Honda and Nissan sit near the top of many shopping lists, but their complaint histories are not identical, and some model years stand out for the wrong reasons. CarComplaints.com has logged thousands of owner reports on both brands, with transmissions a recurring theme. Here are twenty-six Honda and Nissan models with a trouble history to know before buying.
Read next on Morning Overview: Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say
1. Honda Accord: The Accord’s Transmission Years

The Honda Accord’s CarComplaints.com page lists roughly 12,900 owner complaints, with 2,496 against the 2008 sedan, mostly for premature brake wear, and 1,703 against the 2003. Transmission failure is its worst category.
CarComplaints.com rates 2003 as the worst year, with transmission failure averaging about $2,700 near 98,000 miles. The 2004 shows the same failure at about $2,900, so shoppers should ask for transmission records on those years.
2. Honda Civic: Transmissions in the Early 2000s

The Honda Civic’s complaint file holds about 6,990 complaints, led by 1,229 against the 2001 car. Transmission failure is the most-reported problem on that model year.
The 2001 is rated worst, with failures averaging about $2,300 near 105,000 miles, and the 2002 shows a nearly identical pattern. Clear coat peeling on the 2009 averages about $3,100, a costly cosmetic complaint.
3. Nissan Altima: CVT Shudder in the Midsize Sedan

The Nissan Altima’s CarComplaints.com record lists roughly 5,370 complaints, with 974 against the 2013, 657 against the 2009 and 624 against the 2002. A steering wheel lock failure was the 2009’s most-reported issue.
CarComplaints.com rates 2013 as the worst year, with CVT shuddering, vibration and hesitation averaging about $3,100 near 56,000 miles. The steering lock fault on the 2009 averages about $900.
4. Honda CR-V: Unwanted Acceleration and Gas in the Oil

The Honda CR-V’s complaint page holds about 3,780 complaints, with 419 each against the 2015 and 2017 models. The 2017’s top issue is a high oil level with gasoline mixing into the oil.
The 2011 is rated worst, with unwanted acceleration while braking averaging about $5,000 near 16,000 miles. Heat that does not work properly on the 2017 averages about $1,200.
5. Honda Odyssey: A Minivan Known for Transmissions

The Honda Odyssey’s CarComplaints.com listing totals about 2,960 complaints, led by 347 on the 2005, 299 on the 2006 and 280 on the 2007. Transmission trouble fills all three of its top problem slots.
CarComplaints.com rates 2002 as the worst year, with failures averaging about $3,400 near 98,000 miles. The 2003 and 2000 show the same failure at about $3,300 and $3,100.
6. Nissan Pathfinder: Coolant Where the Fluid Should Be

The Nissan Pathfinder’s complaint record lists about 2,190 complaints, with 677 against the 2005 model alone. Coolant leaking into the transmission is the defining failure.
The 2005 is rated worst, with that failure averaging about $3,900 near 102,000 miles. The 2006 shows the same problem at about $4,000, which is why radiator replacement records matter on these years. The 2007 model carries the same radiator-related failure at about $3,900.
7. Honda Pilot: First-Year Transmission Failures

The Honda Pilot’s CarComplaints.com page holds roughly 1,735 complaints, with 257 against the 2003 debut model, whose most-reported issue was an ignition switch problem. The 2016 follows with 208.
CarComplaints.com rates 2003 as the worst year, with transmission failure averaging about $3,400 near 123,000 miles. Excessive oil consumption on the 2009 and 2010 averages about $3,300 and $3,800. The 2005 drew the third-most complaints, with 145 reports.
8. Nissan Rogue: Losing Acceleration

The Nissan Rogue’s complaint file lists about 1,390 complaints, with 209 against the 2013 model and 169 against the 2015. Transmission is its worst category.
The 2013 is rated worst, with loss of acceleration averaging about $3,200 near 76,000 miles. The 2012 shows the same problem at about $4,700, and A/C and heater trouble on the 2015 averages about $2,200.
9. Nissan Xterra: The Radiator That Ruined Transmissions

