At 34,000 feet on the morning of May 25, 2024, the captain of Southwest Airlines flight 746 felt what he described as a small amount of Dutch roll, the tail-led wobble that pairs side-to-side yaw with rocking wings. The Boeing 737 MAX 8 was carrying 175 passengers and 6 crew from Phoenix to Oakland and landed normally, with no injuries. Two years and several months later, the National Transportation Safety Board published its final report on Nov. 5, 2026, and it points back to a thunderstorm nine days before the flight.
Read next on Morning Overview: Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record
The jet, registered N8825Q, had been parked overnight at New Orleans on May 16, 2024, when a squall line pushed gusts of about 73 knots, roughly 84 mph, across the airfield. Nobody in maintenance control was told. Over the next days the aircraft kept flying its normal schedule, and the first sign that anything had changed came only when the oscillation returned in cruise.
Gusts in New Orleans and a damaged standby rudder mount
Investigators concluded that the wind moved the rudder hard enough to damage structure at the base of the vertical fin, according to AeroCorner’s account of the NTSB report, filed under investigation number DCA24LA206. The trailing-edge ribs above and below the standby rudder power control unit were damaged, along with the unit’s forward support bracket, and one rib fractured with signs of overload. The NTSB classed the damage as substantial. It listed the probable cause as damage to the standby rudder power control unit’s connection to the vertical fin due to an extreme high wind event, as quoted in that account.
The rudder has no gust lock, and the standby unit lacks the damping the main unit provides, which is how a parked jet can have its tail forced around by wind. The same report, per AeroCorner, does not cite a design defect in the rudder system as a cause.
A hydraulic test signed off without anyone watching the tail
The storm damage should have been caught. The NTSB docket and its final report describe a chain of missed chances, which AirlineGeeks also summarized. The jet flew 44 times after the storm before flight 746, including 38 flights in the following week with no reported rudder or yaw damper trouble. On May 23, during a scheduled check at Houston Hobby, mechanics ran a standby hydraulic test and signed it off as passed, although hangar video showed the rudder moving right but not left. Nobody was positioned at the tail to verify the movement. The NTSB could not determine whether that test worsened the existing damage, AirlineGeeks reported.
On May 24 the crew disconnected a yaw damper they believed was overcorrecting. It was deferred and later cleared after a functional test. That detail matters because the flight data pointed at the wrong suspect: every oscillation occurred with the yaw damper engaged and none with it off, and after Houston the yaw damper’s commands had started moving the rudder pedals, which normal inputs do not do. AZFamily’s report on the findings added that the crew first suspected turbulence before the pedal movement ruled it out.
Rudder oscillations recorded in flight data were about 0.75 degrees, arriving in bursts of roughly 20 seconds, with no significant change in heading or bank. The autopilot stayed engaged, no warning lights came on, and the oscillations came back after the crew descended to 32,000 feet.
Boeing’s 75-mph inspection trigger and Southwest’s new work card
The NTSB named two gaps that, if closed, would likely have caught the damage before the flight. Boeing’s maintenance manual called for a special inspection after extreme wind but set no wind speed threshold. Southwest had no process to alert maintenance control when a parked aircraft was exposed to extreme gusts, so the jet flew the next morning with no inspection.
Both have since been changed, according to the report as summarized by AeroCorner. Boeing revised its 737 manual so the inspection triggers at 65 knots, or 75 mph; the New Orleans gusts were above that. Southwest swapped a one-line standby hydraulic test instruction for a step-by-step work card that each mechanic signs, and now notifies maintenance control when a parked aircraft sees extreme wind. After the incident the airline had also inspected the standby unit mounting areas across its 737 MAX fleet and found nothing similar. In 2024, the Dallas Morning News reported that Southwest checked its 231 MAX aircraft between June 17 and June 20 under the NTSB’s preliminary findings.
The timing of the damage was the missing piece in 2024. The agency’s preliminary findings, as the Dallas paper described them, said the tail damage adversely affects the structural strength of the fitting and is considered substantial, but investigators had not yet determined when it happened. The first officer on the flight told investigators of tail movement and rudder pedal movement, the details that later tied the episode to the standby unit.
The final report leaves one thing open by its own account: whether the Houston test, passed without a witness at the tail, made the existing damage worse. The NTSB could not say.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
- Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say
- Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge
- Winter weather advisories cover I-80, I-70 and the Bighorns with up to 15 inches of snow