Skip to main content

Morning Overview

19 luxury models whose owners report the most headaches

A luxury badge promises refinement, but it does not guarantee a trouble-free ownership experience. Owner reports on CarComplaints.com show premium brands dealing with leaking lights, oil-hungry engines, failing transmissions and costly electronics, sometimes at surprisingly low mileage. Here are nineteen luxury models whose owners report the most headaches, along with the years and problems behind them.

Read next on Morning Overview: New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25

1. Cadillac SRX: Water in the Lights

Cadillac SRX — Image Credit: IFCAR - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: IFCAR – Public domain/Wiki Commons

The Cadillac SRX’s CarComplaints.com page lists about 630 complaints, with 117 against the 2010 model, 91 against the 2011 and 86 against the 2012. Lights are its worst category, an unusual leader for a luxury crossover.

The 2010 is rated worst, with water getting into the lights averaging about $1,600 near 80,000 miles. Low beams that are too dim on the 2016 average about $1,900, and a CUE touch screen that stopped working on the 2015 about $1,200.

2. Acura TL: Oil Consumption in a Sport Sedan

Acura TL — Image Credit: Dennis G. Jarvis - CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Dennis G. Jarvis – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons

The Acura TL’s complaint file holds about 414 complaints, with 63 against the 2006 and 57 against the 2003, whose top problem was transmission failure. Transmission is the model’s worst category overall.

CarComplaints.com rates 2010 as the worst year, with excessive oil consumption averaging about $6,500 near 63,000 miles. Transmission failure on the 2003 averages about $2,800, and a cracked dashboard on the 2006 about $1,800.

3. Cadillac CTS: Timing Chains and Transfer Cases

Cadillac CTS — Image Credit: MercurySable99 - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: MercurySable99 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

The Cadillac CTS’s CarComplaints.com record lists about 316 complaints, led by 46 on the first-year 2003 and 37 on the 2009. Engine problems are its worst category.

The 2009 is rated worst, with timing chain failure averaging about $3,400 near 95,000 miles. A dead transfer case on the 2009 averages about $3,500 and transmission failure about $4,200, so that model year collects several expensive faults.

4. Audi A4: An Oil-Thirsty Audi

Audi A4 — Image Credit: Michael Gil from Calgary, AB, Canada - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Michael Gil from Calgary, AB, Canada – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

The Audi A4’s complaint page holds about 286 complaints, with 35 against the 2009 and 31 against the 2011. Excessive oil consumption was the 2009’s most-reported problem.

CarComplaints.com rates 2011 as the worst year, with excessive oil usage averaging about $6,000 near 65,000 miles. Engine failure on the 2013 averages about $8,800, and on the 2002 about $6,500. The 2013 drew 25 complaints, the third-highest count.

5. Acura RDX: Squealing Brakes

Acura RDX — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

The Acura RDX’s CarComplaints.com listing totals about 214 complaints, with 52 against the redesigned 2019. Brakes are its worst category.

The 2016 is rated worst, with brake squealing averaging about $300 near 13,000 miles. Cracked axles on the 2012 average about $3,000 near 35,000 miles, a more serious repair for owners of the earlier generation. The 2020 drew 21 complaints, and the 2016 another 20.

6. Lincoln MKZ: Chrome Peeling From the Wheels

Lincoln MKZ — Image Credit: SsmIntrigue - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: SsmIntrigue – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

The Lincoln MKZ’s complaint record lists about 240 complaints, with 52 on the 2007 and 51 on the 2008. The 2008’s top problem is chrome lifting off the wheels.

That fault averages about $1,200 near 62,000 miles. A 2007 report of the engine racing while the brakes failed to stop the car averages about $5,000, and interior accessories are the MKZ’s worst category.

7. Acura TSX: Power Steering Failures

Acura TSX — Image Credit: IFCAR - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: IFCAR – Public domain/Wiki Commons

The Acura TSX’s CarComplaints.com page holds about 166 complaints, with 35 on the 2010 and 34 on the 2009, both led by excessive oil consumption. Engine problems are its worst category.

CarComplaints.com rates 2012 as the worst year, with power steering failure averaging about $1,500 near 69,000 miles. Transmission failure on the 2004 averages about $3,000. Transmission work is the costliest item on its list.

8. Audi Q5: Oil Use and a Leaky Sunroof

Audi Q5 — Image Credit: OSX - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: OSX – Public domain/Wiki Commons

The Audi Q5’s complaint file lists about 225 complaints, with 54 against the 2014 and 46 against the 2012. Oil consumption dominates its record.

The 2014 is rated worst, with excessive oil consumption averaging about $3,200 near 70,000 miles, and the 2015 shows the same at about $2,400. A sunroof leak that damaged a comfort control module on the 2018 averages about $9,000.

9. Cadillac Escalade: A Loud Tapping Noise

Cadillac Escalade — Image Credit: Jones028 from Hong Kong - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Jones028 from Hong Kong – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

The Cadillac Escalade’s CarComplaints.com record totals about 120 complaints, with 22 each against the 2015 and 2016. Door handles that break off easily were the 2007’s most-reported problem.

CarComplaints.com rates 2015 as the worst year, with a loud tapping noise from the engine averaging about $3,400 near 90,000 miles. An extremely rough ride on the 2014 averages about $1,700. Transmission failure on the 2006 averages about $2,800.

10. Mini Cooper: Transmission Trouble in a Small Car

Mini Cooper — Image Credit: OSX - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: OSX – Public domain/Wiki Commons

The Mini Cooper’s complaint page holds about 117 complaints, with 20 on the 2005 and 19 on the 2006. Loss of power steering was the 2006’s most-reported issue.

The 2005 is rated worst, with transmission failure averaging about $5,000 near 113,000 miles. Water on the floor that shorted a wiring harness on the 2002 averages about $4,000 near 48,000 miles.

11. Audi A6: A Tiptronic That Failed

Audi A6 — Image Credit: Sfoskett~commonswiki - CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Sfoskett~commonswiki – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons

The Audi A6’s CarComplaints.com listing lists about 121 complaints, with 17 against the 2019, most often for alternator failure. Engine problems are its worst category.

CarComplaints.com rates 2000 as the worst year, with Tiptronic transmission failure averaging about $4,300 near 86,000 miles. An over-fueling injector on the 2013 averages about $4,700, and excessive oil consumption on the 2013 about $6,200.

12. Lincoln Navigator: Air Suspension Failures

Lincoln Navigator — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

The Lincoln Navigator’s complaint record holds about 130 complaints, with 22 on the 2004 and 20 on the 2006. Air suspension that stopped working is the 2004’s most-reported problem.

The 2004 is rated worst, with that failure averaging about $2,300 near 88,000 miles. A second air suspension entry on the 2004 averages about $3,800, and a 2018 headliner replacement about $30,000.

13. Lexus RX 350: Shift Lag and a Cracking Dash

Lexus RX 350 — Image Credit: Rutger van der Maar - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Rutger van der Maar – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

The Lexus RX 350’s CarComplaints.com page lists about 130 complaints, with 40 against the 2007, most often for a cracking dashboard. Interior accessories are its worst category.

CarComplaints.com rates 2008 as the worst year, with shift lag averaging about $5,000 near 89,000 miles. Engine failure on the 2009 averages about $10,000 near 52,000 miles. The 2008 drew 24 complaints, the second-most of any year.

14. Cadillac XT5: Worn Struts in Year One

Cadillac XT5 — Image Credit: Zytonits - CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Zytonits – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons

The Cadillac XT5’s complaint file holds about 61 complaints, and 47 of them target the first-year 2017. Squeaky brakes were the year’s most-reported issue.

The 2017 is rated worst, with front struts and shocks that went bad averaging about $1,500 near 28,000 miles. Tire complaints on the 2018 average about $1,100, and electrical problems are its worst category. No other year drew more than six.

15. BMW X3: A Broken Timing Chain Guide

BMW X3 — Image Credit: DariuszSankowski - CC0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: DariuszSankowski – CC0/Wiki Commons

The BMW X3’s CarComplaints.com record lists about 150 complaints, and 59 of them target the 2013. A broken timing chain guide is that year’s most-reported problem.

CarComplaints.com rates 2013 as the worst year, with that repair averaging about $9,000 near 83,000 miles. Engine failure on the 2013 averages about $4,500 at the same mileage. The 2005 drew just 10 complaints by comparison.

16. Cadillac ATS: A Frozen Screen

Cadillac ATS — Image Credit: Mr.choppers - CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Mr.choppers – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons

The Cadillac ATS’s complaint page holds about 90 complaints, spread almost evenly across the 2013, 2014 and 2015 models. Transmission shaking was the 2016’s most-reported issue.

The 2015 is rated worst, with a CUE infotainment system that froze averaging about $600 near 34,000 miles. Owners of a 2016 describe the car spinning out as if on ice, at about $3,500.

17. Porsche Cayenne: Brittle Coolant Lines

Porsche Cayenne — Image Credit: Sfoskett~commonswiki - CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Sfoskett~commonswiki – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wiki Commons

The Porsche Cayenne’s CarComplaints.com listing totals about 74 complaints, with 13 against the 2011 and 11 against the 2004. Engine problems are its worst category.

CarComplaints.com rates 2004 as the worst year, with plastic coolant lines that broke averaging about $3,500 near 56,000 miles. An engine that died on the 2011 averages about $1,100, and a resetting PCM on the 2016 about $3,000.

18. Volvo XC60: A Leaking Sunroof

Volvo XC60 — Image Credit: Calreyn88 - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Calreyn88 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

The Volvo XC60’s complaint record holds about 74 complaints, with 11 on the 2010, whose most-reported problem was fuel pump failure. Engine problems are its worst category.

The 2019 is rated worst, with sunroof leaks averaging about $5,000 near 15,000 miles. Oil consumption leading to piston replacement on the 2016 averages about $7,100. The 2015 drew nine complaints and the 2016 eight.

19. Infiniti G35: Brakes Worn by 10,000 Miles

Infiniti G35 — Image Credit: Kevauto - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Kevauto – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

The Infiniti G35’s CarComplaints.com page lists about 52 complaints, with 21 against the first-year 2003. A leaking steering rack was that year’s most-reported problem.

CarComplaints.com rates 2003 as the worst year, with brakes and rotors wearing prematurely at an average of about $3,400 near 10,000 miles. The leaking steering rack averages about $2,000. Transmission failure on the 2007 averages about $1,700.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.