The Nissan Xterra’s CarComplaints.com record totals about 1,080 complaints, with 410 against the 2005. Like its Frontier and Pathfinder cousins, its signature failure is a radiator leak that wrecked the transmission.
The 2005 is rated worst, with that failure averaging about $3,800 near 106,000 miles. The 2006 version averages about $3,900, so owners and shoppers should confirm the radiator has been replaced.
10. Nissan Sentra: CVT Failures in a Compact

The Nissan Sentra’s complaint page holds roughly 1,210 complaints, with 215 against the 2013 and 157 against the 2005, whose top problem was a blown head gasket.
CarComplaints.com rates 2015 as the worst year, with transmission failure averaging about $4,100 near 63,000 miles. The 2014 shows the same failure at about $3,600, while the 2005’s head gasket averages about $1,300.
11. Nissan Frontier: A Pickup With the Same Radiator Flaw

The Nissan Frontier’s CarComplaints.com listing lists about 1,070 complaints, concentrated in the 2005, 2006 and 2007 trucks. Each of those years is tied to radiator coolant destroying the transmission.
The 2005 is rated worst, with an average repair of about $3,700 near 103,000 miles. The 2006 version averages about $4,100, and the 2007 about $3,600. The 2005 truck drew 284 complaints on its own.
12. Nissan Maxima: Jerky Shifts on the Maxima

The Nissan Maxima’s complaint record totals roughly 1,430 complaints, with 357 against the 2004 and 273 against the 2005. Transmission complaints dominate those years.
CarComplaints.com rates 2004 as the worst year, with jerky shifting averaging about $2,500 near 107,000 miles. A transmission not working correctly on the 2005 averages about $3,000. Slipping and jerking on the 2006 averages about $3,500 near 114,000 miles, rounding out the top three.
13. Nissan Versa: Small Car, Big Transmission Bills

The Nissan Versa’s CarComplaints.com page holds about 885 complaints, led by 156 on the 2012 and 154 on the 2009. Transmission failures fill its top three problems.
The 2012 is rated worst, with failures averaging about $3,500 near 74,000 miles. The 2014 version averages about $3,400 and a 2013 transmission that stopped working about $3,800, steep relative to the car’s value.
14. Nissan Murano: Jerking in the Crossover

The Nissan Murano’s complaint file lists about 930 complaints, with 134 against the 2004, often for a broken door handle, and 132 against the 2009.
CarComplaints.com rates 2015 as the worst year, with jerking averaging about $6,500 near 21,000 miles. A soft brake pedal on the 2009 averages about $2,400, and paint chipping on the 2017 about $3,900. Transmission is its worst category on the site.
15. Nissan Quest: A Minivan That Jerks While Driving

The Nissan Quest’s CarComplaints.com record totals about 453 complaints, with 130 against the 2004 and 90 against the 2007. Transmission is its worst category.
The 2007 is rated worst, with jerking while driving averaging about $2,300 near 104,000 miles. A transmission failure on the 2012 averages about $4,500, which makes service records the key check. A 2006 transmission failure averages about $3,500 near 122,000 miles.
16. Honda Fit: Uncomfortable Seats Top the List

The Honda Fit’s complaint page holds about 560 complaints, and 167 of them target the 2015 model, whose most-reported problem is extremely uncomfortable seats. Interior issues are its worst category.
Its costlier entries are older: power steering failure on the 2007 averages about $700, and a spark plug that blew out of the cylinder head on the 2009 averages about $4,000.
17. Nissan Titan: Vibration From Day One

The Nissan Titan’s CarComplaints.com listing lists about 330 complaints, with 72 on the first-year 2004 truck. Drivetrain problems are its worst category.
CarComplaints.com rates 2018 as the worst year, with severe vibration at highway speeds reported from the start and averaging about $7,000. Rear axle failure on the 2005 averages about $3,100. Leaking rear axle seals on the 2006 average about $2,300 near 81,000 miles.
18. Honda Ridgeline: A Cylinder Gone Bad

The Honda Ridgeline’s complaint record holds roughly 365 complaints, with 92 on the 2006 debut truck and 71 on the redesigned 2017.
The 2006 is rated worst, with a failed No. 4 cylinder averaging about $2,900 near 107,000 miles. Fuel injector failure on the 2017 averages about $2,200, and an engine stall on the interstate in a 2022 averages about $7,600.
19. Nissan Armada: Brakes That Stop Working

The Nissan Armada’s CarComplaints.com page totals about 207 complaints, with 38 on the 2004 and 35 on the 2005. Brakes are its worst category, and an ABS light with grinding brakes was the 2005’s top complaint.
CarComplaints.com rates 2006 as the worst year, with a brake light coming on and brakes failing averaging about $2,500 near 105,000 miles. A fallen overhead console on the 2008 averages about $1,700.
20. Nissan Juke: Turbo and Transmission Trouble

The Nissan Juke’s complaint file lists about 192 complaints, spread almost evenly across 2011, 2012 and 2013. An engine that would not turn over was the 2012’s most-reported issue.
CarComplaints.com rates 2013 as the worst year, with transmission failure averaging about $4,000 near 59,000 miles. A turbocharger that stopped working on the 2013 averages about $2,400. A 2014 transmission failure averages about $3,500 near 83,000 miles.
21. Honda Insight: A Hybrid That Burned Oil

The Honda Insight’s CarComplaints.com record holds about 160 complaints, and 88 of them target the 2012. Excessive oil consumption fills all three of its top problem slots.
The 2012 is rated worst, with oil burning averaging about $2,000 near 64,000 miles. The 2013 version averages about $3,300 and the 2011 about $6,000. Owner reports drop off sharply after the 2013 model.
22. Honda Element: Gauge Needles That Fall Off

The Honda Element’s complaint page lists about 177 complaints across its 2003 to 2011 run, with 60 against the first-year model, often for keys that would not go into the door locks.
CarComplaints.com rates 2007 as the worst year, with gauge needles falling off averaging about $1,300 near 80,000 miles. The 2003’s door-lock key problem averages about $500. A key that would not go into the ignition on the 2003 averages about $600.
23. Nissan Cube: CVT Failures in a Boxy Hatch

The Nissan Cube’s CarComplaints.com listing totals about 117 complaints, with 51 against the 2010 and 40 against the 2009. CVT failure dominates its record.
The 2010 is rated worst, with CVT failure averaging about $4,900 near 81,000 miles. The 2012 version averages about $3,000, and a failed transmission on the 2011 about $3,800. Only 10 complaints were filed for the 2012 model.
24. Honda HR-V: Seats Owners Disliked

The Honda HR-V’s complaint record holds about 142 complaints, and 76 of them target the first-year 2016 model. Uncomfortable seats were its most-reported problem.
CarComplaints.com rates 2016 as the worst year. Its costliest listed entry is a 2016 that lost complete power when the transmission failed, averaging about $7,400 near 100,000 miles. The 2017 drew just 16 complaints by comparison.
25. Honda Passport: A Frame Rotted Through

The Honda Passport’s CarComplaints.com page lists about 86 complaints across the original Isuzu-built SUV and the revived model. Body and paint problems are its worst category.
CarComplaints.com rates 2001 as the worst year, with a frame rotted completely through in the back averaging about $1,000 near 107,000 miles. Transmission failure on the 1998 averages about $4,300. A 1999 transmission failure averages about $4,000 near 112,000 miles.
26. Honda Crosstour: Steering That Disappeared

The Honda Crosstour’s complaint file totals about 72 complaints across its 2012 to 2015 run under that name, with 27 on the 2013 and 26 on the 2012.
CarComplaints.com rates 2013 as the worst year, with a complete loss of steering averaging about $4,200 near 107,000 miles. Premature brake wear on the 2012 averages about $400 near 20,000 miles. Vibration on the 2012 averages about $800 near 59,000 miles.
More from Morning Overview
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die