In Austin, school district staff kept a running list. Nineteen times, a driverless Waymo rolled past one of the district’s school buses while its red lights were flashing and its stop arm was out, in one case moments after a student had crossed in front of the car and while the child was still in the road.
Read next on Morning Overview: Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge
Waymo promised a software fix last year. Now federal regulators say the violations largely continued after it, and they have opened a formal recall review covering 2,895 of the company’s robotaxis.
NHTSA’s recall query RQ26006
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration opened recall query RQ26006 covering 2,895 vehicles equipped with Waymo’s fifth-generation automated driving system, according to Reuters reporting published November 9. The agency said it is reviewing whether a software update Waymo implemented under a December 2025 recall “adequately addressed” a defect that could cause its vehicles to pass school buses displaying flashing red lights or extended stop arms after initially slowing or stopping.
A recall query is a step regulators take when they doubt an existing recall worked. In NHTSA’s opening resume for the query, published alongside Drive Tesla Canada’s report on the probe, the agency said the majority of identified school bus passing incidents occurred after November 17, 2025, the date by which Waymo said the remedy had been deployed to its fleet. The query will assess the adequacy of the remedy and determine the causes of the incidents that followed it.
The new review replaces a preliminary investigation that NHTSA opened in October 2025. In its closing summary for that probe, the agency said the continued incidents called into question the effectiveness of Waymo’s fix, which is why it moved straight into the recall query rather than ending its scrutiny.
The timeline is what makes the case unusual. Waymo filed its voluntary recall in December 2025 covering more than 3,000 vehicles, and told regulators the software update had been rolled out between November 5 and November 17, 2025, to make its cars slow down and stay stopped for buses showing red lights or an extended stop arm. NHTSA’s review of incident reports found the passing problem did not end on that date. A recall that was finished on paper, in other words, may not have changed what the cars did on the road during the school year that followed.
Nineteen violations in Austin and six in Atlanta
Most of the documented cases come from Texas. The Austin Independent School District documented 19 distinct violations, including the incident in which a driverless car briefly stopped and then proceeded while a student was crossing. Waymo was fined $300 for each offense, according to electrive. Public schools in Atlanta recorded at least six more violations.
Atlanta was where the problem first drew national attention. WXIA-TV aired video in September 2025 of a Waymo driving around a stopped school bus, and NHTSA’s original investigation cited “a media report involving a Waymo AV that failed to remain stopped when approaching a school bus that was stopped with its red lights flashing, stop arm deployed, and crossing control arm deployed,” NPR reported at the time. The Austin district’s letter to regulators, signed by its senior counsel, described Waymo vehicles passing its buses “illegally and dangerously.”
Passing a stopped school bus is illegal in every state because children often cross in front of the bus, where drivers in other lanes may not see them. For an automated system, the scenario combines several hard problems at once: recognizing a school bus from different angles, reading its stop arm and lights, and holding position for as long as the bus stays stopped rather than treating a pause as permission to proceed.
What Waymo says has changed
Waymo’s chief safety officer, Mauricio Peña, said last December that while the company was proud of its safety record, holding the highest safety standards means recognizing when the company’s behavior “should be better.” The company said at the time that it had identified a software issue that contributed to the incidents and believed its updates would fix the problem, and that no injuries had occurred.
In a statement this month, Waymo said its vehicles’ behavior around school buses had improved since March and that no further fines had been issued, electrive reported. The recall query will test that claim against the incident data NHTSA has collected.
The school bus review is one of several federal and state actions now pressing on the company. NHTSA and the National Transportation Safety Board are separately investigating a January 23 crash in which a Waymo struck a child near an elementary school in Santa Monica. And in California, the Department of Motor Vehicles ordered Waymo to pause freeway driving on November 11 after repeated construction-zone incidents, prompting the company to suspend highway service nationwide. If NHTSA concludes the 2025 remedy fell short, Waymo could be required to file a new recall with a different fix for its school bus behavior.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.
More from Morning Overview
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
- Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say