flame visibility, started in October 2023, which aims to clarify what affects how visible a hydrogen flame is in real-world settings and cites uncertainty around the safety implications of open-fired hydrogen flames used in industrial heat. That page reports no results of its own. An earlier project, Effects of dopants on hydrogen flames, started in February 2020 and asked whether doping hydrogen with higher-order hydrocarbons could improve visibility, radiation and odour.
The open question for appliance makers and standards bodies is which detector approach becomes the norm. The Next Energy paper points to ultraviolet, infrared and temperature sensing, and leaves the choice of standard to them.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
- Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say
- Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge